BA to the Tigers?

Brought up last week on the Sunday Footy show. If anything it will not happen, but if Wests want a coach to get them relevant, BA is a good start. To be fair BA can coach, getting Wests to at least in the 8 would be a massive achievement at this stage.

Michael Chammas brought it up around 1:30 mark. Also mentions Ciraldo taking over as he is courting the job apparently. Again not speculating simply showing everyone what was said.

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 1
Email me when people reply –


      • Great: Of an extent, amount, or intensity considerably above average.

        Good: Having the required qualities; of a high standard.

        Adjectives, like pronounciation, are important to convey meaning.

        Helping uncle Jack, off a horse.

        Helping uncle, jack off a horse. 

        • lol

    • The players under their mantels were envious incomparison to this day and age. Can I give a mention here to Tim Sheens who also knew how to coach and very successful. I rate extremely highly. 

  • BA to the Tigers make a heck of a lot of sense - as much as it pains me to think of BA at another club, he is a good first grade coach and whilst he may not have it in him to get the Eels to a premiership, the position he's brought the Eels to over these past years shows a pretty amazing development coach.

    Some coaches are specialists at development, getting a club from cellar dwellers to regular Finals competitors - and given that the Eels have now remained in the Top 8 longer than any team in the NRL competition, no one is more credentialled at this task than BA.

    As for the Eels, we're probably at that point where we need to take a punt on someone. And Ciraldo certainly seems like the punt worth taking. He comes from a great system and knows what sustained success looks like - he is untested as a head coach so it could go spectacularly badly, but fortune favours the brave and part of success is knowing when change needs to happen even when there is risk involved.

    BA to the Tigers, Ciraldo to the Eels - it just makes sense. This is all post 2022 season of course. We'll do the "end of season review", Arthur will be asked politely to resign, he'll fall on his sword and we'll announce Ciraldo as the next coach. Following that the Tigers will announce BA as their new coach. These discussions need to be going on now behind closed doors, this needs to be managed in advance and managed well - Arthur should have already been told that it's Grand Final or bust for him. Ciraldo should be told the same (and given that he just extended with the Panthers for 2023 I assume he has, or at least considers himself short priced favourite for the role).

    Arthur gets to establish himself as the rebuild coach specialist and have a "Take 2" at trying to build a premiership winning squad. Ciraldo gets to step out of the Penrith Systems shadow and test himself on the big stage. The puzzle pieces fit quite nicely.

    All will happen prior to the new year.

    The only thing that changes that is the Eels making a Grand Final this year.

  • BA is the perfect fit for the Tigers.

    And we need a new direction I think we are a good fit for Ciraldo

    • Offside,

      We know very little about Ciraldo.

      • To be honest, that's part of the appeal. We know too much about too many other options to know they're not worth pursuing (Madge, Barrett, Flanno, Green, NBrown etc). Of the up-and-comers in coaching land of recent years there were always two big names: Ciraldo and Fitzgibbon.

        Fitzgibbon is off the market and looking pretty good in his first season. That's what we'd be hoping to emulate with Ciraldo. 

        This season will show if BA has truly hit his ceiling and peaked as coach - if he has, Ciraldo is definitely the pick of the bunch in terms of who's available in the market right now.

        • Well Cap, i would say Ciraldo could be better than Fitzy, and we have a better line-up than Cronulla this year, so who knows who Ciraldo could do.

          Ciraldo is very smart and patient operator, he would not take any job. Other coaches on the market would. Other than one of the supercoaches who will never be available, not everybody is going to be happy with who we hire. Ciraldo at least is top choice of numerous teams.

  • Great coaches leave the joint in a better place in which they received it.

    • Good coaches do that, great coaches win multiple titles and the best do it with different clubs. Some people here are sloppy with their usage of adjectives, we have words to convey different meanings, otherwise everyone is great, everyone is a winner.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

paul taylor replied to adnan's discussion Game Vs Souths
"WE have to play direct through the middle, off loads and then give Dylan and co room to square up his opposite.  Seriously dont know how we stop their signature plays.   If Waqa stays out and JA and Penisini slide we are a chance. Fractured line and…"
2 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to adnan's discussion Game Vs Souths
"Bingo, Mutt.
I think Jake is going to have a tough night also, Latrell is going to be coming at him at full speed all night. Ice will need to be a body guard."
42 minutes ago
Nightmare Off-Season replied to adnan's discussion Game Vs Souths
"We defend as we did against Manly in the second half. No matter what is happening inside, Sivo & Waqa didnt jam in, they slid & gave time for Penisini & Opacic to cover. Saab had 4 line breaks in the first half, and zero in the second after BA made…"
48 minutes ago
Muttman replied to adnan's discussion Game Vs Souths
"Slide. Souths rarely hit the lead runner and almost always play out the back to a very deep backline. No need to jam in. Souths want you to jam in, they're banking on it. Move up and slide, they'll run out of room."
50 minutes ago