I am starting to think we have the dumbest supporters on here .... watched they way we manouvre and undermine any failures.
The relentless criticism and then the undermining of the coach, front office etc indicates some people cannot just understand the current problems.
Players were pretty pathetic today and I honestly think with the injuries and dislocation of being maimed that we will be lucky to win another game this season......Can we fix it, I doubt it, it is not an actual lack of effort it is more a lack of ability.
We have two backs with any pace and real class, both obviously carried injuries, you all being such determined critics out there realising Moses could not run, or place kick. JAC's ribs are so heavily strapped he had problems breathing. Joash Pappilli tried hard, never dropped a high ball but had no support, Penisini has come back early from injury, Kelly is just a pathetic mess from a once competent player, Volkman was honest and the debut winger also honest. Realistically both Volkman and the new kid are not first graders. You can use players like that in one off's but not as regular first graders. It really was a non existent backline and the length of field tries that were put on us reflects that.
Our forwards I cannot defend them, but I do know that you only need one or two key defensive players out and you are buggered. If your backs cannot carry out defence, then the forwards will always be run ragged.....tell me you understand this?
See I can defend my team, why cannot you at least attempt to understand our situation. Last year Souths had similar problems, their supporters stuck with them, we don't have the talent that they have, it will be interesting to see if we keep our new St George players after he watches and see's this result but no we will blame MON for losing him and anyone else that wants to come.
NB Anyone that wants to sack the coach is a non thinking moron, he can only work with what he has and I am sure he is trying as hard as he can to come up with a side to play canterbury next week.....good luck with that one Jason. I don't envy your attempting to make something out of a club like Parra, but we stalwarts will support you.
Final point rather than being perenial pessitmists laced with disloyalty, try coming up with some solution's and commitments to support the coaching staff through this period of "seeming disaster" without coming with your fantasy solutions.
Replies
Agree
I agree that you agree.
I thionk you need to qualify the idiots and then their replacements Badge, but we all know where you are coming from.
Simply Hamstrung implies something, I am just no sure how simple it is.
Last year Souths had similar problems, their supporters stuck with them, we don't have the talent that they have
Pops you nailed it in this sentence right here (bold is my emphasis).
We are in a salary cap constrained sport. Our Top 30 squad is worth the same as every other Top 30 squad. Our squad is sub par, both our top line squad and our top 30 depth. We can't just keep thinking of excuses that are out of our control, that's not how winners win. So we have injuries, that's why you have a 30 man roster. Injuries didn't force us to sign us Pezet and Kelly and JDB. We chose to do that.
The fact is our talent is sub par, and that is OUR fault, no one else's.
BTW, that ravaged Rabbitohs squad from last year still managed to beat us.
Souths only had 50 on them twice last year, one from Dolphins who were close to the 8 and Brisbane the premiers and both away. We had 52 put on us but one of the worst teams in the comp at home. Yeah injuries have weakened us massively but nothing excuses that. Our defence was a concern before this.
With Kautoga getting hooked, Ryles seems to think it is not an excuse either.
I think is chicken and Egg Cappy. Souths for a reason I am not sure of seems to have a better reputation to have a football team.......than the Parramatta Club for some reason has been making its own bed, and now has problems of getting into it with someone! anyone?
I honestly think the problem is very simple. We are soft through the middle. We lack size and strength particularly at prop and get rolled by teams with elite front rowers. You fix that and get some guys healthy, you'll win games.
That Campbell try just after HT, markers got split, Pascoe ran through, as marker couldn't touch as he wasn't square, and just utilised the space. Our middles were the main concern today, and have been all season to be fair. Su'A will help but we need minimum two more middles.
That wasm't the problem last year.....personally I blame the Pevitt experiment.....people say that is Ryles bed, yes it is, I don't think he needs to be crucified for it just the same.....we have some clairvoyants on here that read minds, maybe Ryles should be consulting them?
He also didn't cause the season ending injuries, the HIA's and the referreeing.
I agree the Pezet move was dreadful. I admitted that we had him so had to support him and what Ryles sees. No defending it now, it was an awful move. A move that was touted as brilliant and never 100% got on board with the idea. Ryles agreed to it and perhaps even was the one that brought up to go for him, but him along with MON, Rogers, Sarantinos and whoever else is on the committee are at fault for that move.
People are blaming MON, yet i doubt highly there is one player that has come to this club since Ryles got here that he didn't agree to having. He would have final say on a player that is brought to him. So Pezet, de Belin, Kelly who have not worked out, Ryles surely would have agreed to.
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 7 Next