Denan Kemp, the former Broncos NRL player and SEN commentator was equally scathing of the Eels as the officiating in the Eels’ Round 1 loss to the Melbourne Storm in his podcast.
“The jersey deserved better than that second half," he admitted.
“(But) The refereeing, especially in the first half, was unacceptable. Unacceptably bad refereeing.”
Kemp pointed to a period early in the match where the set restarts were heavily skewed.
“There was one period where the set restarts were 4–0 in favour of the Storm, and yet their average play-the-ball speed was faster than the Eels.”
“I just don’t get it. To have a faster average play-the-ball speed and also four consecutive six-again penalties.”
“How does that work?”
On the Captain’s Challenge adjudicated by the bunker, Kemp was even more direct.
“I couldn't believe what I was watching. That is disgraceful video refereeing.”
“You can see his arms literally going to pass the ball backwards.”
“What do you mean it hit the attacker’s arm off the defender’s arm?”
He also criticised the momentum shift created by repeated restarts.
“I don’t like that one of their first tries was because they went six-again, six-again, try.”
Kemp then referenced the controversial incident involving Iongi.
“My player has to go off for an HIA after a head-high and crusher and it’s not even a penalty.”
“It was really, really bad refereeing.”
Even some Storm fans at the ground were reportedly astonished at several decisions.
So let’s take a closer look.
High-Level Momentum and Fatigue Management
| 00:30 | PEN for Storm– Dangerous Tk | Hopgood Sin Bin |
| 01:27 | 6A for Storm | |
| 01:42 | Error Storm | |
| 01:53 | PEN for Eels – Slow Peel | |
| 03:17 | Error Storm | |
| 04:32 | 🏉 Try Eels – Russell | 0–4 |
| 06:53 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 09:37 | 6A for Storm | |
| 09:47 | 6A for Storm | |
| 10:27 | 🏉 Try Storm – Warbrick | 6–4 |
| 13:31 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 14:45 | 🏉 Try Storm – Grant | 12–4 |
| 16:49 | 6A for Storm | |
| 17:23 | Error Storm | |
| 18:57 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 19:53 | Error Storm | |
| 22:36 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 22:36 | CAPTAIN'S CHALLENGE FAILED | |
| 24:16 | PEN for Eels – 2nd Effort | |
| 25:00 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 25:17 | PEN for Storm | |
| 26:19 | 🏉 Try Storm – Howarth | 18–4 |
| 29:21 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 31:07 |
IONGI HIGH-CRUSHER HIA (no penalty) |
|
| 31:23 | 6A for Eels | |
| 35:01 | 6A for Eels | |
| 35:27 | PEN for Eels – Late Tackle | |
| 36:14 | 6A for Eels | |
| 36:33 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 37:27 | Error Storm | |
| 38:16 | ❌ Error Eels | |
|
Half-Time |
18–4 | |
| 40:58 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 41:20 | 6A for Storm | |
| 42:36 | 6A for Eels | |
| 43:04 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 45:14 | 6A for Storm | |
| 46:09 | 🏉 Try Storm – Chan | 24–4 |
| 48:39 | Error Storm | |
| 50:09 | 6A for Storm | |
| 50:26 | 6A for Storm | |
| 50:50 | 🏉 Try Storm – Grant | 30–4 |
| 53:24 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 53:26 | PEN for Storm – Offside | |
| 54:45 | Error Storm | |
| 55:00 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 55:43 | 🏉 Try Storm – Leo | 36–4 |
| 58:55 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 62:26 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 63:07 | 🏉 Try Storm – Faalogo | 42–4 |
| 65:08 | PEN for Storm– Professional Foul | Simmo Sin Bin |
| 66:37 | 🏉 Try Storm – Lisati | 46–4 |
| 69:08 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 70:03 | ❌ Error Eels | |
| 71:11 | 6A for Storm | |
| 71:51 | Error Storm | |
| 71:58 | PEN for Eels – 2nd Effort | |
| 74:47 | 6A for Eels | |
| 76:53 | 🏉 Try Storm – Faalogo | 52–4 |
| 79:07 | PEN for Eels | |
| 80:00 | ❌ Error Eels |
17-8 errors and 63% completions sealed the Eels' fate. So did 404 vs 278 tackles.
But, let's look at the time zones where restarts were awarded.
Graph: Time Zones for Set Restarts; Fatigue makes cowards of us all.
The Eels were only given set restarts in two small chunks.
Late in the first half, either side of the break — after the Storm had 18-4 on the board. And then late in the second half in the final minutes — after the Storm had racked up 46-4.
That's high-level fatigue and momentum management in effect.
And it is irrespective of intent, or if it is unrelated pay-back against the Eels' confronting and subpoenas of HQ in the Lomax-Storm saga the Eels won.
17 vs 3 sets
In between the 46th and 72nd minute the real damage was done.
The Storm had 17/19 sets compared with the Eels 3/6.
During that time the score went from 18-4 to 46-4 in the 66th minute.
During that time, the Eels made 150 vs 40 tackles, held the ball 3.5 vs 11 minutes.
How the Eels only managed to only concede one try in the last 14 minutes with 12 men for ten minutes of those with all that preceded is a miracle.
In the second half the Storm has 24 tackles vs 1 tackle in the opposition red zone.
Kemp's noted: "The silver lining here is Ryles can use that (game) for the rest of the season of like, boys, this is how far away we are from the top tier."
2026 could also be the Year of the Ref.
Summary of Questionable Refereering:
- Hopgood’s head clash resulted in a penalty and a sin bin and a two-week suspension, which seems excessive when compared to Crichton’s direct-head contact with Tu’s head which only resulted in a penalty.
- The HIA incident involving Iongi, which appeared high and a crusher, didn’t even result in a penalty.
- The Captain’s Challenge decision seemed dubious as Kemp noted, Ryley Smith's hands were clearly moving backwards at all times.
- From the 45th to the 72nd minute, the Storm completed 17/19 sets, compared with the Eels’ 3/6.
- During that same stretch, the score blew out from 18–4 at half-time to 46–4 by the 66th minute.
- The set restarts were 9-5 to the Storm.
- Kemp also makes the point that the Storm’s play-the-ball speed was faster than the Eels’, which makes the lopsided six-again restarts 4-0 at the beginning seem odd.
-
The only time the Eels received any set restarts was either side of half-time (31st–42nd minute) and very late in the game (from the 74th minute) , after the Storm had already those established decisive leads mentioned above.
Replies
If you look at the Brian Kelly "knock on" it's pretty hard to make an argument that Butler is that incompetent.
Considering the following night where Jenkins lost the ball in the tackle when it went forward and was called back? Funny who the team was that benefitted from it.
I mean it seems they don't even try to hide it anymore, it is like they think "Fans know it, they will just cop whatever we give them".
NRL thinks fans are idiots. Some are unfortunately.
This is very interesting HOE, great work as always.
Great to see Kemp seriously blast the refereeing publicly from a non-Eels neutral position.
He nailed both the Eels & officiating performances.
Eels vs Ref Bunker and the perfect storm
We all saw what we saw.
We also know for a fact (with evidence) that the Storm CEO text messages the NRL CEO and asks for favours.
So you'll excuse my tin foil hat for believing my very own eyes.
💯.... but here we all are watching this rigged comp. Must be some type of kink we all enjoy.
Todd Smith is not an NRL referee. If he is one of the games best, the game is in serious trouble. Where are all the good, consistent young referees coming through the system?
Parra need to ask the NRL for clarification on some of the decisions, because from what we saw, that was anything but a fair contest. And that's despite Parra's woeful capitulation.
Look at the rabbits v dolphins game souths won the penalty count 7-1 and dolphins got there first in 79min.
Kendoza,
In that game, set-restarts stopped being given between the 24th to 73rd min. In our game Storm got 9 restarts. That's more than Rabbits and Dolphins combined.
Restarts
04:47 — Rabbitohs
07:49 — Dolphins
09:05 — Rabbitohs
18:05 — Rabbitohs
24:18 — Dolphins
Stopped
73:47 — Dolphins
78:52 — Dolphins
Rabbitohs won restarts 4-3.
Rabbits won penalties too but with penalties you get a breather and reset your line. Penalties also stopped between the 38th to 70th minute, again letting the contest be decided by the teams during that period.
Penalties
01:28 — Rabbitohs
06:39 — Rabbitohs
21:32 — Rabbitohs
38:22 — Rabbitohs
Stopped
70:32 — Rabbitohs
71:03 — Rabbitohs
72:12 — Rabbitohs
76:28 — Dolphins
78:57 — Dolphins
79:44 — Dolphins
Rabbits won penalties 7-3
Effectively the ref let the game be decided by the teams more.
There was only one penalty — during the 24th minute and 70th minute — the time Souths stormed to a 28-10 lead from 12-10 and then the Dolphins came back to 28-22, and then Souths went to 40-22. A fairer contest.
Restarts and penalties after 70th minute all Dolphins way helped the Dolphins come back to 40-30.
Check the play by play at https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2026/round-1/dolphins-v-ra...
Hey mate,
I'm not trying to compare. I was just stating even the game yesterday souths were up 7-0 in the penalties how were souths perfect? The ref's are deciding the out come of games. Todd smith was a joke thurs nite.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 5 Next