Forward Pack Ratings

I was listening to Scott Sattler and Matt Rogers tonight, who rated their top eight forward packs on paper for next year. Neither of them rated our pack in the top eight. They even made specific mention of RCG now at the Titans. Yes, he is gone, get over it as I will be told and so be it. Our forwards were imo our strength for the past four of five years. Yes, they could both be proven wrong and I hope they are , but for our pack to not to be rated in the top 8 by two experienced subject matter experts is worrying.  I don't perceive bias from either of these guys. I hope this stuff motivates the forward pack to prove them all wrong.  The modern game needs impact forwards and a pack that endlessly hunts in defence. I always rated our pack and was surprised to see them not even mentioned in the top eight packs.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • 🤣😂 "experienced subject matter experts" 😂🤣

  • We finished second last this past season - you could say we didn't have a top 8 forward pack then either. You can see where the club is going with this team now though, and the players they have brought in have been in an attempt to modernise the squad. We do still have some very good forwards on paper, but Ryles needs to extract the best out of them consistently.

    I don't take much notice of what the "experts" say, but we'll see what transpires this coming season and next.

  • our forwards weren't the best last year but with our backs making 6m or less per carry they were always  exhausted and looked better from set starts I.e. penalties.

    Put any of our forwards in penriths pack and they'll look better

    • 100%   the weakest part of our pack the last couple of years were our back 3. 

  • We already paid a price for being to top-heavy in the forwards the last 2 season we were gargage mobile fit packs are the way with the concussion rules and sin bins rules in place 

  • Sounds about right. We won 7 games last year and weve lost RCG. Its up to the pack to get their act together and improve under Ryles.

    A lot of work to get our pack into the top 8 I would think.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

The Captain replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R14 v Dogs: King's Birthday Battle (L14-12 in the fight again, another close loss, our 3rd, 6 points)
"This is the same story every year - our depth is never up to scratch. And yes I know we are injury ravaged, but other teams are copping it too (eg Rabbitohs and Cowboys) and are still fighting for Top 8.
Injuries have definitely cost us a place or…"
13 minutes ago
Offside replied to Yehez's discussion Kane Evans
"I know of one former player who felt he couldn't come out during his career.
I hope more players are able to its naive to think only Kane and Ian Roberts are.
 
Aside from that to be open in his mental health battles is very strong and I hope he has…"
20 minutes ago
The Captain replied to Yehez's discussion Kane Evans
"Super, super brave and vulnerable of Kane to come out with this interview.
The fact that he's only the second openly gay NRL player after Ian Roberts 30 odd years ago shows how many young men he will be helping because statistically speaking there…"
31 minutes ago
paul taylor replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R14 v Dogs: King's Birthday Battle (L14-12 in the fight again, another close loss, our 3rd, 6 points)
"I watched the NSW Cup match very closely yesterday. I hate to say it but Lorenzo was very average. His confidence is shot. I know a lot of that team and most are still elgible for Jersey Flegg.  However, defence was appawling. Some of the tries the…"
38 minutes ago
More…