Replies

  • Well it makes sense. They have Liddle signed til 2028. He is 31 next year. Watson for 2027 only. So Coinakis has a chance of being a 14 and even starting for Saints in 2028 if Liddle goes down, which he has been prone to do.

    With us, he could have been 14, though maybe Ryles prefers Trey-Stewart and even Bell behind him in 2028 onwards. 2027 we have Smith and Edwards behind Da Silva.

  • Not too bothered. Da Silva is 21 and has dibs, and if anything the 14 for us needs to be able to play in the pack elsewhere. 

    With Ryley Smith still around, not sure when Coinakis would've got anything other than another Flegg season.

    And he doesn't seem to be as rated by us as Fletcher and co.

    Again, one of those where you can't keep them all.

  • This just shows that the junior conveyor belt is starting to work. This is exactly as it's designed to be. Bring young players through and if they are good enough they play NRL. If not, they go elsewhere. The club just needs to retain the right players. There will be players further down the line to take up the gap left by Coinakis.

    • If the eels were a publicly listed company you would all be buying in at the wrong time. This was being built two years ago and every man and his dog on here has been slagging off at the club without a clue as to what's actually happening and giving the club the time it needs to execute the plan.

      • If the Eels were a publicly listed company and people were trying to say "it's all part of the plan" after the CEO just got tapped on the shoulder closely followed by the Head of Recruitment we'd be calling them crazy!

        FWIW I do agree our pathways have some strength to them, but we also have a history of overestimating our own nursery and losing some of the good ones so the scepticism is pretty normal and probably prudent.

        • I'm in the process of buying residential real estate as we speak. Do you know what counterintuitive means? Management turnover is a constant, it should take place on a regular basis and is healthy. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Parrafan101 replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Tryrell Sloan likely to replace Addo-Carr - Kent
"Salary cap relief, knowing parra we'll keep him so we can have an advantage to snagg someone. We are playing chess here."
22 minutes ago
Tin Tim replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Tryrell Sloan likely to replace Addo-Carr - Kent
"Parramatta are really thinking of the decision to release Ado-Carr, they are taking into account he a very popular player in the squad and the huge amount of work he does outside of football. He has endorsement which might be reviewed this is going…"
33 minutes ago
Adam Magrath replied to Roy tannous's discussion Lachlan coinakis signs with the dragons
"I'm in the process of buying residential real estate as we speak. Do you know what counterintuitive means? Management turnover is a constant, it should take place on a regular basis and is healthy. "
52 minutes ago
The Captain replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion This doesn't look.good
"Blows my mind how you can consider a team going from wooden spoon to the grand final in the space of a single season to be bad cap management.
If you want to rocket up the ladder you need to blow your budget, yes it makes future years harder but you…"
1 hour ago
More…