Replies

            • No I think Asi is more suited to the NRL than Hawkins. That's why he's played three times as many NRL games despite being a year younger. I'm sure we would've liked to have kept Asi as a backup but he is too good to be a backup (and not quite good enough to be a starter in the NRL). So it's off to the UK he goes.

              • I liked Asi, but he and Hawkins are two different styles of player. We need a Halfback, Asi was a Five-Eighth. But Asi was not going to stay as a back-up any longer, therefore Hawkins comes in. We needed an organiser, that was the issue with Brown and whoever partnered him. Hawkins at least can organise somewhat as an actual Halfback.

              • I liked Asi, has some good skills and an underated kicking game but was inconsistent. We dont have Harry as our hooker so we do need an organiser. Hawkins would have played a lot more 1st grade this year if he wasnt out injured long term. Ive watched a bit of him and he looks like he is a solid all round halfback .

                • Yes, and I think ASI is a reserve grader, until he can defend he will always be a heartbreaker.

                  Probably will go well in the UK where it seems halves don't have to defend to a standard as high as the NRL.... that is the difference Pou, and how many games ASI has played is semantic and circumstantial. If Moses and Brown were always available, he would have played none. Face it, we needed a back up half, if ASI was the choice he would have stayed. 

                  Lets say we had Hawkins and Asi playing reserve grade as halves, do you think that Asi would play half ahead of Hawkins? NO

      • Thank you

    • We needed a backup half since the previous one left for greener pastures. We did have a backup 5/8, but no one really who could play half. I'd hope he is only required to fill in at NRL during SOO.

    • He will only play 3 games unless Moses gets a long term injury. No way ur negative about a proper backup

      • Any old halfbacks a proper backup. Morgan Harper is classed as a proper backup centre too. Does not mean they're the quality needed . We need a player of decent calibre because if one of our halves goes down our season is automatically shot right now.  It's not even debateable. Our season is done as we've invested so much in our halves and Dylan's useless if it's Moses that goes. 

        This is just an indication of how poor our cap shape is. 

    • Wiz, cmon bro, Hawkins shats all over our previous back up 7s. 

       

      12975994666?profile=RESIZE_930x

    • Not quite sure what you want? ASI went to super league for more money.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐 posted a discussion
1. Iongi 2. Fox3. Russell 4. Samrami/Penasini 5. Simmonson 6. Pezet7 Mo8. Jnr 9 Smith 10. Hopgood/ Williams 11. Kelma Tuilagi 12  kit Kautoga 13. Debelin 14. Da Silva 15. Sam Tuivaiti 16. Walker17. Doorey  * Kelma did enough and is a strike weapon…
6 minutes ago
Coryn Hughes replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R2 v Broncos: Back on the Horse
"He's not running from there the defense is too compressed that extra step is taking time off  Pezet the only reason the kick is an option because his times gone.
Go back and have a good look at TDS's service it's the worst part of his game the fact…"
7 minutes ago
SuperEel 22 replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R2 v Broncos: Back on the Horse
"That pass is actually an example of good dummy half play. That close to the line you're not going to beat the defenders with a pass straight off the ground. His step back and dummy holds up the A and B defenders which sees the outside men come up…"
1 hour ago
Richard Jackson replied to Roy tannous's discussion Jdb junior paulo 👉🚪👋
"Pop, next time when Moses is out, the next man up unquestionally, should be Apa Twidle. This guy is a playmaker and leader, and he is ready.
And so I don't want to lose him, as believe me he's getting noticed by everyone looking for young talent.
My…"
1 hour ago
More…