Player Ratings: Eels vs Warriors (Round 1)

An average of seven across the side reflects a strong team performance that the Eel's produced against the Warriors last week. I found cause to give eights to Hayne, Horo, Mannah and Moimoi, with Hindmarsh, Burt and Allgood not far away.
1. Jarryd Hayne 8 (8) 
I couldn’t have been more impressed with Jarryd. He produced exactly what I was hoping for - fewer touches, but still managed to lob up for a try and two assists. More so, it was a mature display. His kicking game was fabulous and he seemed switched on for the entire match. Hayne is in for a very big season.

2. Luke Burt 7 (7)
The consumate finisher, Burt constantly put himself in a position to take advantage of the bounce of the ball and did ok with his dummy half running as well.

3. Chris Walker 6 (6)
Not a high degree of involvement from Walker in either attack or defence, with the Kiwi’s targetting out other flank but he didn’t too much wrong either

4. Ryan Morgan 6 (6)
Not a bad debut at all. Had good involvement and despite being targeted by the Kiwis, he tackled well when in position to do so.

5. Etu Uaisele 6 (6)
Was always going to be the target of New Zealand’s attack and his opening tackle of Manu Vatuvai was incredibly brave, if somewhat clumsy. His running out of dummy half was good, though.

6. Daniel Mortimer 7 (7)
Run Daniel run. What a difference it was seeing Mortimer hit the ball on the run and taking the ball to the defence before passing. His kick for Hayne’s try was excellent and he linked well with Hayne for the second Burt try.

7. Jeff Robson 7 (7)
Got Parra off with the ideal start with a smart little run, taking advantage of a piece of sloppy Warriors defence. Did everything else that was expected of him, although I’m still hoping for his short kicking game to lift a notch.

8. Tim Mannah 8 (8)
How inspiration is it to see a prop hit up a ball twice in the same set of six. Mannah’s numbers say it all - 154 metres from 20 hitups, plus 21 tackles. Proved he is just as effective starting the match as he is off the bench.

9. Casey McGuire 7 (7)
Clever dummy half work added a new dimension to the Parramatta attack. A couple of errors in the mix but a very impressive start to his latest stint at Parramatta.

10. Mitchell Allgood 7 (7)
You probably couldn’t have hoped for a better debut from a young front-rower. Attacked the line with gusto and regularly got over the advantage line for more than an average of 8 metres per run. And no mistakes, either, showing he wasn’t overawed by the ocassion.

11. Nathan Hindmarsh 7 (7)
A nicely balanced effort, between defence and attack. Did plenty of tackling but left enough gas in the tank to make 17 hitups. Couple of uncharacteristic mistakes cost him an eight in my books, but a top captain’s knock regardless.

12. Taniela Lasalo 6 (6)
Hit the ball hard, without overly troubling the defence but his strong surge in the early minutes had the defence scrambling and helped open up space for Jeff Robson’s opening try.

13. Justin Horo 8 (8)
Horo is going to a star this season. He has a complete game. Strong, hard-running forward, who has skills and works equally as hard off-the-ball. Always round abouts the pill and leading the chase to kicks.

14. Matt Keating 6 (6)
Looked sharp at dummy half and was able to relieve McGuire without the side skipping a beat.

15. Shane Shackleton 7 (7)
I thought it was a strong effort from Shack, considering it was his first game for a year. Showed off his good footwork on a couple of occasions and did plenty of work for 15 hitups.

16. Fuifui Moimoi 8 (8)
Only played a bit more than half an hour, but he made an immediate difference when he came on. Made over 10 metres per hitup, which is something he probably does with more regularity than any other prop forward in the competition. Considering his lack of pre-season football it was a fantastic performance.

17. Ben Smith 5 (5)
Only made a few hit-ups on the time he got on the field and was over-shadowed a bit by other members of the pack.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • 1 Eyed would have to be Nostradamus to predict players ratings for round 2
  • Allgood was picked by Big League in the team of the round, impressive on debut
  • I would have given Mannah and Hayne 9s, maybe even Moimoi deserved a 9 too. Was a great performance from our forward pack. Team effort was excellent.
  • Highly impressive for a debutant
  • Good ratings 1eyed and i agree about Allgood,had a great debut.Does anyone know when he comes off contract?
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Mick aka Robin Hood replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Presser v Knights
"Minor hiccup but Jason's hard work is paying off now "
1 hour ago
Offside replied to LB's discussion Built in Parra: Lachlan Coinakis building towards NRL dream
"I think compared to the rubbish we've had since Reed Ryley is a breath of fresh air. I reckon a role as a 14 doing a bit in the middle isn't out of the question but for now I'm impressed with how hes travelling "
2 hours ago
Randy Handlinger replied to LB's discussion Built in Parra: Lachlan Coinakis building towards NRL dream
"How he has handled such a jump in class should not be under-rated....I am cheering for him"
6 hours ago
Randy Handlinger replied to Bert de Naturál✌️™'s discussion Perth Bears 🐻 ⚔️🧑🏼‍🦲
"Music...yes, no, sorta, always, but i am just not feeling it atm. I am doing fine, Randette is good. I have been feeling dark about the state of many folks psyche in the western world, and i could just not be fucked right now.....angry/protest music…"
6 hours ago
More…