You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!
This reply was deleted.
More stuff to read
"Disagree our edge depth is fine. Williams, Kautoga, Tuilagi, Latu, Samrani, Guymer, etc. Plus got Jez, De Stradis, Lokeni, Lewis coming through Flegg.
Need more quality depth in the outisde backs. Russel is fine but after him the rest are crap."
Need more quality depth in the outisde backs. Russel is fine but after him the rest are crap."
"Yeah he is; and would be keen on him."
"I have a feeling we won't be chasing more middles at the moment. With Junior, JDB, Sam, Moretti, Guymer, Williams and Mataele we have a mix of experience and youth. I think more importantly we need to be going after another edge forward because we…"
"Love seeing Bailey and Big Sam back. Think it's telling how far Wiremu has fallen that he's on the bench behind two young guys."
Replies
I don't think having a concussed player on the field is much of an advantage.
Well, if by advantage you mean not having to put up with the massive disadvantage of removing key players and shuffling your team, then I guess it's an advantage. But why should the other team get an advantage just because your player got concussed? Especially if they caused it.
The HIA rule is to protect players' health, not to disadvantage his team. If the player is able to keep playing then that's his business. If he was really concussed he would be a liability.
They didn't gain an advantage, they decided against taking the disadvantage of having to take a player off the field. The player didn't do anything to deserve going off. If one of our key players got a head knock and knew he was ok to play on I would hope we'd cop the fine as well instead of losing him for what could be a pivotal moment of the game.
Every time a player is forced to leave the field for a HIA it has impact on that team. Unde your logic we should leave it to the players and trainers to make that decision and when they get it wrong pay the fine. I think you are not grasping what the NRL are trying to achieve with the concussion tests.
The NRL are just trying to cover their arses. If players didn't want to spend the rest of their lives with health issues they wouldn't be playing professional rugby league.