1Eyed Eel

Parramatta Eels Supporters Website

Unicorn question - Why shouldn't BA be sacked

For all the remaining Unicorns on this site - this is your last opportunity to save Arthur.

Why shouldn't BA released ?

Views: 2539

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Because at this stage there is no better option on the table . Put one on the table that’s a possibility and you’ll have my answer . 

BA vs who Kidwell ? I’ll still take BA 

BA vs Bennett ? I’m leaning Bennett now . 

BA vs Toovey (Maybe)

BA vs Hasler (No thanks)

BA vs Bennett (Probably the best option)

BA vs Maguire (Maybe)

BA vs Justin Holbrook (Know nothing about this guy, but have seen his name mentioned)

Any other suggestions?

Walker Brother's?

Justin Holbrook is a very very good target . But he’s only just started his ESL coaching career . After 2 seasons over there I will say right now he will be a fantastic NRL coach . Getting him now would mean we would have to endure a season or two of him adapting to the big time . Given the cut throat nature of the NRL coaching gig , he’d be a fool to rush in now and stick to enjoying learning his trade over there.  

Personally id do either , 

Stick with BA for the remainder of his contract and bring in a coaching director, all whilst nutting out a deal with Justin for 2020 . 

Get Bennett on a 2 year deal whilst still negotiating with Holbrook for 2020 as Benny’s assistant and from 2021 as our head coach . A year working with Bennett would be an excellent kick start for a future coach . if Bennett doesn’t work for 2019 Justin takes over in 2020.

1 the guy bleeds blue and gold.
2 with what the club has put him through deserve to atleast see out his contract
3 this is his first stint as a coach he has the qualities and training to do this for a long time, he has made alot of mkstakes especially recruitment and really need a recruitment team around him how he gkt a roster this bad to play last year was special, parra has enough offcontract and being shopped around to go to market like newcastle did lets see what he does nextseason, fans deserve a good coach who cares about the club.
4 jennings and norman being tapped on the shoulder and the players parra are currently talking to means he is learning

I love when someone says ‘BA bleeds blue n gold’ or ‘he should see out his contract because of the salary Cap debacle’.....

His getting paid to do his job and on reports his getting $1mill to do it!!! Now if he was doing it for free then those above statements I could live with.

His had his time and not everything has worked out the way he would have liked but guess what?? Such is life.

He needs to be sacked!!

We all bleed blue and gold, just because he is a Parra boy and a good bloke doesn't mean he should get any extra special treatment from the club.

Would people be still sticking up for Stuart or Kearney if we were in this position???? 

I agree with the above comments.

I think people are overlooking the fact that coaching is a job, and for that job people get paid, and paid pretty well in the NRL I might add. As a result of that job, a coach will be judged by the success or failure of the team they are coaching.

So BA might bleed blue and gold, and BA might be a top bloke, but that has absolutely nothing to do with whether or not he should be retained as a coach.

The coach can only take responsibility for the teams performance basically off the field.  The inept performances by certain players against Souths was not the fault of the coach. Souths are a top team in both weight and experienced players, the aspect that they scored 8 tries against the eels 5 shows a difference in the overall quality between the two sides.  3 tries difference between the two teams while not good is not that bad.

We need more than one reliable kicker both for goals and for general kicking.  The coach needs to give whoever is in charge of player recruitment and signing a list of players he wants to be signed in order of priority.

Go for Bennet, no way he did ok at Saints but he is a QLD coach and after he left NCLE and Brown tool over its taken several years to clear out his mess.

Bring in Maquire as football manager.

BA  needs to be given the chance to bring in or up the players he wants at the club.

Colin, I think BA is testing out others for back up goal kicking. French was kicking for ages at the open training sesh in Darwin...doing both line dropouts and goals....he only missed one goal out of the tonnes he did from all different areas of the field..so not bad.

you would have seen him doing some of the line dropout kicks against the cows

Amanda, I didn't see the Darwin game, but its good that French is doing a lot of kicking, it actually makes me wonder if he could be better used in the middle in place of Norms?  He's around the same size as MM, but it does mean a near 10kg drop in weight difference to Norms.  I really see the need for more than one player to have the ability to kick for field positions rather than just the one we seem to be employing, meaning its easy to target one player, yet Souths used Reynolds with success as how much pressure was put on him?

I have had a gut full of the dumb plays by Norms after his lashing out and kicking the souths grubber across field (on the last tackle count) that ended up with Souths scoring another try.  He went missing and was wandering around on the outside too often for mine.

My Dad (Roosters fan and used to play for them wayyyyyy back in the day) said he would be interested to see French in the halves...but also likes him for fullback......

he and hayne seem to be working on/testing out some combos with a chip kick..


© 2018   Created by 1Eyed Eel.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service