Ok so last night started with Fullback and it was Hayne in a canter. Now the next one are Wingers.
Now because there are two Wingers, it will be the top two highest votes. If it is a landslide and the second vote is low or close, i will redo this survey taking out the leader.
1. Hayne
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
Replies
Damn it Chief, now I need to redo the survey. I also forgot Wise Kativerata, Mal Kaufusi, Brett Anderson and the likes.
It might annoy some here but do I maybe do a survey for worst 17? Hahah.
Yes how good would a worst 17 be lol. You can absolutely bet that it would be full of brad arthur purchases - think Issac lumilumi, Zack Cini, Werimu Greig, Momosia, joey Lussick, Kane Evans, Jack Murchie, and the list could go on forever
Chiefy, our recruitment of 2010-2013 is elite levels of bad. Paul Whatuira, Chris Walker, Carl Webb, Nathan Smith, Luke Kelly, Ben Roberts, Justin Poore, Reni Maitua, Jordan Atkins, Rory Brien, Esi Tonga, Willie Tonga 2.0, Jake Mullaney and Chris Hicks.
If Justin Poore, Luke Kelly, Nathan Smith and Chris Walker aren't in it, I don't want to hear about it.
It will be a vote, so depends on what the 1EE people suggest.
I tried a few years ago to do a worst 17 and got absolutely abused, fairly enough as it is an achievement to play FG and for Parramatta regardless how good you are. But at the same time i think it is fair game to critique.
Once this modern day 17 is done i will do worst modern day 17. There are names that can be put in there.
I think you could frame it as worst recruits or something. You're right, in that first grade is an achievement regardless. But as fans we can also have our say on which players either weren't right to recruit or who we over-spent on.
Semi and Maiko as not a lot of wingmen stand out in this mod era. Stay with this LB there will be much more debate on the centres
Centre's is going to be good one. As will be Hooker i believe.
Luke Burt and Semi Radradra
Justice for Ash Graham
-
1
-
2
-
3
of 3 Next