The Burramattagal Eels host the Cowboys for Indigenous Round. The Eels have not lost to them at Parramatta for a decade.
The gravevine is buzzing. An excited Dylan Brown returns at centre. The Simonsson Shock. The thunderclouds billowing over Payten's paddock and Burramatta land. But Ryles is keeping his head over it all and any scuttlebutt.
Teams List
Eels (15th) vs Cowboys (13th), CommBank Stadium, Sunday, 10 August 2025, CommBank Stadium, 4.05pm AEST
Weather: Rain likely, 55% humidity, 16C, Winds 17kmh
Sportsbet: $1.62 Eels $2.30 Cowboys
Referees: Liam Kennedy (on-field), Ashley Klein (bunker), Belinda Sharpe and Jon Stone (touch judges).
Eels: 1. Joash Papali’i 2. Zac Lomax 3. Viliami Penisini 22. Dylan Brown 5. Josh Addo-Carr 6. Dean Hawkins 7. Mitchell Moses 8. J’maine Hopgood 9. Ryley Smith 10. Junior Paulo 11. Charlie Guymer 12. Jack Williams 13. Dylan Walker
Bench: 14. Tallyn Da Silva 15. Luca Moretti 16. Matt Doorey 17. Kelma Tuilagi
Extended Reserves: 20. Haze Dunster 4. Jordan Samrani
Cut: 21. Toni Mataele 18. Ronald Volkman 19. Dan Keir
Head Coach: Jason Ryles
Cowboys: 1. Scott Drinkwater 5. Braidon Burns 3. Jaxon Purdue 2. Zac Laybutt 19. Semi Valemei 6. Jake Clifford 7. Tom Dearden 10. Jason Taumalolo 9. Reece Robson 17. Coen Hess 11. John Bateman 12. Jeremiah Nanai 13. Reuben Cotter
Bench: 14. Marly Bitungane 16. Kai O’Donnell 20. Nicholas Lenaz 22. Kaiden Lahrs
Extended Reserves: 18. Jaxson Paulo 21. Jamal Shibasaki
Cut: 4. Viliami Vailea 8. Harrison Edwardsm 15. Thomas Mikaele,
Head Coach: Todd Payten
Ins and Outs from last week
Eels—Ins: Dylan Brown, Kelma Tuilagi Outs: Sean Russell (hand, R27), Sam Tuivaita (knee, season).
Cowboys—Ins: Jason Taumalolo (returning from calf injury), Jake Clifford (returns from a quad injury), Viliami Vailea (returns from a foot injury), Thomas Mikaele (returns from a knee injury), Semi Valemei (returning from broken jaw). Outs: Robert Derby (knee). Reshuffle: Jeremiah Nanai returns to the backrow from centres last week.
A Parra Hoodoo
Round 13, 2015: The last time the Eels lost to the Cowboys at Parramatta. One man survives that game and plays this Sunday. Guess who? (Getty Images).
The Eels have won their last four-straight here.
The Eels have won 5 of their last 7 games against the Cowboys.
Josh Addo-Carr has scored 11 tries in 11 games against the Cowboys.
Zac Lomax has scored five tries in his last five games.
The Cowboys have lost 3 of their 4 games in Sydney this season.
Twinkle-toes, Scott Dancing Drinkwater, will be on the prowl looking to silence the Eels (Getty Images).
Source: Statsinsider
The Cowboys' Right Edge leaks more tries than a colander. It's the worst in the competition (conceded 55/101 tries). A Fox double? Expect Hawkins or Moses short kicks behind the line. The Cows like to rush up, resembling a tactical train wreck.
Similarly, the Eels' right edge is its Achilles heel. The fifth-worst in the competition (conceded 42/86 tries). This presents opportunities for their try-scoring freak, Jeremiah Nanai. Also, the dangerous Jaxon Purdue. And it might help make Braidon Burns and Jake Clifford look good. Expect Tom Dearden to float with a sweeping Drinkwater.
The newly-formed left side with Dylan Brown back and his partnership with Hawkins and Guymer is an unknown. But no doubt Deardon, Robson, and Drinkwater will look to exploit any vulnerabilities.
Meanwhile, both can be Shaky Stevens in the middle, conceded the same number of tries here. Expect Robson, Smith and Da Silva to have a crack.
Guymer's try (R22): David Copperfield meets Mark Waugh and goes blonde. (Getty Images)
Last Week: In the Arm Wrestle, But No Cigar
Last week, you could forgive Jason Ryles for having his head in his hands after yet another dropped ball in prime real estate against the Storm.
"They didn't beat us, we beat ourselves," he told us in the pressor.
He was right. Despite the obvious improvements in the Eels' resilience, consistency and structures, ball-control challenges have been a constant theme this year.
The match-winning moment of Aerial Kings. Coates outpoints Lomax.(Getty Images)
The short story. The game was won with a "F#@% Yeah" Coates Moment off a pinpoint Munster short-kick ten minutes from the final whistle. It came on the back of a barnstorming length-of-the-field-set off a less-than-urgent Eels kick chase. And where Utoikamanu steamrolled defenders like bowling pins.
The Longer story. 14 errors. Eight of those in prime Storm real estate. A gold medal in missed opportunities.
The Storm did enough, without being at their best. Professionalism.
"They've been doing it for twenty years, while we've been doing it for twenty weeks," Ryles added.
'Losing Sleep'
Todd Payten also felt the Cowboys were fighting-toe-to-toe with a top team. "We were in the game up to our eyeballs," he told us.
"[I saw] a team connected and fighting hard. But I'm losing sleep on ... parts of our game."
Both the Cowboys and Eels are in the top four for handling errors: Roosters are the worst (9th on ladder), then Cowboys (13th), Knights (14th), and Eels (15th).
Butterfingers
Eels (15th) | Cowboys (13th) | |
Recent Match-Up Difficulty |
Dark Night of the Soul (vs 2nd, 6th, 1st, 5th) |
Easier, but not super-easy (vs 7th, 8th, 11th, 3rd) |
Won 1 / 4 |
Won 1 / 4 |
|
Form |
Won 4 of their last 10 |
Won 3of |
Av. Points |
16.0 pg |
24.7 pg |
Av. Points |
25.3 pg |
37.7 pg |
Errors |
59 (14.75 av.) |
58 (14.5 av.) |
Games made |
15/19 (79%) |
12/20 (60%) |
'Dumb'
Ricky called his team "dumb" after 14 errors last week. We matched it. So did the Cowboys. An error-fest trifecta. In a wet round 22, let us never forget:
- 13 errors (67% completions) cost the Bulldogs (3rd) in their shock loss against the Tigers (9 errors, 79% completions), 28-14.
- 14 errors (64% completions) cost the Raiders (1st) in their shock loss to the Dragons (10 errors, 83% completions), 18-12.
- 14 errors (68% completions) cost the Eels (15th) against the 2nd-placed Storm (7 errors, 84% completions), 16-10.
- 14 errors (68% completions) cost the Cowboys (13th) in their heavy loss against the 7th-placed Sharks (13 errors, 79% completions), 32-12.
- Of course, there were exceptions. 16 errors didn’t stop the Roosters winning because Manly made 15. And then there's Souths.
There are a few morals of the story. Even the best get punished. Don't be dumb.
'Here in Body, Not in Spirit'
Plenty of experts have written off the Cowboys. Greg Alexander, the Panthers great, was scathing.
“It doesn’t happen very often in the NRL where a team makes it obvious that they don’t want to be here, but that is the Cowboys this afternoon,” Alexander said last week of the Cowboys in their Sharks loss.
“They are here in body but not in spirit. The Sharks are in cruise control and are tearing the Cowboys apart. I don’t know what Todd Payten says at half time."
"This is the worst performance I’ve seen from a team this year."
"They are the most disappointing side this year because they have more talent in their side than plenty of other rosters.”
And therein lies A Warning. Drinkwater, Dearden, Robson, Nanai, Cotter. A classy spine. A team littered with Origin class. Why are they playing so poorly for so long?
Dearden and Robson are two dangermen along with Fred Astaire (Getty Images).
Ryles is fully aware of it, telling us in yesterday's pre-game pressor, "They're a dangerous footy side that can score points quickly. They're well coached and highly skilled."
"We're going to have to defend really well."
Final Word
The Quixotic Cowboys have been off their game for months, slipping from sixth in round fourteen to thirteenth. They can scorch the land on their day, but they own the worst defence in the competition leaking almost 30 points a game. An elite Horror Show. But this is their chance at redemption.
The Kaizen Eels have improved their defensive and attacking structures over the last few months, but struggle to close out games despite being in the grind for most games since the early season. A patience and potential movie where hope is a leading character.
This game could end up being decided by who controls the ball better and executes their chances.
History, form and the Burramattagal Land Gods say the Eels. So does my head. But my heart knows better. Never turn your back on a desperate Cowboy. And Ryles knows it.
Spoon Alert: Rabbits ($1.91), Titans ($3.40), Knights ($5), Eels ($14), Dragons ($67), Cowboys ($76)
Footnote: Stats are supplied by Rugby League Project, nrl.com, Foxlab, David Middleton and Statsinsider.
Replies
Big win today in Jersey Flegg. Eels beat first place Storm 24-18. Both teams scored 4 tries but Lynn converted all of eels tries. We started off horrible with Storm scoring 2 tries quickly. Talagi dropped the ball of the kick off and Storm scored in the first 10seconds of the game. Thats how bad the start was. But eels cameback to win.
MoM for me was Australian Schoolboy Christopher Petrus who scored the match winning try and made 2 great try savers during the game. Always put his hand up for a carry and is making a case to skip SG ball next year and start the year straight in Jersey Flegg.
The forward pack really stood up today for me. We started with a full SG ball eligble forward pack against Storm who mainly have 20-21 years old in their full team. Our team today had THREE 18 year olds. Rokusuka was definitely caught out defensively today but due to promotions and injuries we got no choice. Leigh had some poor errors too but he is probably our 5th choice fullback.
Experience was only really in the halves and bench today. Neemia & Samuela was very strong too. Popo and Talagi were good too. Coinakis defensively strong. Halves had good moments too
Ethan Strange is 20 and killing it in FG.
Are we too conservative with our juniors' development?
this year we are definitely been less conservative. Tuivita going from JF to NRL within a preseason shows that approach. No nsw cup games as a 19/20 year old prop is crazy.
Then Nanva(21), Richie (20), Jez (19), Lokeni (20) all playing nsw cup this week too.
That's probably why he keeps getting injured. That's a huge jump and he plays in the toughest position.
He has but he's probably going to be an exception to the rule for every Ethan Strange there's an Ethan Sanders.I've always been of the addage that there isn't any rush and players aren't punching the same clock.
The only other question is realistically are what we producing good enough for early entry to FG.I mean of the squad now DB made his debut at 18 I think.
I also think the way we are bringing them through via interchange is also another way to bleed new players through increasing there loads as the physical and mental maturity grows.
Onething I've seen for sure is the nature and physicality of a 20 plus game season takes a toll on young players in alot of cases it's sink or swim hence why I think via the interchange bench is the perfect introduction to that sought of intensity.
Agreed. Penisini and Russel debut young as well.
Yep it's hard for Eels fans who've been starved of success for so long.
Development is the long game it should be never ending we should be stocking the shelves high in every position as deep as we can and supplement in the market place as we see fit not getting in the shit fight for the top tier guys like we are.
Tino is the latest but I'd be dead set shocked if 1 he'd even give us a look or 2 we have the guile and the resources to get a player of that caliber in the door.
Its why I think the slow burn is the correct route for our club.
FYI Petrus hasn't turned 18 yet. Still 17. Not sure what month. He turns 18
I haven't heard much about Lucien. Must be a gun to be 19 playing in the front row and keeping neemia out.
Great blog as always HOE !.
I think Lucien is just being used to absorb the collision at the start and use Neemia for impact. Lucien to me does not have a NRL future at this stage