Is Thurston really worth it?

http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,26655773-5018866,00.html

The Cowboys are set to offer Johnathan Thurston $700,000 a year over 3 years to try and keep him at the Cowboys.  Japanese Rugby has apparently offered him $1.1 mil per season. 
I really don't see the point in the Cowboys trying to keep him.  Granted, he is the current Australian half back, but for that kind of money they could buy 2-3 good players.  Since arriving at the Cowboys he has taken them to a Grand Final and won a stack of individual awards, but what have they really achieved with him there?  In 2009 the Cowboys were woeful and I'm not sure this year will be a whole lot better for them.
We showed last year that a 'budget' halves combination can be just as good, if not better than an all star combination if your team is playing well.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • yeh i agree it is alot of money for one player, plus the cowboys did have a very bad season but it is just not up to thurston to win a premiership every member of the team needs to step up and in the cowboys case many didnt. we know what its like look at inu one year has an awesome season the next an average one.
    Plus would our budget halves have been that good without our superstar hayne. every team needs a star we have hayne, mateo, storm has slater, inglis, broncos lockyer, the cowboys other than thurston and bowen when uninjured have no one. When thurston is playing for queensland, australia the cowboys have a very ordinary team where as for us when hayne is out we still have hindy,inu,mateo and now tahu.
  • yes he is worth 700 grand a year but doesnt mean he should have it, hayne is worth a million a year but cause hes passionate and not greedy he is taking half of that.
  • The cowboys can keep him at that price.....leave him there to climb palm trees with willie........we don't need the monkey man.....
    • haha
  • Interesting question Camo73 - "but what have they really achieved with him there?"
    I think the question should be what would they have achieved without him there? With Thurston playing, they are always a chance.
    As long as you have the right players around him, Yes, i believe he is worth $700K.
    • You won't have the right players around him if your sinking that much into one player. I can't see that he is worth that kind of money if you can't afford any other decent players.
  • He's a very very good player, but the Cowboys are wrong to simply put all the chips on Thurston and hope he can take them to a premiership alone and single-handedly.

    There's a difference between building a team around a star, and just having a star and a bunch of crap players around him.
  • He's worth it. Put it this way, if we had thurston last year we would have won the comp.
  • he hasn't won shit at the cowboys!
    he has a 15 minute man at the bulldogs when they won the title in 04!
    if thats his nrl highlight, hes not that good!
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"We are only now seeing some of the halves who were highly touted years ago start to come good after refining their game in reserve grade or struggling for years such as Tannah Boyd and Jake Clifford.  They still aren't great halves but are much more…"
2 hours ago
fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"Was Twidle debut as good as Fa'alogo for Melbourne.  Is he better prospect than Iongi who waited behind Edwards.  Players who wait and develop without rushing their debut, starting roles or big money early are seeing the benefit of it over young…"
2 hours ago
LB replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"Like Ethan Sanders, who after one game people were annointing breakout star of the year. Ever since Round 1 he had a good Round 2 and has been average since.
1 game does not make a player."
3 hours ago
The Captain replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"Control the narrative Pops. We knew we were going to debut Apa. We must have known for some time he was on the cusp. 
This reaction by his manager implies the narrative wasn't controlled. I guarantee a Politis would have already taken both Apa and…"
5 hours ago
More…