Replies

  • Off topic a lil here but

    Let's be real here

    Our spine should've still been

    mahoney (9)

    Moses (7)

    Brown (6)

    RNR fkd up in a lot of different ways. 

    • Mahoney one was Matt Arthur was the future.

      • That's correct. 

        The bush coach didn't want anyone blocking boods Arthur.

        Also.  Jakey would be our 6 if ba wasn't still in the joint and the fans didn't stand up for the club

    • what about Gutherson at (1). ........it will make Chief's day if you can pull that one out of your arse.

      PS Mahoney and Moses didn't get on, Brown got an offer he could not refuse and Gutho got a retirement package to take him into his sixties......Moses only survivor and he is overated, R&R could get rid of him.....then we could play with a new spine!

      • Gutherson at 1? Poppa you now need to put coins into the swear jar 🫙 . And knowing popo, he's that tight he pulled the globe light out of his fridge.   True story 

      • If RNR didn't put PO options every year in browns deal he still would be here on a long term deal.

        Mahoney and Moses didn't get on but we were 80 mins away from ending a 40 year hoodoo rightio buddy the RNR lowballed him offered him 450k-500 or something like that at the time. 

    • Parra boy let's not forget when Norman and Moses were at each others throats and playing shit. R&R gave them both the choice to leave. Here below is an excerpt from AI that i asked.  so take it however you want re AI product, but R&R has been a problem for a while. Fancy telling Moses he can leave. Gulp! For the record Mark O'Neill joined the club in R&R in 2018.

       

      Following the Parramatta Eels' disastrous 2018 NRL season, where they finished with the wooden spoon, management determined that the halves partnership of Corey Norman and Mitchell Moses was not working and that one of them had to leave
      . 
      NRL.com +1
      Here are the key details regarding the situation:
      • The "One Must Go" Directive: After a 0-5 start and a poor overall season in 2018, it became apparent the duo "just didn't work on the field". Club management decided to split the pair to change the team's dynamics.
      • The Targets: While many assumed Corey Norman would be the one to leave, the Eels also told Mitchell Moses that he was free to explore his options elsewhere, despite having joined the club only the year prior.
      • The Outcome: Corey Norman was ultimately released from the final year of his contract and joined the St George Illawarra Dragons for the 2019 season.
      • Moses' Reaction: Moses later revealed it was "heartbreaking" and "upsetting" to be told he could leave, but he ultimately remained at the club to lead the team in 2019
  • Dodged a bullet there. The last thing we need is to spend 800k for 3-4 years on an ageing forward. 

    Mind you, we are never going to get an instant Premiership without a sombrero. Those who think otherwise are fooling themselves. The reality is that we need to build excellence from the ground up, using our juniors. Once we start winning consistently we will attract the star players.

    • Great points you made Longfin  in your second paragraph! Totally agree with you, pretty clear we can't attract big names maybe we have to focus on keeping our worthy juniors right now and build from there. Realistically build this year. We must do this now vip with so many new options looming! Ryley, Tuivati, Brown and others need securing now!

      Buying big names with big TPAs (or even location attractions) is clear. Buying big names off limited cap dollars (as we seem to do), means no moula to keep up and comers... which right now we have a substantial number of great prospects (at last). They'll be firing next year or thereabouts and I feel this is how we are left to do it panthers style with a big core group who have played together...just  need to focus on purchase of a couple of outside backs still... we don't seem to have at all. Time to raid the neighbours now! Bring them in now. Prepare for a window starting next year and further. It definitely ain't this year :(

      Realistically, as you say big names don't often go to bottom half of comp in western suburbs, no beaches etc no huge TPAs and at least becoming consistent and a realistic chance of vying for premiership will improve greatly our chance of attracting few big names.

  • That's a shame.  I wasn't really sold on him due to his age unless he was replacing Junior or Hopgood for a year or 2 max but then this came up on my feed and he was smashing Nathan Brown. 

    It was when he was young but even when Brown played for us I thought he was a dickhead so good to see someone put 1 on his chin.

    https://www.facebook.com/share/v/1EaAqobPjz/

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

macybrown replied to Muttman's discussion Barnett signs with Broncos
"Great points you made Longfin  in your second paragraph! Totally agree with you, pretty clear we can't attract big names maybe we have to focus on keeping our worthy juniors right now and build from there. Realistically build this year. We must do…"
11 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Muttman's discussion Barnett signs with Broncos
"Parra boy let's not forget when Norman and Moses were at each others throats and playing shit. R&R gave them both the choice to leave. Here below is an excerpt from AI that i asked.  so take it however you want re AI product, but R&R has been a…"
28 minutes ago
Mallee57 replied to Muttman's discussion Barnett signs with Broncos
"Brisbane is a better place to live than Sydney in my opinion. Maybe Barnett and other possible signings thought the same way"
30 minutes ago
macybrown replied to Muttman's discussion Barnett signs with Broncos
"Im very happy to hear that HOE. Coz the last thing we need is an outside back less. With Will out, Samrani in we basically have no one else (going off what Kelly showed).still wish we'd keep quiet in future on those we chasing...seems like we have…"
30 minutes ago
More…