Replies

    • Poppa, players values are often spoken of subjectively as  we've both found ;) ...actually a pet hate of mine. Next minute  here, Dylan will be on 1.6M ha!

      Perhaps this dude is gunning for walker to land at broncs and appears he is talking up the comparison value of the new signing who even has a ring :))

      he talks Pezet up is a surprise ha ok 

      ...these days I sometimes wonder if the free press is actually still 'free'

       

    • Ploppa The only person that's ever tried to convince us Moses is on 1.2 is you .  I've said 1.3+ since his last contract , and that's before he gave up his ejector seat clause .  1.5 is very realistic . 

      • If it cost a couple hundred grand extra to re-sign without the player option, that shows the value of it in bringing down his price.

        • No, that's the cost of having the clauses removed. Having the clauses raises his value every time the clause comes into effect as it gives him the power to extract more from the club to remain. 

          • If it's the cost of having them removed then that was the same discount we got for agreeing to them in the first place. Otherwise we wouldn't have agreed to them. Likewise, if we were giving them away for free, every player would have them. But most players would rather more cash up front than a PO.

  • I don't think hes completely wrong 

    Moses is both over rated and under rated depending on the day or situation.

    He deserves his rep jerseys in saying that if im picking the next best NSW half is Katoea.

    If we cut our losses with him for walker it would be the most significant signing in 20 years but wont happen. 

     

  • he is on 1.3. was 1.2 and went up to 1.3 to take out the clauses.  I agree with Badel, Moses has won us nothing and plays good sticking to the structure but when he plays eyes up he is a headless chook. his running game has gone backwards and Volkman on 1/3 of his wage is more dangerous then Moses. Everyone gushes over his kicking that goes straight to the fullback or winger and they make 10 or more metres on return. Auther said he was free to leave if he can find another club when he was the half with Norman we would of been better off if he left, would of had better players now with the money we would of saved. Has never been worth 1mil and never will.

    • This is one of the dumbest takes I've read on here for quite some time. No, we wouldn't have been better off if Moses left.

  • Aust v Fiji had around 380 kicking mtrs, Moses kicking is worth $$$$$, unfortunately that's about it.

  • Badel has the IQ of a field mouse and the footy brain of a door knob. Put Walker, Cleary, Cherry Evans in the Parra side and we still run bottom of the table the last few years with our roster. The Roosters won a premiership with Cherry Evans playing the perfect foil when Walkers game unravelled. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

KENDOZA replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Peter Badel - Moses overpaid and overrated!!!
"Badel has small man's syndrome. He use to get bullied at school and now is taking it out on everyone else"
35 minutes ago
LB replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Peter Badel - Moses overpaid and overrated!!!
"Reminds of the story Harry Reknapp told about Emmanuel Adebayor. Spurs had a system where if you do a foul like turn up late to training for example. So they get fined and the money goes to children's hospital across the road.
Adebayor got fined…"
44 minutes ago
Mitchy replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Peter Badel - Moses overpaid and overrated!!!
"Some background here - i watched the show and they had a long and dribbling conversation around Walker and this led to Badel making the comment that Moses is on $1.3-5 million and he said in his view he is not worth it - words to that effect as he…"
51 minutes ago
Poupou Escobar replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Peter Badel - Moses overpaid and overrated!!!
"If it's the cost of having them removed then that was the same discount we got for agreeing to them in the first place. Otherwise we wouldn't have agreed to them. Likewise, if we were giving them away for free, every player would have them. But most…"
1 hour ago
More…