Replies

        • I'm miffed as to why we didn't have a crack at the May brothers.

          Both would have at least on field fixed a number of our issues.

          As for Simmo , if we went to market for a decent centre I'd struggle to find a spot for him, I'm a big fan of  Stanford To'a .

          Put some speed or power  outside that man and you've got a  lethal right edge.

          I'd like to see Ryles use Russell and Samrani in the same way , have a shootout to see who can cover backrow and centre the better leading into 26 and they get a bench spot at least for a large part of the year.

          Back to Simmo if he's on the reported $500 thousand odd a season and can't fully establish himself in the starting 13 it makes sense you'd let him go and rely on your developing juniors for salary cap reasons.

          Simmo is too good for Reggie's but hasn't taken his chances enough in first grade.

          Ryles to me looks like he's only moving forward with players whose best and worst games are closer apart then your rocks and diamonds type players or those that have a good game one week and quiet the next few.

          He's playing players in first grade who offer him consistency, albeit allowing the younger members off the side leeway with mistakes but is seemingly unforgiving of the older members of the playing group lacking consistency.

          Which I'll go out on a limb and assume that's why Simmo, Matto and the like have got the shits.

          If that's the case the older players should know better and I agree with Ryles.

          • Hey Bup,

            Could be correct, absolutely.

            If there is a superior centre on the way, or if Lomax is headed back to centre, and we are purchasing a winger, it will make more sense. Hopefully, this is centred around incoming recruitment.

            On consistency, Hopgood (as much as I like him) has probably been the most inconsistent player this season? His errors have been very poor. He hasn't been dropped. So question remains what has happened with Simo since he was re-signed last season? Thought Bailey had been pretty good this year when on the field, outside a few defensive lapses, injuries his biggest issue.

            Anyway, we don't have all the info yet, see what happens I guess. Not losing any faith in Ryles, it's just this one stands out compared to others.

             

            • Hopgood at locks been poor , at prop he's been very good.

              I wouldn't be surprised if Hopgoods the next bloke to ask for a release.

              Players that like to ball play a bit generally don't take it well when their asked to put the cue in the rack.

              It certainly looks like we're positioning ourselves to make a significant play in the player market.

              One thing about Ryles is he seems to be communicating exactly where players stand in his plans early and succinctly, he's not placating anyone.

              There seems to be a seismic shift in accountability, not all players will respond well to that.

               

              • Bup, insightful comments as usual.

                I suspect our 2026 moves will largely depend on if we can (and how fast) move on Matto, Hands, Lane, Simo from 2026+ contracts. Lots tied up there.

                Our cap looks set to be cleaned up for 2027 onwards.

                 

                • 27 is the year next year we need to continue to build and evolve our style of play and continue the defensive improvement.First contact right now isn't upto it imo.

    • Completely agree NOS! I was excited for his return to the side because, in my book, he is in our best 17 every day of the week!

  • Opens up another spot on the top 30 roster for next year I guess.

    Not worried about the reasons now if he's been requested a release so be it I won't be losing my sleep losing Simonsson.Onwards and upwards regardless of whose done what.The coach has made a decision move on let's find someone else.

    • Yes agreed here Coryn

      • yeh! but it is a strange one that bears some explanation.....it does show just the same that all the logic and bullshit being thrown at recruitment ......is something we haven't a clue about?

        Finally just to add a bit of salt to the wound....i have not been able to fathom Moses negative body language in last weeks pressor, i was trying to see past it at the time, but it was hard to think no, it was nothing Ryles was saying?

        This weeks game will tell us a lot!

         

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

LB replied to Axel's discussion Matto open to stay in England
"Well Matto is $700k alone apparently "
55 minutes ago
Flow Basket replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Bailey Simmonson requests release
"We are young and thx to Jr we r organised but without lomax and Moses we lose.with our money I think it needs to be spent on an organising halve top shelf "
55 minutes ago
KingGutho replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin's discussion Bailey Simmonson requests release
"I wouldn't be releasing Simonson, unless there is a player swap. "
56 minutes ago
shane replied to Eels2025's discussion Round 23 - Team List
"Only have to get rid of Moses,Penisini, Paulo and Hopgood and Ryles will near have a new team that wasn't under BA. Maybe the way to go, a new begining and era."
2 hours ago
More…