Top 6 Dirtiest NRL Players

As its the 'Off Season' I thought I'd start with what players that you would consider to be in the 'Top 6' Grubbiest / Dirtiest Players in the N.R.L. Mine are:

1) Russell Packer

2) Nate Myles

3) Cameron Smith

4) Billy Slater

5) Josh McGuire

6) Nelson Asofa Solomona

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • It's incredible how those players are either Queenslanders or Melbourne players LOL

  • This reply was deleted.
    • Yes, I forgot about Micheal Ennis. He wasnt to popular with Nathan Hindmarsh.

  • John Hopoate

  • On a side note did anyone else notice how dirty the Panthers players became after being down by a big margin last night?

    I thought Luai, Martin and Korosau in particular got very dirty especially the number 6.  I know they are young but when times are good they are over the top excited and happy.  Almost gloating! But when times are tough these guys resort to dirty tactics.  

  • defiine dirty players... what is teh category for dirty player. For example Cam Smith is pretty good at getting is team finish the line...

    • A dirty player is a broad statement. So it could include numerous points such as:

      1)Physically using inappropriate tactics to injure the opposition players in the hope of not getting caught.

      2) Manipulating referees and disrespecting them / arguing

      3) Rascist, sexist, religious comments to opposing players to get them off their game or to retaliate physically

      I mean the list is endless and can vary in peoples interpretation.

  • Les Boyd also comes to mind but he was before the NRL period. I would also consider him more aggressive and tough than dirty.

  • In no particular order:

    Nate Myles, Justin Hodges, Josh McGuire, Michael Ennis, Adam Blair, Cameron Smith

    • Forgot about Hodges and Blair

  • This reply was deleted.
    • Yeah, I don't watch many Canberra games, but this year I  noticed how bad Rapana is. He rarely gets panalised for it too.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Nightmare Off-Season replied to Muttman's discussion Apa Twidle signs with the Bears
"Hey Daz,
1) - You want me to go through 2 years worth of blogs & comments to show you the Dylan Brown criticisms didn't 'exceed his value as a potential halfback' -something you claimed? I didn't say 'everyone said he was a crap 5/8th', lets not…"
10 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to Muttman's discussion Apa Twidle signs with the Bears
"NOS, I just burned through that Feb 2025 blog and did not find a single comment saying Brown is a bad 5/8. Some criticisms were his inconsistency and off-field behaviour. Also that he is not a 7 but no biggie he is a 6. 
My favourite comment in the…"
15 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to Muttman's discussion Apa Twidle signs with the Bears
"Is this 1000% like RFK Jr's "600% savings"?"
29 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to Muttman's discussion Apa Twidle signs with the Bears
"Absolutely fair, Coryn.
This was the issue facing us 14 months ago, and this is where we are.
https://www.1eyedeel.com/forum/topics/the-dylan-brown-conundrum"
31 minutes ago
More…