This is the exact signing Parra would chase.
You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"Axel, one of the best replies on this site. Sick and tired of all the 'agony aunts' on here complaining about this and that. Looks like angst lives rent-free in their brains."
"I mean we are all guilty of it at some points. I have been in the past. But it is just annoying to be fair that there is no in between. If the team is good it's "Premiers or nothing" or slightly bad "We are spooners for the next decade" all because…"
"I think his family were caught up in the NSW floods so he went home to help out
"
"
"Samrani has shown it isn't always the young players with massive hype that will succeed at NRL level. Didn't have the wraps some other players have but there is a reason he was given an opportunity and has grabbed it.
Doesn't matter if a back…"
Doesn't matter if a back…"
Replies
You yell sign a player. I agree, however you cannot just sign anybody. We did sign a player in Edwards and Su'A, but that doesn't answer the SIGN A PLAYER claim?. I know Edwards is not a big name as that is what you want.
There are some decent names out there who are either available or could be available; Jenkins, Timoko, Tago, Xerri, Burton, Leniu. I mean getting say two of them is not bad business. I reckon we get one at least.
As for Dearden, it depends on how much he wants. He was the starting 7 for QLD and if not injury he would be the incumbent. Now we have Moses on $1.3m at the moment. What would Dearden cost? Roughly the same? Question is with so many needs in this team, particularly in the backs where we could need 3 starting quality backs and a quality forward, how much are we willing to spend on a 5/8? Burton, if we see him as a 5/8, at least would be slightly cheaper. But do we break out bank for Dearden, have nearly $3 mil of our cap on our halves and the rest could fall by the way side around them?
If we had some talented backs coming through, i could argue you can do that as they would be cheap and the halves make them even better. But we don't therefore to be somewhat competitive we need to spend on the market and need money to do so.
I would much rather for example get Jenkins, Tago and Leniu. Instead of just going Dearden and maybe get Jenkins. The latter is still not a bad haul but our back 5 is still roughly the same with just Jenkins and still need a quality middle.
Let's say we did sign Dearden and could only get Tago with Penrith pitching in, i would be fine with it of course. But getting 3-4 signings would be better. For what i would cost to get Dearden you could get Jenkins, Tago and some of Leniu's contract all in one go. Think about it. Is it really clueless or more so priorities? As i would not go for Dearden as he would cost $200-300k more than Burton at this stage and that money can be used for more crucial areas.
If you for example land the three i just mentioned, you could get away with Volkman at 6 and be competitive.
Sad to say it we'll be wooden spooners for a long time. Nothing seems to be happening at the club.
Parrafan how can you go from positive and i can feel we will get Burton, to just saying "we will be spooners for a long time" simply by a rumour of Dearden going to Souths. Like seriously some people. I would argue heavily backs are more crucial for us to address before 5/8. There are still some quality backs on the market. Now if they are off the market and none sign for us, then the panic button can be pushed.
I mean you said a few weeks ago you are 100% certain we get Burton. Well ok, if we have Burton like you think, why do we need Dearden? Why is it we are now spooners for not getting him, we have Burton?
The bipolar reaction of some people on here is ridiculous. I know it sucks but maybe wait til November the latest and see what we have. They could have 0 signings and we can be worried or they could have 2 done and another nearly ready to go. Plus as well, after the GF teams begin to cut dead wood to extend their current players. Players pop up and are available when you think they aren't. Not saying we should have to wait as we should have had players signed that we chased, but it is what it is.
Plus those saying 'SIGN A PLAYER' well we did. Two actually. Su'A and Edwards. You do not stipulate the quality just simply sign a player, any player it seems.
The bipolar reactions on the site are hilarious LB. One of the reasons I don't respond as often but they do provide some comical relief to lighten the day after a loss; or a win!
You're right Axel, it's fucking hilarious.
I mean we are all guilty of it at some points. I have been in the past. But it is just annoying to be fair that there is no in between. If the team is good it's "Premiers or nothing" or slightly bad "We are spooners for the next decade" all because of a rumour from a site that has poor strike rate, in a position that is of need but way less than our back 5.
We would sign Dearden, break the bank. Then people complain "Where did all the money go?"
Axel, one of the best replies on this site. Sick and tired of all the 'agony aunts' on here complaining about this and that. Looks like angst lives rent-free in their brains.
No
Nostradamus never gets it right.
Please, no more washed up Saints.
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
of 8 Next