Replies

  • He hasnt been at his best for a long time. He would be a complete waste of money
  • I hope not; he would not be cheap and tbh a winger? surely Jennings Junior / Hoffman / Aua'va would be ok.

    • Agree.  We have enough players capable of replacing Semi next year, on his day (away from certain others and venues) he is a good player but to me doesn't have enough days in that regard for me.

      Semi is in many ways irreplaceable but having watched a replay of highlights while waiting for a 2 for one dinner at Wyong last night of the Wests game with Semi's try and as great as it was, I believe he could have got it much closer in as once he beat the two players coming across he did advance it but its something that I have noticed a few times.  A small nit pick but was there.

  • Greg Leleisiuao looks the goods to replace.
    • Do you find him attractive?

    • By the sounds of that, a big yes
  •  20eel13: I don't know about a complete wast of money but his performances have been down for some time. He appears to have lost some speed, aka  JH. There are rumours of off field issues that Easts are concerned about. A very last resort at best.

  • Colin Hussey : I think it better that Semi does that rather than try and gain a metre or two extra. He could get injured by the last desperate tackles of the defenders. Most try scores,but not all, put the the ball down early. Semi knows what he is doing. It is up to the goal kickers to come up to the plate.

    • Robert Lloyd, every time any player runs and there is defence around he can get injured, so after 17 minutes in possesion a club could get every player injured and the opposition has no worries about winning, problem though is once the last man standing kicks off and tries to defend, game over.

      Semi had room to move, thankfully his one hand put downs have all been ok.

  • As a Queenslander always happy to see that guy in a blue jersey
This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Snottie Pimpin replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Players Vote Eels No.2 Club, Behind the Panthers
"Is this not just the clubs players rating their own club ? So in other words Penrith players voted themselves the best club? "
33 minutes ago
Coryn Hughes replied to tyler's discussion ANY MORE SIGNINGS???
"They've got a lot of quality kids coming through there system right now and they seem especially within there fowards to have a type that they are targeting.Naufahu Whyte is the next boom front rower coming he'll be up and near that Tino Tapine and…"
2 hours ago
Coryn Hughes replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Players Vote Eels No.2 Club, Behind the Panthers
"Very good to hear.
All we need is a bit of help on the recruitment and development front and results.
 "
2 hours ago
Eli Stephens’s discussion was featured
 

“The Panthers are extremely proud to be number one ranked in this year's RLPA survey (2025), ” Panthers CEO Matt Cameron said as reported by The Australian.
“Our position within the league is a direct reflection of Ivan Cleary's attitude toward…
5 hours ago
More…