Replies

          • If they were starting they would. Someone like Jenkins who left once and failed probably had that in mind.

      • He can't. Two types of fans realistic ones and the ones when you get flogged 50-6 they at least they tried.

      • Galvin was NEVER coming. Kean, why would you pay a million plus for him, I'm glad we didn't get him. As for Wilson, like LB stated, he is dumb. I can't believe so many are losing their shit over missing out on Wilson and Jenkins, Wilson is a reserve graders, and any winger would look good on the end of the Panthers backline.

        • Michael, Galvin was considering us. I know that. His family were pushing him to go to Parramatta but Luke Vella and Ciraldo pitch for him being 7 got him to Dogs. He considered us.

          Keaon on the other hand heard we had an meeting, but only offered a short deal, but it was mentioned not tabled. So technically could say we didn't even offer a deal. Now i know you and i disagree with Keaon but that deal i think is being overplayed how much we went for him. Personally i think we should have as his dad said he would have taken a reasonable offer.

          As for Jenkins, reason i and a few others are disheartened is not Jenkins himself, it is he is the best of what is left, discounting Taulagi as he seems odds on for Easts. I am a massive advocate of not signing for the sake of signing. Jenkins would not of been that as you are getting quality with good age and skills. But also, i would have chosen Taulagi over Jenkins too.

          As for Wilson, he needs to sack his managment. They have not steered him well at all. Imagine if he came to Parramatta in 2024? He would have played every game and in 2025 as well. 

        • People are losing their shit because we can't even sign such players you regard as a reserve grader and only looking good on the end of the panthers backline,  you get?.

          • Jenkins is better than reserve grader for sure. He is better than what we have, take out JAC.

            • He regards wilson as the reserve grader, which he is, and Jenkins as looking good at the panthers, both true. It's the fact we can't even sign players he considers as not worth worrying about is the reason we are worried. 

        • Sorry mate but if we put big money infront of Galvin Kolomatangi and Barnett we must have at least thought we had a shot at these players or what would be the point putting your best in front of them.

          Something is missing in the recruitment stakes.I don't know what it is but as a club and FG side if we keep losing these battles the war will never be won.

          Me I'm watching the sides assembled up at the Dolphins Newcastle and the Warriors and saying I want a piece of that pie.One person has had his finger prints on those sides and they have all turned the corner in the last 3-5 years.I'll say this now if we are going to recruit somebody that's making a huge difference in the recruitment stakes Parra need to be head hunting Peter O'Sullivan and they can't change the signage on a door in head office fast enough.

          Bin the whole R and R committee bin it rethink the whole space and anyone not named Jason Ryles is out.

          • O' Sullivan as well would have the ego to take the Eels job, to be seen as the one to change them. 

          • Coryn, was thinking the same watching the Dolphins last night. 

            O'Sullivan won't fix all the Eels issues, but it would be a huge first step. 

            He has the experience, success, the contacts & ability to communicate / sell a vision to players & agents.

            As LB said, the Eels challenge could appeal to him.

             

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Darren Munro replied to Nightmare Off-Season's discussion The Ticking Time Bomb
"I think JR is more likely to go to rooters more so than storm. Rooters should be top 2 with their roster. Jury still out on JR or our top squad. When we didn't have injuries we were still getting flogged most games. "
3 minutes ago
KingGutho replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R15 v Raiders: Response or Reward?
"Raiders by 16
the raiders forward pack will kill them!"
6 minutes ago
KingGutho replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Jenkins most likely to extend at Penrith (edit) signed
"MON probably offered him 100k a year and a backyard bbq at hes place. 
that tubby fuck needs to go as well as the rest of the board! 
I bet Ryles is getting sick of it "
11 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to Nightmare Off-Season's discussion The Ticking Time Bomb
"Great post, PT.  Always good to get your insight.
Your thoughts around a younger assistant is interesting too, that ability to communicate to this generation seems to be having an impact with Foran at Manly."
13 minutes ago
More…