- Iongi - Had a good game. Still work to do on his game overall but that is expected for someone his age. Should have had that try assist if Samrani was not in the way.
- Lomax - Did his job. Needs to stop slipping lol. Backed up well. Unfortunately he did not have much support in yardage.
- Samrani - As you can see he is a backrower. To slow in attack and defence for centre. Penisni will be back next week so I expect he will either go to reserve grade or bench. The first try his read and speed cost him.
- Russel - No consistency with his catch and pass. He needs to work on it much more. Barely any yardage meters.
- JAC - Poor error at the end of the game as he did not trust Russel. Great diving try. Poor yardage game.
- Brown - Felt like he had to run the attack by himself tonight. His reads on kicks and effort to get back into play was tremendous multiple times. Did well in both eels tries in running at speed to draw defenders. I felt in the first half he had another chance to create a chance of an offload but he passed way to early.
- Moses- He was definitely not full fit. His job today was just to kick and be an onfield coach. Rather Hawkins play rather than Moses back up from origin if that is the performance we get. Cleary cooked Moses today.
- Paulo - Ran hard. Could not get as many offloads out today. Saw Panthers really focus on him since he is the only big bopper in the side.
- Smith - probably his best game for us. Tackled everything and was everywhere. Certainly think he deserve to be our 9 for now rather than going to the market. Saw his running game too when given a chance.
- Moretti - Was solid but again was well contained by Panthers intensity.
- Williams - Was very strogn again. Came so close to scoring. Made the poor error in the first half though.
- Kautoga - Being his first year, you have to expect a sub standard game after a few good weeks. His catch and pass today was shit.
- Hopgood - Any more errors in the game? Like fmd man stop ball playing and just ran and tackle hard as a forward. Let Walker and others do the ball playing.
- Walker - Very limited ball playing today. No short passes with his forwards today which probably made it harder for eels to make yardage and generate quick play the balls. Gave a dumb penalty.
- Tuilagi - Ran hard at the Panthers but struggled to make the impact. His defence was fine from memory
- Matto - Did his job.
- Papalii - Probably not the best time for him to come on when we were getting dominated in the ruck and defending our line.
For me the main focus this weak is talking about the teams perforamnce rather than an individual. But before I say much, everyone has to realise Penrith were on tonight. They were desperate to win.
Defence:
We definitely look more solid defending our own line. The first try was caused by a poor defensive read rather than a poor system. The second try Lomax slipped. The last try I just applaud the play making off Cleary. However I was not impressed with our ruck control espicially in the second half. Panthers outside backs were making way to many meters in their yardage work. We struggling to contain them. Its what Panthers did so well in their sucess. Something we really need to continue to work on. Penisni will come in for Samrani against Dogs. Hopefully he plays to the defensive system.
Attack:
We need to be more clinical. Williams so close to scoring. Samrani getting it the way off a pass. Brown passing early to Kautoga who could not find the line. Panthers scrambled well but if we were more clinical we should have got a couple more tries for sure. Decent considering Moses was no where in attack.
We really missed the work of Penisni and Simmo in yardage today. Samrani and Russel were getting belted and its not JAC strong suit. We could barely make any meters today from yardage. Panthers will do that to you if you do not have the cattle. So we got exposed. Iongi, Simmo, Penisini and Lomax is great yardage at full strength. As long as Penisni does not drop the ball or make horrendous reads lol.
We have failed to score of one of our biggest assets this season. Lomax in the air. We have completely struggled with any attacking kicks for him. He is obviously on the tip sheet for every opponent so they try put blockers in front of his run. But still we need a plan around that and kicks that give him the chance to compete properly. Too often the kicks have been to deep for him to reach or too shallow. JR and the attack coach need a better plan around Momax combo. Even bomb in the middle off the field for him.
The second thing we are yet to take advtange of is JAC speed. Put a fucking grubber into the ingoal for him please. To'o was jamming all game yet we did not one kick behind him. We really need to implement this in our game because we never do it. Our catch and pass needs a massive work on to as so many chaaces JAC would have been away if it was excuted well.
Lineup:
We need another big bopper in the middle to help Paulo. Panthers were coming out and trying to smash us and we did not have the cattle to match it in the middle. Tuivita would be a massive help when is back. But still Payne Haas or Tino. I wont be picky. Just one of them please. lol. Tino would have been coached by JR at storm. I recon Haas stays at broncos. We did not use Papalii at a good time. To be fair Smith was playing great But we brought Papalii on and when we were defending and had no field position. Do not want him at 9 during those times.
Replies
Maybe they're Moses traits and not BA traits ? He's the common theme across 3 coaches now. Maybe we need a decent halves coach to change his game up a bit. He plays a very structured and predicable game , and when our arses are stapled to the wall he becomes quite impotent. Smart opposition account for him quite easily , hence his flat track bully tag.
My ball sack man of the match.
Long- shit(the Melbourne back up scored 2 tries, winger-addi car or Carr-dod shit, centres- let's just have 11 players on the field save some wages, the other winger-How do you be man of the match for NSW but gassed after 20 mins maybe a KP prime decision needed to be made, DB- cmon let's not imagine he's capable still the worst 5/8 bar Crossland when picked, forwards the Italian stallion is a weapon the rest are absolute shitte.. DWalker geez can't pass left to right needs to flip his body like a blow up doll to pass but let's pretend we played the team that have won the last 4 or 5 years woohoo lost by 8 points! Team coming last.
Edit had some 12 percent Woodstock stress relief!
Merkin, you speak like you have some authority or even knowledge.
BUT time and time again you show you are a total fcukwit!........if you found a bar of gold, I would bet when you melt it down it will turn to shit!......
Great effort EA, really like this blog, and I hope you can do more of them. Totally agree with most of your ratings. Definitely need to sign another centre and prop and of course a 6.
Was proud of the overall effort and the improvements in learning the new defensive structures implemented by Ryles which has been very good of late
Defensively I'm pretty sure we've averaged under 20 points in the last 5 or 6 games which is a big improvement
I can understand why Ryles chose to have cover for Smith, he has been playing a lot of 80min football lately. But why not for a short period just have Hopgood go there and put Doorey or Guymer through the middle off the bench for a short spell? Or worst case just name Hands or Lussick there for a straight swap. Just for a couple weeks.
I don't believe he was there specifically for Smith LB. Circumstances being what they were, that was his punt at the end, probably wrong, Joash had no desire to get into the front line defensively, he should have been a terrior chasing their ankles and upsetting them that way. Standing back he will be walked over. Actually showed me he "will not be suitable for 5/8". A 5/8 still needs to be in the front of the action, as does a hooker. I Think Ryles took the punt taking Smith off for reasons I understand. He needed a game breaker, on this occasion it wasn't to be.
Talented kid but I suspect back up fullback will be his position. Whilst he is agile and nippy, he hasn't got the explosive pace to do what say the Canberra kid did yesterday.
Good honest review EA, I thought it was a good solid even game, the difference being the halves. Cleary showed why his the best, every where trying things where Moses was the conducter but offered nothing else, when he finally tried when too late they where selfish plays that just wasted our hopes and nothing plays.
Overall agree man. I won't mind a forward but I think Ryles will continue with Tuivati. I don't think he was Paulo, Tuivati and a Haas all in the 17. 2 big poppers is all he wants and I am with it, it's the game he wants.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 5 Next