All Discussions (44453)

Sort by

Forwards vs Backs

In your opinion, who is more important to a team, the forwards or the backs?

Before you answer, I'll throw a hypothetical out seeing as though it's orf season and all...

Let's say we swap out the forward pack of the best team in the comp with the forwa

Read more…
1 Reply · Reply by Angry Eel Sep 26, 2023
Views: 308

Remis Smith and Justin Olam

Surely these 2 cannot play reserve grade for Melbourne and Melbourne cannot be cap compliant. Either or both of these players would be handy for us as we wait for the current batch of juniors to develop. Melbourne have significantly upgraded a number

Read more…
12 Replies · Reply by adnan Sep 23, 2023
Views: 1253

Depth

Depth chart below shows we needed Tuilagi and will need a top quality left centre- that way Simmo is a good quality depth for all positions in the backs. Still 4 spots left. I put Moretti in even though can't find him contracted anywhere. Put Matters

Read more…
44 Replies · Reply by Poppa Sep 21, 2023
Views: 1398

More stuff to read

iamnot replied to Clintorian's discussion Lomax Update - Zac Lomax entered into preliminary contracts with R360 and the Melbourne Storm prior to being given his blessing by Parramatta
"I'm not sure how a court could determine what is a fair settlemt in the NRL sphere. Unless they use the value of Lomax contract as a baseline, or do you use the precedent set by the Dogs when they paid Brisbane $500k for Oloapu? There are far too…"
10 minutes ago
iamnot replied to Clintorian's discussion Lomax Update - Zac Lomax entered into preliminary contracts with R360 and the Melbourne Storm prior to being given his blessing by Parramatta
"We don't need to shop him at all. He can sit in NRL pergatory for three years haha"
13 minutes ago
Nitram replied to Clintorian's discussion Lomax Update - Zac Lomax entered into preliminary contracts with R360 and the Melbourne Storm prior to being given his blessing by Parramatta
"So Melbourne storm were dodgy and then still did the right thing and uploaded their dodgyness to the nrl portal thingy... This is comical stuff. The audacity and arrogance of the melbourne storm offends me as it should ALL nrl fans. This is our game…"
17 minutes ago
Muttman replied to Clintorian's discussion Lomax Update - Zac Lomax entered into preliminary contracts with R360 and the Melbourne Storm prior to being given his blessing by Parramatta
"Mate the NRL can't take over once the Court hands down its ruling. If the Courts decide the release is valid, that's the end of it. Vlandys, Melbourne and anyone else has to abide by the terms of the release. Because once a Judge rules it becomes…"
18 minutes ago
More…