“I’d be lying if I said I didn’t want to play NRL every week. As a kid you grow up and that’s what you want to do." Gosford-born, now 22 year old, Jonah Pezet told The Queenslander last year.
This could be a make-or-break signing or a missed opportunity for the Ryles era. Pezet has divided some Eels fans, and there are plenty of “ifs” and moving balls. And until a signing is confirmed this is all hypothetical.
Cons & Threats
Two generals in one team? Too many cooks? Mitchell Moses is a dominant seven, and Pezet appears to want that role long-term, though he could compromise to play full-time NRL.
Pezet is a risk, for sure. All signings are. Maybe he’s not yet the superstar we’d pay him to be. He's still getting his body ready, after some significant injuries (another risk) for the gladitorial week-to-week grind of NRL. And also every young half goes through dark nights of the soul; even gets dropped. Sam Walker. Ash Taylor. Tim Smith. Next Big Things.
It’s an expensive risk. Beyond the Raiders, Pezet won’t be short of suitors. He’d likely be number three on the Eels’ salary cap after Moses and Junior Paulo. Number two not long after. (Refer Salary Cap Blog)
If it's really a loan deal, while waiting-on-Munster, we would be a pit stop of convenience, doing more service to the Storm than our club. How did the Harry Grant loan deal work for the Tigers? In that case, we should stick with Ryles’ “The Future is Now” philosophy developing project players like Joash Papali’i, Dean Hawkins, or Lorenzo.
Pros & Opportunities
Pezet could provide a short,mid, and long-term spine solution. The heir to Mitchell Moses. A spine that could grow together for the next 10 years plus, building around it.
In the short term, he could ease our over-reliance on Moses and his fitness, as has missed large Turbo-Ponga-esque chunks of games in recent seasons. This year, the Eels have a 54% win ration with Moses, 27% without.
Why couldn't Pezet play six for a while? He has 15 games at six, 20 at seven, and 15 off the bench at Cup and NRL levels. The Broncos won a grand final with a two-sevens in the halves (Reynolds-Hunt), while Storm have succeeded with three fullbacks and a Grant spine.
In 18 NRL games with the Storm, Pezet has scored two tries, kicked five from six goals, and maintained a win ratio of almost 85%.
He has also shown he’s team-centric. “I’m confident in my ability to play 80 minutes at halfback,” he said, but he’s willing to play six or off the bench. "What’s best for the team.”
And who better to mentor him than Moses? A win-win. Moses spent the first half of his career at six with the Tigers, and the second half at seven with the Eels. On the Sixes and Sevens podcast, Moses said he wished he had a senior seven to guide him.
Bottom Line
In the bold V'Landys Universe of Attack, Attack, Attack, we don't have the supreme x-factor talents like Reece Walsh or Payne-Haas tanks through the middle to compete in a gunslinging, power shoot-out. We'll need to continue to build resilient systems with some creative enterprise. Winning on guts and pressure and nuance. A strong kicking game will be critical. Pezet provides added points of attack and opportunities, reducing pressure on Moses. His utility value to play both six or seven or off the bench is a plus, not a negative. His game-changing kicking game and footy IQ as a bona-fide half, gives us a rare one-two punch in Moses. We talk about x-factor, well there it is.
In the end, Jonah Pezet could be a luxury we can’t afford or the cornerstone we can’t afford to miss. The Ryles era is just getting started and this decision could define it. Will history remember it as bold brilliance or a missed opportunity, a Waterloo moment?
Source of Johah Pezet quotes: The Queenslander
Related blogs: Eels' Salary Cap Study, Where Do We Fit in the New Era / V'Landys Universe?
Replies
Da Silva came in with 9 games to go, of course he would be on the bench knowing our system. Was not til the last game where he clicked. He wasn't on the bench due to ability or not good enough. Ryles will let Smith and Da Silva fight it out.
As for Joash beating Pezet, well anything is possible and Ryles I believe will name best player but Ryles has seen Papali'i play 6 in game and training, he knows what he has in Papali'i and if he was convinced he wouldn't have gone for Pezet.
Papalii is slicker but doesn't translate to constant play to the point where Papali'i is the best 6 for us. Joash was fine at 6, but that's all he was, showed he is capable to fill in. Can he get better? Of course but seems the coaching staff see otherwise and we will have to see what hindsight gives us.
In terms of Joash at Melbourne, I do not think so as his play at 6 has not warranted the attraction. It's not Ryles is going "let's see what's at Melbourne that I can buy"
Storm did good with a fullback to halves, Hughes and Munster came throught that route.
Wasn't my point, who's to say that Pezet is/would be better than Joash.???
Hang on I will answer that Ryles, but remember Ryles also wanted Talagi and Galvin so his judgement is human! He also obviously wanted TDS and the jury is still out there? Yes he did come good in the last round.....we won by 60 points....relevance is still an issue and again I am assuming we paid 350k for TDS and not the rediculous number that people want to quote when talking their agenda/book.
Pezet would have been on how much at Storm 150/200 ?? What's Joash on at Parra 150? how would Joash have gone in that Storm side if the positions were reversed?
I'm not too concerned about fit because JR knows exactly how he's going to use Pezet or he wouldn't have gone and got him.No doubt he'd have laid the gameplan out and his usage and that'll be that.
2 generals I don't see it we got our Field Marshall Pezet can be the general if he likes but there's only one guy running this team for the next 3 years and that's Field Marshall Moses.
It was clear all the way along JR was looking for Moses sidekick and if confirmed now he's found him.Papali'i Volkman and all the rest will battle it out for a potential halves spot down the road because as above if this signing is confirmed in 3 weeks then I don't see any halves movement outside of injury.
The Galvin chase was basically the writing on the wall that we were never set with what we had in the cupboard..Now just get us that enforcer in the foward pack cough Tino cough cough and then the timeline for success speeds up expediently.
Great point Coryn. Ryles not only knows how to use him, he has coached him before at Melbourne. He has seen this kid play for years, knows how he plays and how he is around the club. Had Galvin not come available, Pezet was always the no.1 choice to replace Brown. Then when Galvin signed with the Dogs, Ryles went for Pezet. The crumbs were there when on a podcast Anasta mentioned another 6 Ryles liked then stopped himself saying more due to conflict of interest. Put 2 and 2 together since he manages Pezet and Ryles has worked with Pezet before that it had to be him.
In terms of generals, who is to say Galvin wouldn't of been that? He would have demanded the ball along with Moses. Pezet is a smart kid, he will know how to run the game around Moses and if Moses is out through Origin for example, Pezet takes control, not a case of looking at Brown and saying "Do something".
Not saying this signing is a slam dunk, no idea if it will be but it is a good signing in principle. Ryles so far has not been too far off in his recruitment. Iongi, Kautoga, Williams, Papali'i, Samrani has done a job, JAC. Da Silva probably so far has been the one where he didn't kick on til the Knights game but also did not have a pre-season with us.
But he has done well with his recruitment so far, so he deserves the benefit of the doubt.
The only thing I'd say is combination your basically starting from scratch again putting in yet another new piece on that left side.This is where the system is important how quickly if signed can Pezet strike up atracking and defensive consistency with those around him.
Defensively more so as I believe if we are to make finals next year this is why we'll do it.There's indicators there of potential but the consistency isn't that's where this team has to get to.
Don't forget Pez is coming off an ACL and was it another one after that?
I like this as a signing , Moses too often gets bogged down in directing the team around the park instead of playing what he sees.
Moses is such a great runner of the footy, even as he gets older he has great acceleration and we haven't been able to utilise it as much with Browns limitations .
Pezet allows Mitch to play how he wants without the burden of our game plan falling apart if he's not always on point.
This combination would also allow Pezet to work on his own game, taking the line on and ball playing late knowing Moses has his back.
Get a middle who bends the line in traffic and an outside back that does the same who both quickly find their belly , get fast play the balls and we'd have a serious football team here.
As usual, insightful, Bup. If what you saw happened, we'd be utilizing more of Moses' skills-set.
Yet, I doubt Moses will relinquish Numero-Uno-Field-General as Pezet isn't Nathan Cleary.
Hawkings, Moses, Hunt, all show we don't need to get too hung up on Pezet at six. Just his skill-set, which add more to the team when Moses is in and out.
Few things to point out. Although Moses is a general like player, he also is one of the best running half's in the comp. I stand by no half does a better short side raid than Moses.
hawkins is also a similar styled player. I thought he and Moses also were able to combine well.
price tag is a fair concern given his previous injuries. Agree a loan deal would only be suitable if we reasonably believed talentina is a season off being a first grader. He has been well at cup level but still think he needs 2 years of growing/learning systems to be a first grade half.
Lets not forget Moses missed close to 50% of games over the last 2 years. It might worth having a 6 that can switch to 7 on a weeks notice.
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
of 8 Next