1. Iongi 

2. Fox

3. Russell 

4. Samrami/Penasini 

5. Simmonson 

6. Pezet

7 Mo

8. Jnr 

9 Smith 

10. Williams 

11. Kelma Tuilagi 

12  kit Kautoga 

13. Debelin 

14. Da Silva 

15. Sam Tuivaiti 

16. Walker

17. Doorey 

18. Hopgood 

 

* Kelma did enough and is a strike weapon out wide. Although Williams is a steadier player, i really think Kelma creates opportunities both on and off the ball. He also had a massive pre season as Ryles pointed out.  Without Kelma we don't beat the donkeys 

* Also, i don't know what to do with Hopgood/ Williams fighting it out for a prop rotation position. 

* I think Ryles will opt for Penasini over Samrami if fully fit.  If Samrami is kept at centre i have no issues. 

* The bench must be retained, each of the four turned the tide for the eels in the second half

* Williams & Hopgood.  Williams the player of the year 2025 wont be left outHopgood returns after suspension  - a good headache for Ryles to have having a number of choices 

Debelin/Hopgood.  One of these two will.be left out

 

Some interesting choices 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

        • I won't be happy if Tuivita misses out. He needs to play every game for sure. 

    • Moretti the forgotten man.  Id always have him in the 19 

      • Well to be fair, i see him and Doorey practically being the same player. I feel Moretti is more consistent though.

        • Moretti also had a very good combo with Walker

  • It should be horses for courses, so our bigger middles to play. We have that luxury, so why not use it?

    • Exactly right we have enough versatility to adapt to circumstance.

      I still see Jnr as the pack alpha though there are times during the game where it loosens up to much and he gets exposed.Ruck control is so important in the modern game more so now you just can't have a quick ruck of you'll get run over like we did the first 20-25 last night.

      • Brisbane's play the ball speed was quicker, but later on we got control of the ruck, poking our nose through and getting on our elbows for quick play the balls, Brisbane were out on their feet. Tawha was having a tough time keeping up and Mam suffered for it on that right side. So many times there was opportunities for both Smith and Da Silva to scoot out with markers dropping off to the side.

        We had control for a big portion of the second half and it was quite incredible considering how much work we had to do in the first 25.

        Having that big body in Tuivaiti helped as well. Takes 2-3 to get him down.

  • I dont give a rats about the line up ....this match at Home is a must win ...we will be favorites ...if we dont win the Broncos match is and was a fluke

  • Kelma has deadset played 1 good game and he is in a contract year. If he stays it's because he strings together 10 quality 60+ minute performances, and even then, on a low wage. Can't keep going around in these circles. 

    • Agreed. I won't renew him no matter how well he plays. He was still sketchy yesterday. He is a good impact bench player against tired edges and Moses slipping him balls. 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Randy Handlinger replied to SuperEel 22's discussion State of the Site 2026
"Browny , Dowload and open Brave browser (it is safe). Set 1EE as Homepage and get it to save your login. Only use it to come here and Viola, you have an 1ee app with no intrusions...you won't look back and you're welcome
 
 "
5 minutes ago
Clintorian replied to Parra_Greg's discussion Next Five Weeks at Home
"It was a huge win, massive upset.
McGuire will be copping the knives all week from the media after that one. Which is complete bullshit, but anything to destabilise them after last year is a good thing."
8 minutes ago
Parra_Greg replied to Parra_Greg's discussion Next Five Weeks at Home
"Really shows how important Thursday win was .  Im sure Ryles would take 50% for that road trip"
18 minutes ago
Tin Tim replied to Herbert Hamilton's discussion Fight off spoon again
"Dribbler!"
19 minutes ago
More…