Forward Pack Ratings

I was listening to Scott Sattler and Matt Rogers tonight, who rated their top eight forward packs on paper for next year. Neither of them rated our pack in the top eight. They even made specific mention of RCG now at the Titans. Yes, he is gone, get over it as I will be told and so be it. Our forwards were imo our strength for the past four of five years. Yes, they could both be proven wrong and I hope they are , but for our pack to not to be rated in the top 8 by two experienced subject matter experts is worrying.  I don't perceive bias from either of these guys. I hope this stuff motivates the forward pack to prove them all wrong.  The modern game needs impact forwards and a pack that endlessly hunts in defence. I always rated our pack and was surprised to see them not even mentioned in the top eight packs.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • When we lost our forwards got beaten up

    Either with low impact in attack 

    Most telling was how ineffective in defence we where at our best our pack was good the game has sped up and our big pack got found out.

    In the big games Paulo consistently lost his battles so based on that I think it's reasonable to suggest that we shouldn't be rated high at this point

    • So would it be a fair assessment that Junior was the over paid and non performing forward that should have been released?

      • He had two years left on $900k or RCG one year left on less and wants to go. Who is easier to get rid of? Can't just go to Paulo and say "you're gone" and he goes.

      • That wasn't  a option. 

      • Yep but I reckon be hard yo find a taker for him

  • It's going to be interesting to see how the Titans go.

    Theres been a huge trend in the game for mobile forwards . Penrith led the charge with Leota and Fish and an ex edge in Yeo playing 13. The game has got really fast and slower forward packs are being left behind ( see us and Souths 2024 ) . Titans have a huge pack and added RCG. It honestly could make or break them . If it breaks them the same blokes that ranked them 1 this year will b staying they're rubbish next year. That's how the rugby league media works . 

    On paper Titans look like a side that will be good with possession and horrible without it . Story of their lives . 

    • That Pahulu theory is wild but. 

      • Even more wild Gus is first to get wind of whats going on at a number of clubs. Got to have more contacts across the game than anyone else that bloke.

      • What's the theory?

  • Bulldogs pack would of ranked 17th last year. I don't really care what they say tbh

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

The Captain replied to Angry Eel's discussion Hypothetical Question
"Honestly, yes. Prime Hayne was that good. He was a one man team and he did almost take us to a premiership almost completely on his own.
Semi was great, but Hayne was on another dimension in his prime year. I've never seen such a dominant player as…"
3 minutes ago
The Captain replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Signing predictions !
"One player? Xerri looks like a strong possibility given his issues with the Bulldogs. He'd be a good pick up.
There's lots of noise about Jenkins - he had an amazing start to the season, but the rest of his career has been pretty average. He's made…"
7 minutes ago
Hell On Eels replied to Fiddy's discussion Burton to Eels?
"NOS, We just lost Keaon. Bon Voyage.
$1.05m for five is overs for Dylan – but if Ryles is desperate – deal.
Naturally, the only way Dylan would forgo the Knights extra $8m is to sack everyone and use O'Sullivan's scorcery and Richo's year-by-year PO…"
11 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Signing predictions !
"Jenkins, Burton, Xerri - and a front rower.
Ford as others have said would be great. But Warriors likely wouldn't let him go with Barnett leaving?"
1 hour ago
More…