What is everyone's preferred BBQ meat choice?

So Sunday, to celebrate the start of a new season, i am hosting my mates with a BBQ, pool table, darts and man cave while watching the Vegas matches. Though i am curious for a fun discussion what is everyone else's go to for the BBQ? For me, a piece of Scotch Fillet, seasoned with salt and a BBQ seasoning which consists of mustard seeds, paprika, thyme, garlic and more that i cannot remember, cooked to medium rare to medium, simply devine. All i can say is on a pan cooked same is my death row final meal, it is heavenly. At the moment, since i bulk buy cuts of steaks with my local butcher, i am stuck with NY strip atm as my butcher sold out on whole Scotch Fillets. NY is good, but cannot beat the Scotch Fillet.

Of course, cannot go wrong with sausages, ribs are good too, as well marinated chicken. But also smokers are becoming a thing. My mate hosted Australia Day at his and had a brisket in the smoker along with a BBQ. 

And finally, a drop of golden ale also, with at the moment i have a case of Toohey's New and Coors (American beer) to get through. Both my favourite drops of beer.

Let's go with a debate of what is the go to steak if many of you are steak eaters, and are you doing anything on Sunday for the new season?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I got a smoker last year and hosted Christmas.

    For steaks, I like a good Scotch Fillet or NY Strip. Salt and pepper, nice and simple but I reverse sear mine. In the oven with a probe till almost at temperature then onto a searing hot pan to get that nice crust.

    For smoking I've done brisket, chicken, sausages, pulled pork, short ribs and bacon. Chicken is probably the easiest and simplest. Spatchcock, season, fridge uncovered overnight. Bang it on the smoker for about 3 hours set at 110c. It will be perfectly cooked, juicy and have that great smokey flavour.

    I've also cranked the smoker right up and used it for pizza. Gives you that woodfired look and taste without needing a pizza oven.

    I have a chargriller kamado from Bunnings.

    • Scotch Fillet is to die for honestly, or as American's call it "Ribeye". My Butcher moved from my local area and went about 15mins up the road but gave myself and family a cut of Wagyu as a thank you for shopping with him. It was nice but man is that cut overrated. I would much rather a Scotch Fillet anyday, 10/10 times i'd choose a Scotch Fillet.

      My mate got a smoker as i mentioned, he swears by it, never uses his BBQ anymore. I know a lot of people who have moved towards using smokers over BBQ's, they are very popular now.

      • I just find my smoker more adaptable than a barbecue. I can use it to smoke meat, make bacon, turn the heat up for a charcoal bbq, or really heat it up for pizza.

        My gas bbq could only bbq.

  • I am a lamb chop fan on the bbq.  Keep the marinade simpe (Garlic,Rosemary,salt pepper and rub in some quality olive oil)  and also dont mind a pork sausage on the BBQ.  

    • Yeah not a big lamb chop fan. I don't mind it from time to time on the pan but not a big fan, particularly how expensive they can be.

      Though i am bias towards a steak. Yeah Olive Oil mixed is beautiful. It's what i do with roasts (Lamb or Pork), Salt, Pepper, Garlic Salt and Olive Oil over the top. Beautiful.

  • Good debate 

    Rib eye for me; basic season with rosemary/ pepper and touch of salt. 
    Basic BBQ; wish to invest in a smoker too; and pizza oven although seeing here smoker can be used for pizza seems ok. 
    Im also a snag man; bloke up the coast at Chirtaway Butchers does a huge range of snags...thick ones and varied favours - love a good snag on the BBQ;

    And my wife loves my cooked onions with some basic olive oil and garlic. 

    • Ribeye is the most popular cut in the world, it is for a reason since it is so bloody delicous.

  • My Dads "mock chicken legs" Recipe. Big hit with everyone that's tried them.

    • Maybe could look into a tuducken also?

  • Human

This reply was deleted.

Latest comments

The Captain replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Lol, fair call. Showing my age Pops. With inflation nowadays I'm surprised if we could get a large pizza for $60k.
Hope the shoulder is healing well! Read my response to Daz below too - I think that hits the nail I was trying to hit. I agree Mark…"
4 seconds ago
The Captain replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Lots of people are Responsible for talent scouting. Mark is Accountable. It's the old RACI matrix, and it's why it's built into job descriptions just as it is for Mark.
Kelly Bayer Rosmarin wasn't the one who was personally responsible for…"
2 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Good points Daz,  I do like how they are sitting equal 4th at the moment.
Im not set on whom should be that negotiator, But I do really like how he gets elite talent to sign with him. He is the master of signing the right talent for a rebuild,…"
13 minutes ago
Mat Bo replied to Mr 'BringBackFitzy' Analyst's discussion Eels ask for Sua 2026
"Everyone's mentioning Herbie and forgetting Matt Burton. He'd likely be cheaper, can play centre and 6 and has that bomb that would complement Mitch's kicking game. "
22 minutes ago
LB replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Though I wonder if his negotiation tactics are better than what we currently have. I understand he won't have that appeal being out of the game for over a decade and a half but he was able to talk players into coming. Again could be way off but it…"
25 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Ha Daz, I was hoping you would come into this blog as you have been quiet discerning in your own way about the "scapegoat" theory.....I am happy to apply it anywhere in this very appropriately titled "lament".....Oh there is that Hubris again, "will…"
34 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"No worries, i thought you had some inside scoop Pops, with the player manager angle.  I was hoping to learn something. I was agreeing with you re the last paragraph, just adding my thoughts as well."
37 minutes ago
Blue Eel replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"All true, disrespected the negotiator, disrespected the club. Its always about money and when it isn't , it is but they don't know it.
'Some people earn respect, some command it, some want it and never get it, others never want it and have it in…"
44 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Hi Captain, do you think these Top 3:

Player roster & recruitment
Salary cap
Player contract negotiations

. . . are the same as talent scout? Because after a bunnch of very fair remarks about which I agree, you then say the issue is "the club…"
48 minutes ago
Poppa replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Cappy, you of all people are being disingenous.....receptionist/sub 60k/ year 10
Do you know a bus driver gets in excess of 100k a year now.....my guess would be that MON is probably on around 500k.....after that you could be expecting something…"
52 minutes ago
Prof. Daz replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Blue Eel, your story about Brown and his manager laughing about clauses they had accepted does in fact suggest the negotiator made the wrong call. Fair point. But it also suggests Brown is telling fibs when he says it was not about the money. The…"
1 hour ago
Darren Munro replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓's discussion Parramatta sign Harrison Edwards immediately
"Gee and his our 3rd string hooker? Development club that doesn't give their juniors a go. Good luck he got another chance "
1 hour ago
Poppa replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Bluey, I wrote a long summation in the form of the blog....
You now ask me questions that I cannot answer and make no apologies for same i.e.
How would I know who leads the negotiations and works out the b/w details? I was suggesting unequivalently…"
1 hour ago
Poppa replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"If you were working for me Parra G....the first thing I would say in our corporate planning process would be
"You weren't listening to the message I was sending" i.e
.stop being an apologist for MON and at least agree that he has been poor at best…"
1 hour ago
The Captain replied to Die hard eels Supporter's discussion Just heard on triple M whisper that Eels and Dragons are monitoring the Luke Metcalf situation at the warriors
"You said it!! If Luke Metcalf is the answer, we're asking the wrong question."
1 hour ago
Prof. Daz replied to Poppa's discussion Poppa's Corner: SCAPEGOATS..... A funny thing, you can say it with a cry in your voice!......The Parra Lament
"Richardson was appointed Tigers CEO in December 2023 (interim first 6 months then contracted to July 2028). The Tigers had won the spoon in 2022 and 2023 and they won it again in 2024. So Richardson's first year yielded another spoon. 
Richardson…"
1 hour ago
More…

Keaon done deal

As of Thursday, December 11, 2025, South Sydney Rabbitohs forwardKeaon Koloamatangi has reportedly agreed to a deal with the Parramatta Eels, but it is not yet officially announced by the clubs.  Soon to be announced.

Read more…
14 Replies · Reply by Poppa Jan 9
Views: 2404

 

<script src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<!-- Sidebar -->
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<script>// <![CDATA[
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
// ]]></script>