Don't rate Sivo or Scott. Penisini has his defensive shortfalls. We are not that great in outside backs and desperate for JAC. We are lucky our halves in the best 3 in comp
Sivo can still score 20 or so tries a year. You think that is only due to Moses and Brown, well Dunster has score 3 tries in 19 games. Simonsson only 3 tries in around 22 games as a Winger for us. Yeah his running has faultered from his rookie year but scoring that many tries has to go on the player too.
Scott is still young and can develop under BA. He had some injury issues but his defence was incredible for Melbourne. He was considered a bolter for Origin around 2018-2019. If Scott doesn't work out, Simonsson has proven he is good at Centre.
I'd take him , but he's a goose . Can't see it happening but iid tip my hat to the R&R knobs if they could prove me wrong. He's 1000% on the outer at Canterbury . They want him gone yesterday .
Unfortunatly my guess would be it'll be a massively back ended deal and more then he's worth . But we need some strike so it is what it is .
CP > Wizardssleeves official receiptsNovember 29, 2023 at 7:11pm
Yep, we wanted X-Factor and JAC is it. Our backs are in desperate need of speed.
"Smith has fallen away badly in defence. I don't know if he's lost bulk to become quicker, but even in reserve grade yesterday there were plenty of meters made by running at Smith. He was very poor, and took wrong options on a couple of…"
"after just watching the replay the first thing needed is this week they should all be put on the tackling bags and work their arse off and learn how to tackle. To me Iongi is not a full back, always out of position, can't tackle, should be moved to…"
"Yeah fair comment. Him being closer to the ruck instead in position also wouldn't have helped as Lucas garnered the momentum to pass Iongi. Had Iongi been back in position he would have been able to build speed up. Though yoh could tell Iongi is…"
"Well as Ryles said, Edwards gives you that versatility. PM is right, Edwards gave us what Smith does sort of, but can play middle. Thats what Ryles prefers a Hooker that's not specialist. Helps your bench rotation out massively."
Replies
Plus Scott by seasons end
A back 4 of Gutho, Sivo, Penisini, Scott and Addo-Carr is phenomenal.
Don't rate Sivo or Scott. Penisini has his defensive shortfalls. We are not that great in outside backs and desperate for JAC. We are lucky our halves in the best 3 in comp
Sivo can still score 20 or so tries a year. You think that is only due to Moses and Brown, well Dunster has score 3 tries in 19 games. Simonsson only 3 tries in around 22 games as a Winger for us. Yeah his running has faultered from his rookie year but scoring that many tries has to go on the player too.
Scott is still young and can develop under BA. He had some injury issues but his defence was incredible for Melbourne. He was considered a bolter for Origin around 2018-2019. If Scott doesn't work out, Simonsson has proven he is good at Centre.
Just need a Centre to prove the can tackle.
The other factor in all this, dogs are still goin for Luai, so they need cap space to secure him. see how it pans out
I'd take him , but he's a goose . Can't see it happening but iid tip my hat to the R&R knobs if they could prove me wrong. He's 1000% on the outer at Canterbury . They want him gone yesterday .
Unfortunatly my guess would be it'll be a massively back ended deal and more then he's worth . But we need some strike so it is what it is .
Yep, we wanted X-Factor and JAC is it. Our backs are in desperate need of speed.
Fox-Factor
Dogs after Luia now. AFB and Luia I think the fox is on the way out for sure
-
4
-
5
-
6
-
7
-
8
of 9 Next