Replies

    • Haas isn't going anywhere. That is just a pipe dream, he is about to extend at the Broncos.

      • I mean that's what this thread is isn't it.

        Supers already kiboshed the Paulo retirement anyway.

  • Grant Anderson is not available if you kept up with the times.. 

  • Sipley goes against what we are building i feel. He barely plays for Manly nonetheless starts, yet we want him to come in an start? We have money to get bigger players, we should aim higher.

    Mozer also i feel Ryles will keep Walker as the primary 14 with Hands as the back-up Hooker.

    • Makes zero sense your basically replacing like for like Sipley for Paulo when the game is speeding up we don't want the 120 plus kg props there getting phased out.

    • Smith is dog shit at hooker. 

      • I do not think Smith is amazing like some here but he is not rubbish either. I feel he is a good Hooker that can definately get better. He is a Hooker you can do well in finals with. 

        • I don't understand LB. If "He is a Hooker you can do well in finals with"  why is he only a not rubbish good hooker?

          • I think Randolph makes a fair point LB. I'm not really sure if too many players are in the amazing category.

            I will say this and that is Rylie Smith is a better talent than Reed Mahoney ever was (that doesn't mean  Reed was rubbish btw). Don't discount his aerobic ability either. 

            THis kid is a genuine talent, don't discount was he has done in the space of 4 months. 

    • Your talking about aiming higher yet happy with smith as a starting hooker, the guy barely takes the line on and gasses after 20 minutes and passing becomes average. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Joel K replied to Offside's discussion Selections for this week
"chuck us a hint"
5 hours ago
Shawn peters replied to Offside's discussion Selections for this week
"Be positive, sick of all this negative stuff.positive news though a high quality player is heading our way, in the next few weeks"
5 hours ago
Yehez replied to Offside's discussion Selections for this week
"I think Papalii has earned a call up, but not sure where. I think he's played wing before and he can come inside to play-make if needed too and added some more unpredictability especially next to Hawkins. 
We have Tuilagi back tho so maybe that…"
5 hours ago
LB replied to Offside's discussion Selections for this week
"I think Ryles will do same. Name Samrani and put Doorey onto the bench. I would be tempted to name Papali'i for a debut, Manly have a big pack, why not some speed around that ruck."
5 hours ago
More…