What is everyone's preferred BBQ meat choice?

So Sunday, to celebrate the start of a new season, i am hosting my mates with a BBQ, pool table, darts and man cave while watching the Vegas matches. Though i am curious for a fun discussion what is everyone else's go to for the BBQ? For me, a piece of Scotch Fillet, seasoned with salt and a BBQ seasoning which consists of mustard seeds, paprika, thyme, garlic and more that i cannot remember, cooked to medium rare to medium, simply devine. All i can say is on a pan cooked same is my death row final meal, it is heavenly. At the moment, since i bulk buy cuts of steaks with my local butcher, i am stuck with NY strip atm as my butcher sold out on whole Scotch Fillets. NY is good, but cannot beat the Scotch Fillet.

Of course, cannot go wrong with sausages, ribs are good too, as well marinated chicken. But also smokers are becoming a thing. My mate hosted Australia Day at his and had a brisket in the smoker along with a BBQ. 

And finally, a drop of golden ale also, with at the moment i have a case of Toohey's New and Coors (American beer) to get through. Both my favourite drops of beer.

Let's go with a debate of what is the go to steak if many of you are steak eaters, and are you doing anything on Sunday for the new season?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • I got a smoker last year and hosted Christmas.

    For steaks, I like a good Scotch Fillet or NY Strip. Salt and pepper, nice and simple but I reverse sear mine. In the oven with a probe till almost at temperature then onto a searing hot pan to get that nice crust.

    For smoking I've done brisket, chicken, sausages, pulled pork, short ribs and bacon. Chicken is probably the easiest and simplest. Spatchcock, season, fridge uncovered overnight. Bang it on the smoker for about 3 hours set at 110c. It will be perfectly cooked, juicy and have that great smokey flavour.

    I've also cranked the smoker right up and used it for pizza. Gives you that woodfired look and taste without needing a pizza oven.

    I have a chargriller kamado from Bunnings.

    • Scotch Fillet is to die for honestly, or as American's call it "Ribeye". My Butcher moved from my local area and went about 15mins up the road but gave myself and family a cut of Wagyu as a thank you for shopping with him. It was nice but man is that cut overrated. I would much rather a Scotch Fillet anyday, 10/10 times i'd choose a Scotch Fillet.

      My mate got a smoker as i mentioned, he swears by it, never uses his BBQ anymore. I know a lot of people who have moved towards using smokers over BBQ's, they are very popular now.

      • I just find my smoker more adaptable than a barbecue. I can use it to smoke meat, make bacon, turn the heat up for a charcoal bbq, or really heat it up for pizza.

        My gas bbq could only bbq.

  • I am a lamb chop fan on the bbq.  Keep the marinade simpe (Garlic,Rosemary,salt pepper and rub in some quality olive oil)  and also dont mind a pork sausage on the BBQ.  

    • Yeah not a big lamb chop fan. I don't mind it from time to time on the pan but not a big fan, particularly how expensive they can be.

      Though i am bias towards a steak. Yeah Olive Oil mixed is beautiful. It's what i do with roasts (Lamb or Pork), Salt, Pepper, Garlic Salt and Olive Oil over the top. Beautiful.

  • Good debate 

    Rib eye for me; basic season with rosemary/ pepper and touch of salt. 
    Basic BBQ; wish to invest in a smoker too; and pizza oven although seeing here smoker can be used for pizza seems ok. 
    Im also a snag man; bloke up the coast at Chirtaway Butchers does a huge range of snags...thick ones and varied favours - love a good snag on the BBQ;

    And my wife loves my cooked onions with some basic olive oil and garlic. 

    • Ribeye is the most popular cut in the world, it is for a reason since it is so bloody delicous.

  • My Dads "mock chicken legs" Recipe. Big hit with everyone that's tried them.

    • Maybe could look into a tuducken also?

  • Human

This reply was deleted.

Latest comments

Axel replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Great read Lurker. Appreciate the effort and also the others who also contributed.The season is around the corner and the excitement is building nicely."
4 minutes ago
EA replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"27 and beyond they will be with Coinakis coming through. Its more of a 26 issue for me."
8 minutes ago
EA replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Yes I know the young hookers coming through the pathways but they are in Jersey Flegg and SG Ball, not even NSW Cup. T
The versatile players JR is reffering to would be Papalii and Hopgood based on the fact they played a bit of 9 last year. Hooker…"
9 minutes ago
ParramattaLurker replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"I also only had Fruit to choose from Mitchy ha ha.
Agreed in your points there, added some additional points and summary I may have missed in my blog. Club is very united from top to bottom right now and it is pleasing to see. Stability and Unity is…"
9 minutes ago
EA replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Mate our third string hooker is Meni Luke who plays most of the year in Ron Massey. He is barely NSW Cup level. I think we can expect a bit higher quality for a third string hooker. I am not expecting some high calbire player.
Hooker would be…"
12 minutes ago
Mitchy replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Michael, the NRL keep propping up Melb IMO, Parra have or should have a v good nursery to choose from and we need to ensure we keep the right ones and coach them well. I feel Melb have been caught up with over the last few yrs tbh"
15 minutes ago
Mitchy replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"EA, its interesting as they never mentioned D/H i thought the same but come away thinking they must be ok with who we have now and plans for 27 and beyond. Ryles I am sure said that we have a good crop coming though over the next4 yrs and to ensure…"
18 minutes ago
Mitchy replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Thanks Lurker, I was also there last night, and you must have got all the food as when I go there i had only fruit to choose from.
Yes you are spot on - Beach to me is a very shrewd guy, seems quiet but knows his stuff. He got an applause at the end…"
19 minutes ago
Poupou Escobar replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Papalii and Hopgood are both decent third choice hookers. Honestly, how good do you expect a third string player to be?"
31 minutes ago
ParramattaLurker replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Ryles expressed many times during the evening that we have a lot of good talent coming through in key positions. Wasn't asked or commented on the hooking rotation and how they will be used however he did comment many times on the verstaility of…"
40 minutes ago
EA replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Yea but my main point is our dummy half position has worse depth than our outside backs espically since Smith & TDS are not 80min hookers."
1 hour ago
The Badger replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Excellent write up Lurker. These sort of event summaries are great for us who can't attend."
1 hour ago
Archie replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Great blog Lurker, thanks for taking the time to wrote it up. Sounds like great things for the future."
1 hour ago
SuperEel 22 replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"The club has got a major focus on match day experience and making CommBank intimidating for the opposition. It was a key talking point at our SGA meeting end of last year. It won't be forcing fans to do anything, but emphasising and building on what…"
2 hours ago
Blue Eel replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Thanks Lurker, a great share mate. Really interesting.
I've got plenty to say about MON, but in the interest of club unity and the need to be positive from now on, i'll suck it up, and say nothing. "
2 hours ago
Adam Magrath replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS
"Fantastic insight, you could sense this was taking place more than 12 months ago. The stance we are taking re Zac Lomax is the culmination of a lot of good work going on at the club. No way would we have done this 2 or more years ago.I'd be…"
4 hours ago
More…

Keaon done deal

As of Thursday, December 11, 2025, South Sydney Rabbitohs forwardKeaon Koloamatangi has reportedly agreed to a deal with the Parramatta Eels, but it is not yet officially announced by the clubs.  Soon to be announced.

Read more…
14 Replies · Reply by Poppa Jan 9
Views: 2060

 

OUR CLUB IS IN GREAT HANDS

I had the opportunity this evening to attend the Members Forum for 2026 which was restricted to about 100 season members of the club and my goodness was it a great evening, a great initative from the club and a great insight in where we are going…

Read more…
28 Replies · Reply by Axel 4 minutes ago
Views: 808

1EE Legends Tipping Comp

The 1 Eyed Eel tipping comp is back for 2026. You can join via this link on ESPN Footy Tips:https://www.footytips.com.au/comps/1ee_legends?p=1eyedeelPassword: 1eyedeelIf you are still in the comp from last season, you don't need to join again.Here…

Read more…
1 Reply · Reply by Gustarny 11 hours ago
Views: 65

Vale Vince Fawcett

I seem to remember him always being on the verge of becoming one of the great UK exports, had a bit of a cult following with Eels fans too.Am I right that he had a blinder for the Eels against GB one night busting the line and scoring a runaway…

Read more…
1 Reply · Reply by KENDOZA on Monday
Views: 415

<script src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<!-- Sidebar -->
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<script>// <![CDATA[
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
// ]]></script>