Replies

  • Players like RCG are easier to replace than guys like Junior Paulo. RCG is a metre eater and good defender. Paulo is a ball playing prop who is part of our attacking structure. If you think Paulo is expendable then go have a look at our forward pack in 2017 and 2018. I'd say he's more crucial to it than RCG, particularly if Hollis and Rodwell come through as expected.

    • Paulo had a pretty meh season . RCG added starch. Something we have lacked for decades. 

      • Both RCG and Paulo are vital to our success IMO.

        It was no coincidence we wilted without RCG in the games he was injured.

        Paulo is equally as important for dominating the middle, generating second phase play, fast play the balls etc. He has a different skill set to RCG but they are both super important.

        Paulo was immense in the finals games same as RCG.

        • Was going to post this exact point this morning but got tied up so to speak.  It says it all that our flat spot towards the end of the season was when RCG was out.  He came back, we competed.  He is the heart and soul and main driving force of this forward pack.  He is a metre eater and lifts the team with aggression in his defence.

          • He is our enforcer in the middle. He is the bully that the other team fears running into. Every team needs a hard man that scares the other team. RCG is that guy for us. If we lose him we need a new one.

            • So we develop one. Let's remember we still have Nathan Brown, and Nakatoa has shown he can deal, so can Ray Stone. We don't lack for hard men. 

              • I'm hard right now - just at that thought...

  • For a team that prides itself on its forward pack and all its momentum drives from the forward pack i.e when the forwards don't aim up and dominate we struggle to turn moment and loose. This will be a massive loss, he has been our best forward and was an absolute animal when he returned from suspension for the final series, i would go as far as to say that his injection in the final series is what made us so competitive. He dominated the entire knights pack on his own and made Tyson frizell he's baby boy.

    • Exactly Blaze.

      BA has proved in 2018 without super dominant forwards he has no plan B.

      RCG is nearly irreplacable. How are we going to replace such a dominant forward for the same cost? The answer is we can't. We will have to pay far more money.

      • BA has proved in 2018 without super dominant forwards he has no plan B." 

         

        that's because his halves are about as creative as a boiled egg without the dippers 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 13 Team List v Newcastle Knights
"Where did he say he regretted it? I saw an article saying he had no regrets at all declining St. George Illawarra.
He left them at the alter as they wouldn't let him have his own people in charge. Plus, yes they have good signings but are still a…"
12 minutes ago
fake midget pseudoachondroplasia replied to Parra-all-the-way's discussion Cowboys rumoured signings
"There is plenty of quality players able to negotiate on November 1st.  The new teams and new broadcast deal being negotiated mean the really good players and agents held off on signing as values will go up.  I know Parra like every other club have…"
19 minutes ago
Darren Munro replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 13 Team List v Newcastle Knights
"Might be a deal with Burton or Xerri.  Lose tuivati  gain a dog or 2."
33 minutes ago
Darren Munro replied to EA's discussion EA & SB Rookie Report - End of Season SG/HM Player Review
"EA I haven't heard you mention Famui that much. Seems his highly rated."
38 minutes ago
More…