Updated about 3 hours ago

Queensland billionaire property tycoon John Van Lieshout stands outside a mansion.
 

A self-made billionaire, who is one of Australia's biggest private landlords, has defended asking some of his commercial tenants to keep paying rent, saying he should not be made a "scapegoat" for the coronavirus-driven economic crisis if those tenants have been successful.

Key points:

  • Billionaire John Van Lieshout has asked business tenants to pay rent until the Government details plans to help them
  • Mr Van Lieshout says successful tenants should "first use some of their own capital" but will offer relief to some in distress
  • Some businesses say it is unfair to be charged rent when the Government shut down much of their business

 

John Van Lieshout has declined to extend rent relief to all businesses across his $1 billion-plus property portfolio.

Commercial landlords will be banned from evicting their tenants after the national cabinet on Sunday announced a six-month moratorium.

Mr Van Lieshout said he was considering requests for rent relief but would not commit until he knew what the Government was doing.

His company has asked tenants to detail any government assistance they will receive, which after yesterday's Federal Government announcement could now include wage relief of $1,500 a fortnight per employee.

But he said he would help those in distress, depending on their size and length of time trading.

"I've got some tenants that have only started you know, a beauty salon for 12 months," Mr Van Lieshout said.

"Some of those people I'm going to be very kind to because I know that they cannot possibly [pay] because the Government's closed it down completely.

"But the burden of this should be also accepted by the tenants themselves that have run successful businesses for many years."

Arif Memis, owner of Cowch Dessert Cocktail Bar in South Brisbane, was told by Mr Van Lieshout's company that rent was due despite his trade being "decimated" by the ban on restaurant dining.

"I don't understand what planet he lives on," Mr Memis said.

 

Mr Van Lieshout, the former owner of Super Amart, was ranked this year by The Australian as the 35th richest person in the country with a $2.4 billion fortune.

The 74-year-old told the ABC he believed businessowners had a "moral obligation" to reach into their own pockets first before turning to landlords given that "a lot of these tenants — I know for a fact — are wealthy people".

Mr Van Lieshout said he knew it was a tough argument to make amid perceptions that "landlords are all bastards, they're terrible people, they are capitalists and they should pay".

"But the thing is, take a tenant that has a good business that's been in business for 10 or 15 years, say he has a holiday home, he drives a nice Mercedes, and he has money in the bank," he said.

"This [the coronavirus pandemic] happens suddenly — I think he has a moral obligation first to use some of his own capital.

"He might be paying $100,000-a-year rent and for three months, a quarter, he has to dip in his pocket for $25,000 of his own money instead of coming to me and saying, 'How about you put up this money for me?'

"Why is it that people look at landlords and say, 'Well landlords, you cop it'. If these people sack their staff and don't pay any rent, they're almost off scot-free."

 

Empathy 'required'

Commercial lawyers say it comes amid a wave of disputes brewing between landlords and business tenants facing wipe-out across Australia.

Some large institutional landlords have been pro-actively extending rent holidays.

An email from the centre manager, State Government-owned QIC (Queensland Investment Corporation), told retail tenants on March 27 "you may defer your upcoming April rent payment until 30 April".

Ange Kondos, managing director of retail lease consultants LeaseWise, said some private landlords such as Mr Van Lieshout had not "shown the empathy that's required".

"I think the conduct of this particular landlord is abhorrent," Mr Kondos said.

"If [landlords] want to play that hard line, they're going to end up with lots of empty malls."

Mr Kondos said the ban on evictions was welcome but rental terms remained unclear.

"Even working with landlords, the harsh reality is some people just won't make it through the longer this goes on," Mr Kondos said.

Appeal for rent relief

Mr Memis said another of his landlords, the Westfield shopping centre at Chermside on Brisbane's northside, had given him a rent holiday.

 

Meanwhile, he said trade at his flagship South Bank store had dwindled to about six takeaway orders a day.

"I think people are scared to order and people are scared to use the Uber and Deliveroo platforms or come out and pick up," he said.

"We had about 35 staff … we're down to three."

Mr Memis said he had been appealing for weeks for rent relief and had sent financial information when requested.

But he said he had received several "letters of demand explaining that rent is due and payable right now".

'Cash-burn cycle'

The owner of a carvery outlet in Windsor in Sydney, Terry Hasan — who is the tenant of a different property owner — said he shut his award-winning business on Saturday.

"We're in a cash-burn cycle now where we're throwing our own money to burn it, our staff as well are saying with coronavirus they're afraid to work, so I've knocked it on the head," Mr Hasan said.

"I feel as though it's extremely unfair for us to pay rent."

 

'Very paranoid about ever going bust'

Mr Van Lieshout said he was not subject to bank pressure because he owned properties outright "and that's something that should not be used against me — for the fact I've been very frugal and that I've taken care of my affairs".

"As I could, I owned my own premises because that got rid of two of the biggest worries in my life, which were banks and landlords," he said.

"I hated bank managers because I feared them because they had control over me.

"Second thing was I had an early dislike for landlords because as a retailer … you had to negotiate with them all the time."

Mr Van Lieshout said: "What I'm saying here can give me a lot of trouble because people say, 'Well, he's in a very sound, financial position and he won't do this, he won't do that'."

"But I always kept capital reserves in [my] business," he said.

"I couldn't go bust because I always made sure that I kept substantial reserves — always — because as far as I was concerned, I had two responsibilities: one was to be able to pay the staff at all times and secondly, my suppliers.

"I'm very, very paranoid — always very paranoid — about ever going bust.

"As a businessman, you have to save for a rainy day — and right now it's a cyclone — [but] I run a business the same as everyone else does. Why do I become the scapegoat at the end?"

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Both are right and both are wrong.

     

  • It's a terrible situation for people to be in and thre will be no winners only losers come out of this.

    If the landlord pushes too hard he could very well end up with empty properties collecting no income from them at all, on the othet hand if you have run a successful business over many years you should bail yourself out.

    • Agreed, and most agents will advise a compromise based on individual circumstances.

  • Where's Kram? He will sort this out...

  • No. He is outright wrong. Someone tell this landlord that we are dealing with a virus that has caused small business to lose anything from 50% 50 100% of their turnover within 48 hours. That cannot be planned for. The Prime Minister has asked tennants to liaise with landlords about coming to a compromise for 6 months. This is a Team Australia moment where everyone takes a hit in order to survive. Clive Palmer has donated 1 miillion dollars to obtain a shipment of the malaria drug to help Australians and has pledged to spend all of his 8 billion if necessary to help Australians. This bloke appears to worship money and control. I would send copies of his refusal letters to Josh Frydenberg's office as The Teasurer has said that if necessary he will bring pressure to bear on landlords. I read this in complete disbelief.

    • Actually he has planned for it, as he said he always made sure he has plenty in the way of cash reserves. He is debt free and he hasn't gotten that way by spending stupidly.

      That said I do think he should show some generosity in this matter, but he has shown wisdom in an area most don't.

      That's the real lesson here.

  • illuminating, Brett. About as illuminating as Genesis.

  • Greedy. Self-centred. A-hole. 

    Yes, he has a point that some landlords might be wealthy themselves and should kick in their own capital. Fair point. But that is a cop out regardless, as he is shirking the whole idea of everyone chipping in.

    For me, the most important part of that article is where he says he owns outright every property. So he is thus refusing to give up any income, even though he is not in the position where he would retain expenses like mortgage payments. In addition, we all know he will gouge taxpayers later on, claiming losses. 

    There can be no defence of this guy. None. Unless you want to defend being a selfish prick.

  • I bet his way to the top, he would have burnt a lot of people. T

  • 35th richest man in the country who owns billions, poor form from the greedy cunt.

This reply was deleted.

Latest comments

Darren Munro replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Ryley smith extends to 2027 😤
"Great reward for all the effort on and off the field. Congratulations young man! Love watching him play and is only going to get better "
4 minutes ago
Speech replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Eels NSW cup team - Some big ins
"What is interesting is Matthew Hunter is picked again. He sealed the game last week with a try his second for the game. I hope we see highlights this week as his stats look great. Seems to know how to win but also when to be involved in the game."
11 minutes ago
Muttman replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Ryley smith extends to 2027 😤
"It would seem so. 3rd and 4th string hooker isn't much of a job. "
15 minutes ago
EA replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Eels NSW cup team - Some big ins
"dang it"
31 minutes ago
KingGutho replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Eels NSW cup team - Some big ins
"He played one game lol and most likely got injured.
if you look at RM cup team, it says he's out, also Hayne played the last game and he's out too, so who knows "
51 minutes ago
Uncle Wizardssleeve- Indigenous Elder-Freemason Hunter -He/Him replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Knights sign prestigious young half
""
54 minutes ago
CarloEEL2 replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Knights sign prestigious young half
"Stop it you two !!!!
no chance of that nonsense 
I'm still thinking Baldy is owed his " shit in a box" for fucking up the GF with giraffe on the bench . I could do a local delivery now 🤔😆"
1 hour ago
EA replied to Eels2025's discussion Forwards we should chase...
"Jacob just recommited to Dragons. No chance he is leaving there. Big player of the future. The most promising backrower yet to debut in the NRL."
1 hour ago
EA replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Eels NSW cup team - Some big ins
"Martyn is not in RM this week. Hope this is a sign he is a late in for Scolari this week."
1 hour ago
EA replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Eels NSW cup team - Some big ins
"Yep. Will be like Moretti. High leg speed and aggression through the middle I recon."
1 hour ago
Perpetual Motion replied to Bob mertens's discussion BA to coach knights in 2026.
"Im agreeing with you. Personally I dont give him much thought."
1 hour ago
Johnny Suede replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Ryley smith extends to 2027 😤
" Is this the end for Hands & Lussick? "
2 hours ago
Johnny Suede replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Ryley smith extends to 2027 😤
"Now to win some games...!"
2 hours ago
WMD replied to Eels2025's discussion Forwards we should chase...
"A firing Fifita would be awesome 👌.  We are probably 1 strike weapon short in our pack.
I think that we should also make provisions for a 5/8 incase Joash doesn't work out in that position. Are Bevan French or Tyran Wishart available? 
Probably a…"
2 hours ago
Mitchy replied to Eels2025's discussion Jason Ryles... Report so far
"Decent blog; and a good account of things thus far.
WE are def playing better than the last few years; just need some more games for these young kids, and a blend of experience.
We have also had a few key injuries again this year.
Our team looks…"
2 hours ago
Mitchy replied to Eels2025's discussion Forwards we should chase...
"Go after Jacob Halangahu; he is a former Mt Druitt kid and tough and played origin reps; He is on the way up. Brink him back to the wetsern Sydney area.
I agree we need another forward with some NRL type experience as per Ford or Hayes"
2 hours ago
More…

NSW Origin Squad 2025

WESTPAC NSW BLUES SQUADAmpol State of Origin, Game OneSuncorp Stadium, Brisbane Wednesday 28 May1. Dylan Edwards (Penrith Panthers)2. Brian To’o (Penrith Panthers)3. Stephen Crichton (Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs)4. Latrell Mitchell (South Sydney…

Read more…
0 Replies
Views: 248

 

Forwards we should chase...

Following the signing of TDS, I believe the club’s next priority should be strengthening the forward pack by targeting 1–2 middles, along with a reliable, NRL-ready back-rower.While it's unlikely that one of the elite-tier forwards will become…

Read more…
7 Replies · Reply by EA 1 hour ago
Views: 758

Jason Ryles... Report so far

Before diving in, it's important to acknowledge where we currently sit on the ladder. We must acknowledge as fans that our position is far from ideal nor acceptable, however, we must also consider the challenges we've faced throughout the early part…

Read more…
5 Replies · Reply by Mitchy 2 hours ago
Views: 631

<script src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<!-- Sidebar -->
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<script>// <![CDATA[
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
// ]]></script>