The 2018 debacle that is driving Arthur and the Eels

Parramatta and expectations haven't gone well together in recent decades.

Which begs the question: what will happen this year now the Eels are considered top-four contenders? Especially given their storming finish to last season, plus the addition of representative forwards Ryan Matterson and Reagan Campbell-Gillard.


Eels coach Brad Arthur has worked all summer to make sure his players are fit, but also ready to cope with the higher-than-usual hopes from one of the game's most passionate fan bases, sponsors and the media.

You only have to go back to 2018 when the Eels promised so much but finished with the wooden spoon. Arthur, like his players, was happy with their finish to the 2017 season when they won nine of their last 10 games and went within a couple of points of humbling the Storm in week one of the finals.

But the coach noticed something creeping into the playing group at the start of the following season. There was a blowout trial win over Newcastle in Maitland. Then there were players declaring in the media they could win the competition. Some even started to believe the hype and tried to squeeze the club for more money.

It all went wrong from there, the Eels lost 11 of their first 13 games of the 2018 season and finished last.


High-profile recruit Reagan Campbell-Gillard.Credit:Benjamin Cuevas

Arthur has good reason to believe things will be different this time around.

"There will be no excuses," he said. "It is up to us now. It will come down to our want and desire.


"I remember 2018: there was expectation and we simply didn't aim up. I'll bear the brunt of that.

"As a coach of this team and club, we've shown when we face adversity, like the salary cap dramas [of 2016], we rise and find that extra motivation. But now the challenge for us is on the back of a good season last season we need to be better again."

54703c21872f435b5cc415187ee2f81caba26dfc"Fullback and captain Clint Gutherson had a season to remember in 2019." />

Fullback and captain Clint Gutherson had a season to remember in 2019.Credit:Benjamin Cuevas

Arthur said he made the mistake in 2018 of giving his players only one trial match. The Eels ran out of steam against Penrith in round one, lost their first six games of the season and had their confidence shattered.

Clint Gutherson and Mitchell Moses had outstanding seasons last year. Both will push for NSW and Kangaroos honours. Arthur knows if they fire the Eels will fire.


Campbell-Gillard has done nothing but impress since shifting up the M4 Motorway from Penrith, as has Matterson who was involved in a messy off-season split from the Wests Tigers.

"Ryan has come home really," Arthur said. "He played his junior footy here. I'm sure that Tigers game will be built up when it comes around, but he's focused on training right now.

"He has strong beliefs about how he wants to be as a person and how wants the team to be seen, and he's not afraid to express it."

Andrew Johns could prove the Eels' trump card this campaign. The eighth Immortal was in Papua New Guinea this week, but returns next week and will continue to work with the halves and Eels players.

Johns has also proven vital for Arthur – the coach who guided the Eels through their salary-cap scandal and put up with a board that warred for years, not to mention the high-profile defections to rival codes of Jarryd Hayne and Semi Radradra.


In fact, when you tell Arthur he once looked like the kind of guy who would bark at his own shadow, he smiles and says: "In six years I've made a shitload of mistakes, but I'd like to think I haven't made the same mistake too many times over.


"I'm sure I won't make the same couple of judgment errors I made in 2018. I've learned I have to deal with everyone differently. I've learned how to deal with the media.

"I have the trust and comfort in the playing group that they can hold each other accountable rather than me being the one with the big stick all the time.

"I want to be a career coach. I love this club and playing group. We have an opportunity and we need to do something about it. It's as simple as that."

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –


    • 8 years? Where did 2020 and 2021 go Frank? He starting as head coach in 2014.

      • Ok slight exaggeration but if you count his tenure as assistant also it is 8 years.

        Point still stands, deliver or be gone - he's had long enough by the end of his current contract

    •  Frank The Tank : You will not be thought well of mentioning the reality of Arthur--8years and nothing and they want more! God help us. There is only one prize in the league and that is to win the premiership--as you correctly mention. Arthurs score in that is a big fat nothing and he has had 7 or 8 years doIng it!

  • He's definitey right, unless there is a calamitous injury crisis, there are no excuses this year. Everything has come together now. For me it's the Top 4 or his number will have to be called. I can live with not winning the title this year specifically, but to give ourselves the best chance we need to be top 4 bare arse minimum, preferably top 2, and we should be with this roster


    • Major prelim should be the minimum.

      • No, the minimum should be the level you've reached before, ie: top 4. I mean if we are talking about BA's job being on the line. If he gets us to the Top 4 this year, his job would, and should be safe.

        • Even if he loses both semis? Sorry I disagree 

          • Well that would depend on how we lost those two games. If we lost them the way we lost to Melbourne last year, then yeah maybe, but if we lost them the way we lost to them in 2017, then you couldn't fire him on those terms. We were a fanny hair away from winning that prelim semi in 17. We stuck it to the Storm pretty solidly that day.

  • Top 4 has to be the goal this year, and we have to be tougher in the grind and when things go against us.


    We made great strides last year but in that Storm Semi we are still not up to those top few teams just yet.  Hopefully RCG and Matto can make a big difference.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

EelsAgeMe replied to Old School Eel's discussion Erin Molan’s Broncos Boo Fu**ing Hoo
"Ironically the most shit that gets thrown at Parra happens right here on this blog. What point are you making?
6 minutes ago
Tin Tim replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Field out tomorrow & RCG rested.
"Happy to see RCG rested, I thought he was a little flat the last two games. I worry how slow Taka is, he is good with the ball in his hand but very slow. "
9 minutes ago
Offside replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Field out tomorrow & RCG rested.
"Field is dropped he's done ok defense has been surprisingly good but as a half he hasn't locked down the spot he has no kicking game and I think we play to flat for his type of running game. Field may come back in but it's worth seeing if takka can…"
13 minutes ago
"I enjoyed this & I was wondering what would be said about this game. Lol "
14 minutes ago