Watching last night, I don't believe Dyllan is anywhere the level he was attaining.
Whether it is the ACL tear (definitely lost pace) but his body language showed to me in pre and post game interviews he doesn't want to go anywhere. I think he sees Parra is home and whilst no one can complain for him taking the 13m, I wonder if he will ever be happy in the Knights wilderness.
I have always been a DB fan, but I also think we burn't him out in the last 2 seasons and confused his role in the process.
I now see DB as a 600pa player and if he maintained his original potential say 800k. i.e my implication is he has lost 25% as a player.
WE have most probably won the jackpot as I think we have seen the best of him whereas I question his future now. I would be surprised if he retains his NZ Test status when you look at the Warriors and their young half.
Watching his current game he is missing tackles, whereas previously he hardly missed a thing. He has also lost confidence in the line, doesn't know or understand his role by the rules that made him recognised in the first place.
We are very luckty and whilst it has been said repeatedly, I cannot believe how dumb the Knights are as he will never be the play maker they have signed for, O'Sullivan has a lot to answer for!
Replies
I love Dylan but it's not the end of the world his gone. If Galvin comes it's actually an upgrade but if he doesn't it will hurt us short term
A quick report on JF. It was meant to be a bye but they played their game against Manly that was postponed in rd 4. At HT Manly lead 10-6. Eels bombed 3 tries.
Eels have gone close a couple other times but Manly scrambled very well including right on HT. Both teams completiton rate has been poor.
Very interesting was LORENZO is listed at the utlity on the bench and has come on and played hooker.
The bench is all SG ball players. Lorenzo, Shane-Tapau, Funa-Luta and Summers
Eels ended up winning 24-16.
Whilst on the topic of juniors my nephew played on the wing for city U16 v country today and grabbed a couple of tries. He is a parra fan but contracted to penrith.
I was meant to watch the game but saw Hayden Bell was the only eels in the team so I decided to watch the JF game instead.
My sister said it was a boring game won 44-0
City will always smash country in these games. The blokes in the city team are from the country but the eligibility rules are just stupid.
I bet you're dirty on yourself now EA. Watching those errors we made was unbelievable. Still knowing you, your devotion to describing the game for us was paramount. As you say Twidle was outstanding.
Lorenzo at 9 is very interesting, should get him a few reps at lock could be our Walker replacement at 14
Good read, Pops.
Agree that DB doesn't look overly settled in his decision.
Also agree 100% with you that he is not, and likely wont be, a halfback. He is laid back, off the cuff, and that is fine, if you have Moses there to execute the game plan? We are seeing with Jahrome Luai in 2025 why genuine 5/8ths aren't automatic halfbacks.
DB as a player for us? 6 weeks ago, I would've agreed, but not so much in the past month, where I feel he's been one of our best with Mitch Moses back.
That has to be a massive concern for Newcastle, right? He relies heavily on his halfback, like Munster, like Luai, like Cody Walker.
Against the Fins, DB was literally involved in every attacking play - every line break, try etc. The way he created space by attacking the line & used his outside men, plus his support play was excellent, and that the player I am concerned we lose?
But no player is bigger than the club, and with the Eels defence improving & less reliance on our one cover defender of the past, im less worried defensively.
1.3m is crazy, we all agree on that, and next year he wont be able to just 'walk to the beat of his own drum', that coin brings expectation & pressure most players don't have to deal with?
Even us DB fans stood by the club in standing firm on the offer, and that hasn't changed, but who replaes him is still vital to becoming a contender again, or middle of the road, just opinion though.
Good stuff, Pops. Another good edition & merely mentioning DB on this site should increase the hits by 1million percent.