Replies

  • This is ridiculous, how many times does a man have to front up to court over this.

    I hope it's not chewing up tax payers money.

    • I doubt Hayne was ever on legal aid where the government pays an accused legal fees . Hayne would likely have paid out of his pocket as much as it cost to keep his new legal team going including senior counsels ( SC / QC 's ) for now three trials plus his  appeal to the Court of Appeal.  If he was on legal aid there is a chance the new trials would not have proceeded so as to reduce / eliminate future public legal aid bills for representing him .  

      • Driza, I don't understand how a man that's been found 'guilty' can have another trial to prove he's not guilty?

        • That mean's you don't understand the appeal system JB and why i repeatedly suspect your low intellect.

          • Yes Poppa I don't understand the system totally, I've never been in trouble with the law and neither has anyone close to me.

            I really don't understand how someone can have enough evidence stacked up against them to be convicted but then come back for a re-trial only to be proven not guilty.

            Sounds like a circus to me and a waste of taxpayers money.

            • Surely you have heard of "appeals" JB and again if you had half a brain you would know it was a hung jury the first time and close to it the second time...."enough evidence stacked up" is not relevant if not accepted for any number of reasons, e.g. a court found Cardinal Pell guilty and a team of high court judges dismissed all the charges.

              Maybe it less Bugs Bunny on TV for you JB and one or two of the thousand TV shows that cover the law......if you ever do get caught by the law JB a quick insanity plead should be enough for you along with extracts from IEE under your name.

            • An appeal can ony be granter when evidence is not allowed to be presented in the original trial or evidenve has been found that could impact the original decision.

          • John as you know , fortunately people are no longer burnt to the stake after mere suspicion of practising which craft . A person charged by police ( called the accused or defendant ) is entitled to procedural fairness both during the police investigation and as well during the court process. The procedural fairness owed to him /her during the court hearing ( in Haynes case the court hearing was one of trial by jury ) includes that the trial judge properly instructs the jury as to the lawful way the jury is to weigh up the evidence in determining the accused's guilt or innocence of the charge . In the first trial the jury were not able to arrive at the required majority decision to make a finding of guilty ( i.e. called " a hung jury"  ) in respect of Hayne . 

          In the second trial the required numbers in a different jury of 12 people found Hayne guilty . Hayne thought the second jury's decision was unfair so he used his legal right to appeal to a higher court . Hayne persuaded the court hearing his appeal to both set aside the finding of guilt by the jury as well as Haynes conviction by the court that had followed the jury's decision .(  The reason for the appeal courts decision was I think from memory that the trial judge incorrectly instructed the jury as to the way they should arrive at their decision (meaning Hayne was wrongly convicted and that is why he is entitled to a new trial ) . This requirement for @procedural fairness has been in our legal system since we first inherited from England when the first fleet arrived in 1788 . 

          • Witchcraft sorry not which craft . ( You know riding on a broomstick lol )

        • JB that is why our system is considered one of the most fairest in the land with built in corrections through the whole process.

          For the uninitiated and just for clarity in a nut shell

          1st Trial the jury couldnt agree on guilt 

          2nd Trial - At end of the end of the trial as the Judge explained legal principles to the new jury , These directions are provided to the jury by the judge at the end of a trial and provide guidance on how to apply the law, before they deliberated.  She made statements that were not true about the case. She used phrases that were meant to lead the jury into what they have to consider, her phrases were deemed extreme and had no basis in law. The result was the Jury were mislead by the judge in what they had to consider to find guilt, she basically changed the rules.

          Officailly the Appeal judges found that "Judge Syme's directions to the Jury were so Flawed that it neccesitated the appeal to be allowed" 

          Hope that helps. For the record if you were going away to Jail for an extended time wouldnt you at least want the process to be correct and beyond reproach.

This reply was deleted.

Latest comments

Flow Basket replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"I thought the team was in great shape this season Blair could be a loss "
3 minutes ago
Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Crazy how his girlfriends brother ruined his career 😕 "
4 minutes ago
Flow Basket replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Disappointed joash isn't playing or Dean for whatever reason enjoyed watching there efforts, the team deserves a winning end after turning around the start"
9 minutes ago
Eelawarra replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Here's why Dylan Brown is playing today 
“I’d been thinking about Dylan for a while, and while we were never going to make room for him this last game, the opportunity came up,” Ryles said.

 
“Joash Papalii was booked in for surgery on his wrist,…"
44 minutes ago
Cumberland Eel replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"The Eels should win but the last game they were favourites and should have won they lost. It really depends on what Eels team turns up but if they want to finish the year on a good note and gather momentum for next year then they really need to turn…"
58 minutes ago
Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐 replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Hoping Dunster can somehow come back through the Ron Massy cup and at least be picked up by super league.  Im sure he has good footy left in him"
1 hour ago
parra supporter replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Yep matto and hands just on trial loan deals at present and still contracted for next season and Bailey was given permission to look however the team he was linked to (titans) now will have a new coach which potentially different targets."
1 hour ago
macybrown commented on CarloEEL2’s status
"Same wishes from me Carlo 💛💙 "
1 hour ago
Kurupt - Porn Addict, But I'm In Control replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Union 360 update,
"Don't care, bye."
2 hours ago
macybrown replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Yes just hope they don't think it's in the bag before kick off. 
 "
2 hours ago
macybrown replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Union 360 update,
"What a horrible time for us to be wanting to buy any good experienced first graders. As if Perth wasn't bad enough. They'll all be interested in earning the huge bucks on offer and even use the threat of joining this 'whatever' for more salary.
this…"
2 hours ago
Hector replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"I expect the Knights to come out  and start with all guns blazing we had better be  ready for them  and go with them . It's every things crossed that we don't get ambushed. "
2 hours ago
Richard Jackson replied to Hell On Eels's discussion Game Day Blog R27 v Knights: Momentum Matters (Leo Thompson out)
"Thanks for the tip Joel.  Today the knights are coming...to our house...for a change.
They are motivated to not finish last.    We understand and although still without Ponga and and their injured 5/8, they'll be near full strenght and hoping..
But…"
2 hours ago
Cumberland Eel replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Wouldn't surprise me if the Eels don't turn up but hope not"
2 hours ago
CarloEEL2 replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion Official - Eels to hand chimp Matty Johns & the Newcastle knights the Wooden Spoon Spoon!!!
"Exactly 
he will love the lifestyle , can afford good real estate , the beach , will be hanging out at all the pubs doing his titty runs 
he will be having a ball !!!
better than sweating it out in the western suburbs if you can walk to the beach in…"
2 hours ago
Muttman replied to Eli Stephens's discussion Departures
"Agreed. Just the worst luck. He had some really good moments when he was fit. Good finisher and great hands. "
2 hours ago
More…

Grandson

Hey all,Apologies for any disruptions to the forum but just throwing out how happy I am ATM with a new grandson. First one. As you all know I have had some issues in the past and you have all helped me through. Just wanted to share this moment with…

Read more…
10 Replies · Reply by Joeyboyz Aug 25
Views: 241

NSW Origin Squad 2025

WESTPAC NSW BLUES SQUADAmpol State of Origin, Game OneSuncorp Stadium, Brisbane Wednesday 28 May1. Dylan Edwards (Penrith Panthers)2. Brian To’o (Penrith Panthers)3. Stephen Crichton (Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs)4. Latrell Mitchell (South Sydney…

Read more…
0 Replies
Views: 387

 

<script src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js"></script>
<!-- Sidebar -->
<p>&nbsp;</p>
<script>// <![CDATA[
(adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({});
// ]]></script>