1eE Modern day Eels team

Please don't go down the worst of the worst path.

Running a "Worst 17" poll is a highly disrespectfull move that can quickly turn a supporters' community into a platform for cyber abuse. Even if the intent is "just a bit of fun," the real-world consequences for the website, the members, and the player, many of whom are still part of the rugby league community are real and long lasting.

The NRL community has increasingly focused on the devastating impact of player and past player wellbeing. High-profile figures like Darius Boyd have warned that relentless online criticism can lead to tragic outcomes, including self-harm.

Many players from the last 35 years still have families, children, and professional careers in the industry. Publicly "ranking" them as failures can have a lasting negative impact on their personal lives and reputations.

Defamation occurs if published material tends to "lower a person's reputation in the eyes of an ordinary, reasonable person".

Even if a post is only up for a short time, it can lead to costly court proceedings and damages. High-profile cases, such as Ricky Stuart’s weak-gutted dog comment, highlights how quickly comments about players can lead to so many issues. Fans who engage in this type of toxic content can often be rated as the worst supporters by others, Instead of celebrating the club's history, the site becomes a lightning rod for negativity, which can drive away constructive members and sponsors

If all that fails to convince you LB, i will just ask, how would you feel, how would your family feel, what about your children not just now but for ever, could find your real name on a students voted worst teachers online list of the last 35 years. How would that effect them or embarrasses them and how would you feel. Food for thought my friend.

"In the past we could count on 2 points when opposing Saints. It's no longer the case. What we saw in Saints two games so far is cause for us to be wary. They've toughened up and competing hard could be troublesome for us.
I feel better that we…"

"I'm hoping for an Eels + 10 victory. There first home game this year. They should set the standard to make their homeground a fortress this year. They really need to win this match and make a statement. It would be extremely disappointing to have a…"

"Id also keep Tualagi as a starter. Took the opportunity given and excelled. He gets another chance for mine - not a definite lock in long term and must continue to give 7 or 8 out of 10 games. "

Replies

Blue Eel March 16, 2026 at 3:22pm

Please don't go down the worst of the worst path.

Running a "Worst 17" poll is a highly disrespectfull move that can quickly turn a supporters' community into a platform for cyber abuse. Even if the intent is "just a bit of fun," the real-world consequences for the website, the members, and the player, many of whom are still part of the rugby league community are real and long lasting.

The NRL community has increasingly focused on the devastating impact of player and past player wellbeing. High-profile figures like Darius Boyd have warned that relentless online criticism can lead to tragic outcomes, including self-harm.

Many players from the last 35 years still have families, children, and professional careers in the industry. Publicly "ranking" them as failures can have a lasting negative impact on their personal lives and reputations.

Defamation occurs if published material tends to "lower a person's reputation in the eyes of an ordinary, reasonable person".

Even if a post is only up for a short time, it can lead to costly court proceedings and damages. High-profile cases, such as Ricky Stuart’s weak-gutted dog comment, highlights how quickly comments about players can lead to so many issues. Fans who engage in this type of toxic content can often be rated as the worst supporters by others, Instead of celebrating the club's history, the site becomes a lightning rod for negativity, which can drive away constructive members and sponsors

If all that fails to convince you LB, i will just ask, how would you feel, how would your family feel, what about your children not just now but for ever, could find your real name on a students voted worst teachers online list of the last 35 years. How would that effect them or embarrasses them and how would you feel. Food for thought my friend.
- LB > Blue Eel March 16, 2026 at 3:49pm
  
  I mentioned beforehand that many brought that up years ago, a few mentioned recently they may want it but your case is fair BE.
  
  Would you like to see one in particular?
  - Blue Eel > LB March 16, 2026 at 4:00pm
    
    Cheers LB.
    
    I like supers one that resonates with me .
    
    Best underrated 17.
    
    It brings Burt in fullback contention, Takaraingi or Joel Reddy in the centres, Jeff robson halfback contention, Mick Vella , Tim Smith, Alvaro, Lane, Nathan Brown, Inu, Odenryne, David Woods, Daniel Mortimer, Jason Bell, Andrew Ryan, David Solomona, Justin Morgan, to name some possibles.
SuperEel 22 March 16, 2026 at 3:38pm

Maybe go for the underrated 17 instead of a "worst of". Like we all know Hindy is the best backrower of the last 30 years, but I'd say an underrated guy for us was Chad Robinson or Ben Smith before his knees completely went.
- LB > SuperEel 22 March 16, 2026 at 3:51pm
  
  Robbo was super underrated.

This reply was deleted.

Eels Blogs