Top 6 Dirtiest NRL Players

As its the 'Off Season' I thought I'd start with what players that you would consider to be in the 'Top 6' Grubbiest / Dirtiest Players in the N.R.L. Mine are:

1) Russell Packer

2) Nate Myles

3) Cameron Smith

4) Billy Slater

5) Josh McGuire

6) Nelson Asofa Solomona

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –


  • It's incredible how those players are either Queenslanders or Melbourne players LOL

  • Mark Geyer

    Rod Reddy

    Micheal Innes

    Cameron Smith

    Adrian Morley

    Ivor lingard

    • Yes, I forgot about Micheal Ennis. He wasnt to popular with Nathan Hindmarsh.

    • Ivor just put him in there as click bait for "old bastards" just because he invented the cumberland throw didn't make him dirty.....mind you he was a south african.

      I know why you put Rod Reddy in there! 

  • John Hopoate

  • On a side note did anyone else notice how dirty the Panthers players became after being down by a big margin last night?

    I thought Luai, Martin and Korosau in particular got very dirty especially the number 6.  I know they are young but when times are good they are over the top excited and happy.  Almost gloating! But when times are tough these guys resort to dirty tactics.  

  • defiine dirty players... what is teh category for dirty player. For example Cam Smith is pretty good at getting is team finish the line...

    • A dirty player is a broad statement. So it could include numerous points such as:

      1)Physically using inappropriate tactics to injure the opposition players in the hope of not getting caught.

      2) Manipulating referees and disrespecting them / arguing

      3) Rascist, sexist, religious comments to opposing players to get them off their game or to retaliate physically

      I mean the list is endless and can vary in peoples interpretation.

  • Les Boyd also comes to mind but he was before the NRL period. I would also consider him more aggressive and tough than dirty.

  • In no particular order:

    Nate Myles, Justin Hodges, Josh McGuire, Michael Ennis, Adam Blair, Cameron Smith

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Eel Nut replied to Electric Eel's discussion Jarryd Hayne- Trial Commences this week
"Sir Col it would be resolved one way or the other but sentencing is not given at that time.  It would be adjourned to a future date for sentencing (if found guilty of course).  The matter  could go on for a couple of months yet.  Which takes out…"
3 minutes ago
Al Shaw replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Parramatta Eels 2021 Draw
"We play all of the other top 6 teams from this year in the last 7 weeks. That's the stretch that will make us or brake us. 
Hopefully it's when we start to peak and if we can win most of those we'll go into the finals not only confident but battle…"
4 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Electric Eel's discussion Jarryd Hayne- Trial Commences this week
"Yes, strangley he was offered a judge only trial and waited the extra 6 months to have a jury.
Implies something, not sure what?"
5 minutes ago
MontoEel replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Parramatta Eels 2021 Draw
"The first 2 rounds is a short turn around up against the Premiers the Storm."
7 minutes ago