Didn't get to watch the game live. Was listening on radio while stuck in the long weeking traffic back into Sydney. Watching the replay, I had a couple of looks at the Harper no try at around the 11 minute mark where he had a foot on the touch line coming back into play. Should the Bunker have had a closer look at  Aidan Sezer involvement - tackling/pushing Harper into touch without the ball, prior to him regathering. Sezer wasn't trying to tackle him in the motion of kicking. He took him out of play briefly by running him off the ball chase after he had kicked. Could have given Eels another attcking opportunity?? Whether they could have done anything with an extra opportunity remains debatable.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –


  • Good question. There was another incident where Papali was deliberately holding back a player think it was Harper when Gutho scored a try and I reckon it was definitely a professional foul. He should have had at least 10 in the bin and a possible 8 point try in my opinion. The referee wasn't that great.Tigers were good but definitely got away with a lot especially holding down players trying to slow the play the ball 

    • Surprised they didn't rule an obstruction against Eels for coming into contact with a defender.

    • That is not how the rules work mate. If a try is scored despite a professional foul, the player does not go to the bin. 8 point tries are only given if there is foul play after the try is scored.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Poppa replied to Hell On Eels's discussion R8 v Manly: The Rise and Fall of the Eels
"You are possibly right Frankie, can you get a comparative expense exercise done with other clubs to make this a legitimate comparison..... I get a bit lost when you keep referring to the "bottom of the barrell standard people" ...... I can accept…"
4 minutes ago
Poppa replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 8 Team List v Manly Warringah Sea Eagles (ANZAC Round)
"I had to go over to TCT to see if I was the old dribbler Hugo mentioned as my comments were not supportive of any particular faction, view or site.....so it wasn't me, although in saying that don't let the facts spoil the story. Points being made…"
32 minutes ago
Michael W. replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Jett Cleary off to NZ
"Good on you for acknowledging you're an idiot, bro."
1 hour ago
Uncle Wizards Sleeve indigenous elder He/Him replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 8 Team List v Manly Warringah Sea Eagles (ANZAC Round)
"The old toilets stalkers . The guys that lurk around the toilets at training sessions waiting for players to need a piss , just so they can pretend to take a piss at the trough next to their idols. 
I bet they were horrified when they found out…"
1 hour ago