Gutho Vs Hayne. Who ya got?

In light of Gutho's stellar season and Dally M contention, who would you have in your team?

Two vastly different playing styles, Guthos all out consistent effort and professionalism vs Haynes game winning talent but hot and cold attitude.

Who do you want as your fullback?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Hayne. On his day, not even Melbourne could fully contain him. He was made for big time games. Much as I do like Gutho

  • Hayne but like you said different style of player. Gutho is getting better all the time. He deserves the Dally M

  • Hayne.

  • Jarryd at fullback. The bloke was a genius.

  • I know its a hypothetical question BUT if Gutho had Haynes' pace it would be a no brainer a bit like ?

  • Hayne

  • Gutho every day of the week.  Team player, team builder, a leader and respected by his peers and coach, then there is Hayne. 

  • Gutho, week in week out his work ethic and team first attitude can't be compared to. 
    Hayne was brilliant but Gutho for me.

  • Hayne was as naturally gifted a player as there ever was, but he had a poor attitude. Gutho is all heart and professionalism, if Gutho had a meter more pace he would be the best player in the game today. So I choose Hayne, you can change a players attitude if you have the right skills, but you can’t make a genius and Hayne was one on the footy field, sometimes. 

    • Agree re talent, but please tell me how he is better for a team?

       

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Michael W. replied to Eels2025's discussion Does anyone have hope for the rest of the season?
"The rules allow these blowouts. Playing with 12 for 20mins, 6 against, most on 4th or 5th tackle. No team can come back from that, especially when a team as good as Melbourne have 10 and 12 tackle sets. Playing catch up footy just compounded the…"
4 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to Eels2025's discussion Does anyone have hope for the rest of the season?
"Sounds weird but not a lot has changed for me.
We were never a chance of genuinely competing for a Premiership in 2026 the moment DB left and we failed to replace him (Galvin, anyone else who’s an actual 5/8th).
No team has won a Premiership with a…"
12 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Roy tannous's discussion Attracting big names problem
"NO !"
12 minutes ago
Clintorian replied to Eels2025's discussion Does anyone have hope for the rest of the season?
"Honestly, I felt like we were done last night. I was absolutely ropable.
But after calming down and being a little more reflective rather than reactive, remember we started shit last year while missing Moses and had a NSW Cup team, and then came…"
13 minutes ago
More…