Replies

              • What the Tigers paid is now extremely good value for a State of Origin representative. We didn't have the necessary foresight and botched the negotiations. 

                • He's not an Origin rep. He's nowhere near it. Freddy stuck him in the squad because the Tigers didn't play on the weekend. It's how you slowly bring a young bloke into Origin. He'd be nowhere near playing. Freddy did the same with Campbell Graham for the first two games.

                  But a few weeks ago Stefano was dropped from a struggling Tigers side.

                   

                  • Semantics. Let me rephrase - he was named in the Origin 'squad' by better judges than you or I. 

                    • Yes based in potential. The club recognised his potential but weren't prepared to pay what the Tigers were prepared to pay, nor did we have a spot in our best 17 for him, unsurprisingly the Tigers did. 

                • There's never any guarantee with any young player. To say that the club didn't have the foresight to retain us revisionist bullshit at best. 
                  If guys like Gus can get it wrong from time to time, then don't tell me Utoikamanu was a lay down misere, cis it's just not true. 

                  • contracted for more than 300k without playing a minute for first grade?

                    if eels had signed him up to that then, there would have been a riot.

                    Utoikamanu or Kaufusi?

                    Think i know which one i would keep. 

                    • I would have liked to have kept both (certainly over a few others in the roster).

            • Yes, and we wanted to keep him, but he wanted more money than we were prepared to pay at the time. There's a shortage of talent in the league since less than half the clubs are developing, so the few that do are going to lose a few. 
              The Panthers have lost Burton, Naden, Aekins, CHN, just off the top of my head, and will lose more, but they're not gonna stop developing.

              Nor should we. 

    • This is the official off contract list:

      Cartwright
      Ferguson
      Hughes
      Lussick
      Oldfield
      Rankin
      Roache
      Smith
      Stone

      • Bryce Cartwright is the only 1st Grader we re-sign here.

        Top 30 contracts could be
        – Nathaniel Roache (hooker depth & development)
        – Will Smith (backline backup)
        – Rankin (half depth)

        We should be looking to sign Connor Watson for our full-time 14.
        It's a critical position these days and a position we're not utilizing more.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

The Captain replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"I really love what Ryles is attempting to do with culture and pathways, it's just a bit of a chicken and egg situation if we can't retain the talent.
To build culture you need tenure (people to stick around) and to have tenure you, by your metric…"
37 minutes ago
fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"We are only now seeing some of the halves who were highly touted years ago start to come good after refining their game in reserve grade or struggling for years such as Tannah Boyd and Jake Clifford.  They still aren't great halves but are much more…"
5 hours ago
fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"Was Twidle debut as good as Fa'alogo for Melbourne.  Is he better prospect than Iongi who waited behind Edwards.  Players who wait and develop without rushing their debut, starting roles or big money early are seeing the benefit of it over young…"
5 hours ago
LB replied to Joel K's discussion Bulldogs and Dolphins in talks with Apa Twidle
"Like Ethan Sanders, who after one game people were annointing breakout star of the year. Ever since Round 1 he had a good Round 2 and has been average since.
1 game does not make a player."
6 hours ago
More…