Replies

  • Love how we now think of a price, we don't budge it rock solid. Let him go to Manly, let be frank Manly are heading for a melt down. Everyone knows it & the kid knows it. But he will get more money at Manly. Lol

    • They'll have a half back playing more then 6 games next year. 

  • I mean is this a surprise.

    Why isn't this club looking to upgrade its front office and football department staff aswell as its players has always been the question I've asked for years now.How accountable are the CEO GM of football R and R members are they held to the same accountability as the HC?

    Some of these people have been in positions of power for more than 5 years but here we are why are they not held to account for lack of results.They are all pieces in the puzzle but here we are another missed opportunity to add a player and they've come up short and in a rebuilding phase with $$$$$ to burn yet can't get the job done.When does the mentioned accountability kick in or is it just business as usual and move onto the next failure.

    I also ask is JR not a pull either as he's clearly spoken to players that we've tried to attract and retain I mean if Bennett were here does he get these deals over the line conjecture yes but like Gus I bet he does.

     

    • Only thing I will say is yes Bennett would get players despite the board but that is due to a proven record. Ryles of course doesn't have that so you can like Ryles but not enough runs on the board.

  • Something going on with manly and tigers they've basically swapped players the last few years 😂 I don't really see much changing for manly unless they buy some middles. 

    • Their middles are ageing. They are heading for a rebuild as the Trbojevic brothers and DCE move on and have money. Difference is they will buy most of the players they want.

      MON? Would say "Do you accept bits of string?" As a low ball tactic.

  • 650k a year for a backup hooker who cant tackle. With purchases like these manly are heading for the bottom of the table. What ridiculous money for an untired player. We need a hooker that can transition to lock. That would be ideal.

    • They are definitely paying on potential but their forward stocks are a far bigger issue then the 9 spot. Desperation signing for manly 

      • That's more than Cody walker  ? 

        I honestly don't think we were trying to sign him @ 650k. I meant that at this stage of his career his a backup. He has not proven himself to be a start.  He may never be a starter. Loads of good young hooker with potential. On top of that you can convert fb and halves to play hooker. JR likes playersthat are multi skilled. 

    • You really think we would sign him to be a back-up Darren? We weren't signing him with the intent of being  a back-up. If we were happy with Smith moving forward we weren't signing him.

      We need a Hooker that can play eyes up it seems according to Ryles.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Parra_Greg replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Andddd another signing goes by the wayside
"There is something very wrong with our club ....what is the recruitment pitch......if we cant even convince a second string hooker with Manly as the competition what the fick is going on ?
New Coach woth good ideas and processes,  New COE but same…"
47 seconds ago
EA replied to Roy tannous's discussion Kautoga extends till 2027!🔥🔥
"Moretti has played backrow in the low grades and Hopgood can play there too. But yea probably still want an edge player.
Personally, if you give Smith another pre-season there is a good chance he can play 80min next year consistently. The team…"
11 minutes ago
Tad replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Positive Steps Forward, In Principle — On The Long Road Ahead
"Hi HOE Thanks for your contribution to this site.Always very well presented.
Personally I like any business to have abroad compliment type to a board with well qualified people from abroad spectrum of backgrounds. Certainly good business heads are a…"
16 minutes ago
EA replied to Roy tannous's discussion Kautoga extends till 2027!🔥🔥
"x2"
17 minutes ago
More…