Munster or Cleary ?

How do you compare the two halfbacks 

me personally I prefer Cleary. I think he will be even better in the future. But so is Munster unless grog ruins him. 
if you could buy one of those two. Who would it be 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Depending on your teams needs, Cleary is more of an organizer and would be more valuable on the open market 

  • Munster for me he is unpredictable while Cleary is Predictable. We don't need predictable we already have enough. 

  • As chief stated it depends on who your other half is but cleary is the more valuable player and is far more consistent than Munster, with Munster you get wow plays that you don't with cleary.

    If I was starting a team from scratch I would take cleary without hesitation. 

  • This reply was deleted.
    • That's what's unique about the storm, Hughes, Paps and Munster are all fullbacks 

    • I think he meant half's not halfbacks. 

  • This reply was deleted.
    • Gutherson isn't a centre. He's a fullback and maybe a number 9

  • Munster is a 5/8 not a halfback. 

    Dyl will be every bit as good as Munster by the time he reaches his age so we don't need Munster. 

    Cleary is the best halfback in the game but Moses is in the top 3 so happy to keep him.

    • Coryn and you a right Bem... someone obviously told Grunta at the funny farm that's what happens when you change what we now know is a very good spine.

      Why would/should change that when we have obviously issues in the centres, wings and edges (post this season)....

      Pereham at full back is average, he hardly cuts them up in Reserve Grade and whilst he is handy, he is not good enough, fast enough or tough enough, go back to planting "spuds" Grunts.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Eli Stephens replied to Joel K's discussion National Melbourne League
"he's never really found his feet at storm, be it injury or just others like Grant Anderson ahead of him. In and out a lot. I'd be sick of that "
1 minute ago
LB replied to Joel K's discussion National Melbourne League
"The issue is the NRL now threatening interference more likely leads to them bullying us into just letting him go. Melbourne and Lomax get their way and we sit there with nothing.
Like divorcing someone, you want nothing but the house, they agree to…"
4 minutes ago
LB replied to Joel K's discussion National Melbourne League
"Howarth is constantly picked. However, if Lomax joins it will be a back 5 of
Fa'alogo
Coates
Meaney
Lomax
Warbrick
 
Unless the plan is Howarth to the back-row not sure where he fits. Could be an option if he wants to start."
7 minutes ago
iamnot replied to Joel K's discussion National Melbourne League
"$200k from Melbourne as a transfer fee, plus an extra $1M per season added to our salary cap for 2027-2029 inclusive (no good having extra cap space for 2026). "
9 minutes ago
More…