Replies

  • 1. Iongi 

    2. JAC

    3. Lomax

    4. Simonsson 

    5. Young

    I would play Simonsson at centre over Penisini as he is faster and a better defender.

  • We need 4-5 forwards before we need a winger, he would be a luxury we really can't afford at the expense of signing good forwards. 

  • we should be spending big on forwards dont need him

  • If he is not good enough for the chooks then he is not good enough for Parramatta , the guy has too much Paul Carriage in his game . 

    • I think he is a lot better than Paul Carriage but I am not sure where he fits if we play Lomax as a winger. That said he gives us a backline that is all speed.

      Frankie, any idea why Roosters would let him go....is there something we don't know?

      • He is far too up and down , he can do Paul Carriage like mistakes and is hopeless in defence . He may have speed but he has zero speed in the brain department , he needs to kept as far away from Parramatta as possible .

  • I'd sign him and let Addo-Carr go. No need to have both. 

    I agree with someone above that if anything I'd sign a left centre if we have to play with the backline. Even then though I think the left hand side of the backline is primed for Alemaddine and Richie Penisini to take over it by 2027 to be honest. 

    • The Fox is in a different league to Young. No comparison.

      • Oh I agree, much more tactically smart player. 

        But like if JAC doesn't renew and we want another speedy option I could understand it. I still wouldn't go for Young if I was Ryles mind you.

  • Hard no. Not even our NSW cup side. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Tad replied to SuperEel 22's discussion Parramatta Eels officially open the world’s largest rugby league Centre of Excellence
"I hope Jack can contribute spiritually Super and get the juice running again "
4 minutes ago
Tad replied to SuperEel 22's discussion Parramatta Eels officially open the world’s largest rugby league Centre of Excellence
"At least the ones driving a hybrid will keep the families live longer Pops. I don't think you want to go down that path mate.. The world is changing. ( There are about 1000 billionaire s running the show how many more would you like?) cheers "
9 minutes ago
Bourbon Man replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Dogs now heavy favourites for Galvin.
"So would I."
20 minutes ago
Uncle Wizardssleeve- Indigenous Elder-Freemason Hunter -He/Him replied to SuperEel 22's discussion Parramatta Eels officially open the world’s largest rugby league Centre of Excellence
"Is it just me or does 70 million seem quite cheap in 2025 ?  "
22 minutes ago
More…