My number 1 pick without a doubt is Brad Fittler who the eels came within a whisker of signing on two occasions.  First was in 1989 and then again in 2000 , had he come in 2000 the eels would of 1000% won a comp .

My 2 3 and 4 picks  are Gene Miles , Wally Lewis and Greg Dowling back in 1987 , they were all set to join the eels until the Broncos swooped with bigger offers.  

 

Out of all the players the eels have either lost or let go over the last 30 + years I  can't think of anyone  who  had the talent or leadership that would of changed the course of the club. 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Matterson would’ve been our captain

  • I think we have the worst recruitment in the league. The Tigers have the worst retention. They've basically lost a rep team worth of players in the last 5-6 years. The Panthers should have done better with their juniors all these years.

    Tigers have lost:

    James Tedesco

    Addo- Carr

    Woods

    Moses

    Andrew Fifita

    Our Nathan Brown

    to name a few off memory.

    • Worst recruitment? Seen the Titans of late?

    • taupau

  • BTW..How on earth woul have we fitted Lewis when we had Kenny? Kenny to centres? Miles was also a centre. Where we're going to push Steve Ella out? I really don't recall going after any of them at the time.

    • Wally would of played Lock .

    • The crow gone lol

  • Steve Menzies is one. Not sure if close or one of those urban myths but Darren Lockyer could have been a eel but Brua Smith said he was too small

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Parrafan101 replied to Eelawarra's discussion EELS COACH JASON RYLES PUSHED TO SIGN OFF ON ZAC LOMAX’S RELEASE REQUEST - THIS IS WHY
"LMAO"
9 minutes ago
Wizardssleeves official receipts replied to Eelawarra's discussion EELS COACH JASON RYLES PUSHED TO SIGN OFF ON ZAC LOMAX’S RELEASE REQUEST - THIS IS WHY
"Ryles didn't want Brown , if he did he wouldn't have point blank denied him even $1 pay rise when he requested it. People forget that Brown asked for a payrise long before the Newcastle offer appeared. If Ryles wanted him at the club there would've…"
9 minutes ago
Wizardssleeves official receipts replied to Eelawarra's discussion EELS COACH JASON RYLES PUSHED TO SIGN OFF ON ZAC LOMAX’S RELEASE REQUEST - THIS IS WHY
"Difference is , he has another  bunch of young birds lined up to fuck and isn't out paying top dollar looking for hookers who haven't got a trick lined up."
12 minutes ago
Wizardssleeves official receipts replied to christeel's discussion J.Ryles potential new middle man
"As I said , name one specialist coach at any NRL club who was a above average gifted player ?  
I think what you mean is hand him a token position for nostalgic purposes because he fucked his life up making egotistical dumb choices."
28 minutes ago
More…