R25 v Chooks: Baba Yaga (Lomax Under Speculation Cloud)

Last week, the Boogeyman struck again. This week, the Eels host Baba Yaga. The one you send to kill the Boogeyman, Johnny Wick reminds us.

History is a brute. We have lost 10 of their last 12 against the Roosters since 2017. Not a single win outside Parramatta since 2008. Our most recent win against them was over three years ago. Round 15, 2022.

The Roosters arrive in ruthless form. Sam Walker's wizardry is back steering, and they've won three-straight steamrolling the third-placed Dogs, Dolphins, and Manly. They've scored 96 points in two weeks while the Eels have conceded 100 points to them in their last three meetings. An average 14–33 defeat.

For us, there are glimmers. Commbank. The place we've had our only two wins against them in nine years. It’s Dylan Walker’s 250th NRL game.  And if Moses hits top gear, hope lives.

13695889495?profile=RESIZE_710xThis week’s focus: Unity. Kaizen. Can we bounce-back after being out-hussled in last week’s 20–16 loss to Souths?

Matchups

Forwards Battle: The Dogs and Dolphins tried to bash the Roosters. They got blown away. 

Middle: Whyte, Collins and Leniu will aim to smash us. Yet the Roosters concede more tries here than any other side.

Roosters’ Left vs Eels’ Right: Moses, Lomax, Penisini and Tuilagi own the 4th-leakiest right edge. Five of our last seven tries were conceded here. Lomax has 7 tries in 7 games.

Eels’ Left vs Roosters’ Right: The Roosters’ right edge has Walker and Nawaqanitawase threats, but it can be error-prone. Can Papali’i, Moses, Brown and Addo-Carr pounce?

Eels vs Raymond-Gee: Under those two officials, collectively, we have lost 14 from the last 16 games since 2021. Baba Yaga.13695889270?profile=RESIZE_710xCan Walker’s milestone galvanise the squad?

Bottom Line

We own just one win from ten against top-eight teams this year. And 85 errors in 6 weeks. We're rebuilding. And lack cohesion at key moments. The Roosters, meanwhile, are humming. An intimidating power game. Every inch a finals force in their trademark late-season surge.

If we hold their middle. If we tighten our fundamentals, there’s a path. Better ball control. Support. Execution. Last-tackle options. Urgent kick-chases. Win the loose ball contest. Hussle. Fight. If not, a blowout looms. Kaizen is at stake.

History, form and the bookies all scream Rooster. The head nods along. But the heart clings to Commbank magic.

 

 

13695889678?profile=RESIZE_710xMoses’ leadership, boot and composure will be decisive. Can he be the glue that binds and inspires? Or will Baba Yaga devour again?

Team Lists

Saturday, 7:35pm AEST, 23 August 2025, Eels v Rooster, Commbank Stadium, Parramatta
Sportsbet: Eels $3.20, Roosters $1.35
Weather: Could be Wet.
Referees: Wyatt Raymond (on-field ref), Adam Gee (bunker), Chris Sutton (touch judge)

Eels:
1. Isaiah Iongi
2. Zac Lomax
3. Viliami Penisini
4. Dylan Brown
5. Josh Addo-Carr
6. Joash Papali’i
7. Mitchell Moses
8. J’maine Hopgood
9. Ryley Smith
10. Junior Paulo
11. Kelma Tuilagi
12. Jack Williams
13. Dylan Walker
Bench:
14. Tallyn Da Silva
15. Charlie Guymer
16. Matt Doorey
17. Jordan Samrani
Reserves:
19. Haze Dunster
21. Toni Mataele

Roosters:
1. James Tedesco
2. Junior Tupou
3. Billy Smith
4. Robert Toia
5. Mark Nawaqanitawase
6. Hugo Savala
7. Sam Walker
8. Naufahu Whyte
9. Connor Watson
10. Lindsay Collins
11. Angus Crichton
12. Siua Wong
13. Victor Radley
Bench:
14. Benaiah Ioelu
15. Salesi Foketi
16. Egan Butcher
17. Spencer Leniu
Reserves:
18. Ethan King
21. Sandon Smith
Cut: 18. Dean Hawkins, 20. Dan Keir, 

22. Joey Lussick

Cut: 19. Blake Steep, 20. Taylor Losalu, 22. Tom Rodwell  

Coach: Jason Ryles

Coach: Trent Robinson 

INS
Dan Keir
Dean Hawkins
Haze Dunster
Toni Mataele
OUTS
Luca Moretti (season, calf), 

INS
Junior Tupou
Sandon Smith
Siua Wong
Taylor Losalu
Tom Rodwell
OUTS
Daniel Tupou

 

Sportsbet wooden spoon watch: Titans $1.57, Knights $2.30, Eels $34 odds have lengthened. Souths are off the list.

 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

      • No one really expecting much from Parra this week outside of the four walls at the club, need to use this to their advantage and ambush the chookies 

  • Chooks Rounds 1-18: 7 wins, 8 losses, 3 byes. Then Sam Walker returns for Round 19.

    Rounds 19-24 Chooks 4 wins, 2 losses. Those games? Chooks 31-14 (Dragons), 18-31 (Sharks), 30-34 (Storm), 20-4 (Manly), 64-12 (Dolphins), 32-12 (Dogs). It's obvious Chooks are a better side with Walker. 

    The Eels' high error rate and poor finishing of opportunities, and defensive frailties in their own red zone, suggest this is going to be a tough night and the Eels being within 20 points at full time might be the best outcome? Losing to the Bunnies should be a giant kick up the you-know-where, though, so will the Eels show greater competence and more energy and make a game of it?

  • Haze Dunster comes in for Lomax

    Mataele also coming in for Guymer or Samrani

    • You know this or guessing?.

      • Educated guess, Lomax wasn't at captains run, Dunster was on his wing.

        Mataele pulled from cup but at captains run today

        • We're u at the captain’s run Joel. Just asking 

          • No but I know somebody who was there

    • Have to be for Samrani we don't need another edge on the bench, looks like Lomax definitely wasn't training with them and haze was on that wing 

    • God help us. Just trial a jersey flegg  kid instead 

      • Let's see what haze can do, expectations definitely low for this game now but just don't lose by 30 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to Clintorian's discussion A Great Left Center Option
"Sure, see great player, look for connection and say "Sign him" rinse and repeat with new talent. Not that easy."
1 minute ago
Uncle Wizardssleeve- Indigenous Elder-Freemason Hunter -He/Him replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Are you Gus or Bulldog: Bullish or Bearish?
"As long as people still belive in this myth about our great junior nursery the worse we'll be . We need to recruit , plain and simple. We need to recruit at the top and recruit at the bottom.decades ago we had the great catchment of talent , now all…"
3 minutes ago
Eli Stephens replied to Who Cares's discussion Fridaynight Footy
"Galvin looks lost in the dogs system, what a dud signing "
8 minutes ago
Clintorian posted a discussion
Nick Meaney would be one of the first players I'd be trying to recruit for the Left Center position if I was Ryles. He is a gun in both defence and attack, can play Fullback and wing if needed, and has been a part of a very good system at…
12 minutes ago
More…