There is an alleged RLPA player poll being talked about in the podcast world that could provide explosive media click-bait when it's officially released soon.

Paul Kent’s May 25th podcast (from about the 34th minute) claims that around half the 56-57 odd RLPA poll respondents were senior players with 8+ years NRL experience (over 200 seasons of experience) and their concerns include:

  • half of the players don't enjoy game because of the new rules 
  • Over 80% believe referees dictating results 
  • a significant portion believe the refs influence games more than players
  • almost all believed intensity of the game and fatigue has increased significantly

What's interesting is this RLPA poll has been leaked before it's been made offical. 

Daz makes some valid points that this poll represents a very small sample and it could be widely misleading: "a coin toss".

Still, optics-wise, it’s not ideal, regardless of whether it's fair or not, representive of a broader playing group or not.

Whether that relatively small senior sample represents the broader playing group is difficult to determine. Younger players also have less to compare with than senior players. Also, senior players have a huge influence on younger players too.

It also clashes somewhat with the V’landyball marketing narrative of the game having record crowds, being bigger, faster, better and more entertaining than ever.

There are fans, including me, who aren’t entirely convinced either.

Average scores are now pushing beyond 50 points per game, the highest in history. 20 plus margins of blowouts are common now. Kent makes the valid point coaches fear fatigue: fatigue makes cowards of us all.

Not only that but the risk of injuries increase. With the clamp down on any head contact and force, even caused by ball-carriers falling into tackles, defences are pressured to be more passive.

Defences rarely can withstand more than 3 minutes of sustained pressure. 3 sets. That is based on the best the Panthers have defended without leaking a try.

Gus Gould has regularly commented on the unfair contest between attack and defence and it being next to impossible to have much defensive resilience, especially due to the new rules and huge number of restarts and penalties, and refereering interpretations and head-high issues.

All this doesn’t prove the game is “broken,” but it does suggest the ARLC and NRL should probably examine whether the balance between fatigue, speed, officiating influence and entertainment has shifted too far.

Some solid sources also suggest not all referees, privately, are on board with the new rules and where the game is heading and believe there is some bias.

Kent’s podcast also raised concerns about potential for match-fixing; integrity perceptions in the gambling era. It would be naive to think their aren't shady things happening in the game.

With the TV deal coming up, and Abdo resigning at an interesting point in time, it's food for thought for the game’s powerbrokers. A potential ticking time bomb.

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

    • I'm bored of it now, and you're right about Sportsbet etc, they control the game now, and these new fucking rules, I hate it, killed the game I loved since I was a kid, when scrums were REAL, where a biff ligtened the game up, now it'sd all frigging boring.

      • Totally agree. I've been round a long time and seen a lot of changes to the game  i used to love watching and playing as a young bloke now being an old fart and seeing the way the game has gone ive got to the stage of not being able to even watch a full game on the tv . I've been a member and season ticket holder holder for more years than i can remember and am getting to the stage of not really caring if i go to a home game or not . Some will say it's because of the way our team has performed the last few years . Maybe got something to do with it but mainly it's the way the game has turned into touch football but mainly due to the stupid six agains and the way the officials control the game. In closing this just not the game i grew up with and its just not my cup of tea anymore. Just my humble opinion 

  • Got blog HOE! Meanwhile Pete s on long service for 4 months.

  • As the late Jack Gibson said, only bet on those who can't feed themselves. Doesn't leave much other than horses and greyhounds. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Coryn Hughes replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Signing predictions !
"I'd suggest Milky and Tago as instant improvements and without a word of a lie it couldn't happen quick enough if we are in competition with others the odds are dropping by the minute.
I'd be shocked if Farnworth or any other elite player is looked…"
7 minutes ago
LB replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Signing predictions !
"Simonsson was already signed long term before that so Ryles had a plan for him. So makes sense just keeping him. 
Issue is why complain about not signing Katoa or Ramien? They are fine and are slightly better than what we have but there are options…"
15 minutes ago
Joel K replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Signing predictions !
"Lomax was a top 3 winger in the comp, I was never expecting a 1:1 replacement and I would've accepted Sami, Katoa or Cobbo.
its just the fact that we we ended up taking the easy option in bringing Simonsson back who had a cry and requested a release…"
24 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Kent: "Players Revolt & Ref Turmoil"; A Ticking Time Bomb?
"Not an intelligent response overall but "like your dementia" was funny and witty.
Now I have figured out that Mr Vlandy/s problem in your eyes is that he is "ugly" .....and I am the excitable child???
I don't squeal (defintely not with glee) unless…"
25 minutes ago
More…