1. Iongi 

2. Fox

3. Russell 

4. Samrami/Penasini 

5. Simmonson 

6. Pezet

7 Mo

8. Jnr 

9 Smith 

10. Williams 

11. Kelma Tuilagi 

12  kit Kautoga 

13. Debelin 

14. Da Silva 

15. Sam Tuivaiti 

16. Walker

17. Doorey 

18. Hopgood 

 

* Kelma did enough and is a strike weapon out wide. Although Williams is a steadier player, i really think Kelma creates opportunities both on and off the ball. He also had a massive pre season as Ryles pointed out.  Without Kelma we don't beat the donkeys 

* Also, i don't know what to do with Hopgood/ Williams fighting it out for a prop rotation position. 

* I think Ryles will opt for Penasini over Samrami if fully fit.  If Samrami is kept at centre i have no issues. 

* The bench must be retained, each of the four turned the tide for the eels in the second half

* Williams & Hopgood.  Williams the player of the year 2025 wont be left outHopgood returns after suspension  - a good headache for Ryles to have having a number of choices 

Debelin/Hopgood.  One of these two will.be left out

 

Some interesting choices 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

    1. Iongi
    2. fox
    3. samrani/penisini
    4. russel
    5. simmo
    6. pezet
    7. moses
    8. moretti
    9. smith
    10. paulo
    11. williams
    12. kautoga
    13. Hopgood
    14. tds
    15. walker
    16. tuivita
    17. jdb
    18. Tuilagi 
    19. Papalii

    This is the team I would want but I don't see that happening. Moretti will probably still be in cup and Doorey will be in the team but probably unused on the bench.

    • I expect 

      1. iongi
      2. fox
      3. pensini/samrani
      4. russel
      5. simmo
      6. pezet
      7. moses
      8. paulo
      9. smith
      10. hopgood
      11. williams
      12. kautoga
      13. jdb
      14. tds
      15. walker
      16. tuivita
      17. tuilagi
      18. doorey
      19. papalii
      • Starting paulo should be fine against the dragons forward pack but against elite teams it won't work out 

      • EA

        who you got breaking through on the wing out of Rokosuka, Alameddine, or someone else? Richard P I feel may have fallen behind? Maybe not.

        • Richie's chance would have been 2024, we debuted Jake Tago and Lorenzo Mulitalo. I reckon guaranteed Barrett would have thrown Richie a debut. But he did his ACL while BA was still there. Injuries after injuries, then Nanva getting on the scene as well Samrani kicking on, just got worse for him.

          Maybe Perth pick him up. 

      • I think they will sit Penisini til his groin is 100%. Why rush when Samrani did a job.

        But other than that, i reckon 100% that is the team. Tuivaiti or Doorey would be the question of who misses out, with Tuilagi more likely being used off the bench allowing Williams to go into the middle and the style he is, Doorey becomes expendable for now. You need Tuivaiti who has 2-3 defenders on him to bring him down.

    • Moretti the forgotten man.  Id always have him in the 19 

      • Well to be fair, i see him and Doorey practically being the same player. I feel Moretti is more consistent though.

  • It should be horses for courses, so our bigger middles to play. We have that luxury, so why not use it?

    • Exactly right we have enough versatility to adapt to circumstance.

      I still see Jnr as the pack alpha though there are times during the game where it loosens up to much and he gets exposed.Ruck control is so important in the modern game more so now you just can't have a quick ruck of you'll get run over like we did the first 20-25 last night.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your Team list v Dragons - Kelma must stay
"Brisbane's play the ball speed was quicker, but later on we got control of the ruck, poking our nose through and getting on our elbows for quick play the balls, Brisbane were out on their feet. Tawha was having a tough time keeping up and Mam…"
35 minutes ago
DYNASTY.LOADING replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your Team list v Dragons - Kelma must stay
"Reckon they give their players a few weeks to get fit enough to do their job in Penrith? Hell, everyone on this site would go into meltdown if we signed Leka, but Webster has him on the bench because of standards. Kautoga isn't a first grader, it…"
39 minutes ago
Michael W. replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Your Team list v Dragons - Kelma must stay
"Kautoga started the same last season, everyone wanted him out of the team. By the end of the year he was our most dangerous attacking weapon, and was hitting hard in defence. Give him time, he will come good."
57 minutes ago
Michael W. replied to Blue Gold Legend's discussion Radradra, Hayne or Sivo - Most NRL Tries
"Irvine was a far better winger than Johnson. You could probably count on one hand how many tries Johnson created for himself, the majority were handed to him on a platter. Irvine could, and did, score a lot of long range tries with his speed and…"
1 hour ago
More…