Worst forward pack ever in team history?

Think this pack we rolling out on Sunday is worst in club history?

Paulo slow and old

Smith can't pass from dummy half

Moretti not fit enough to start 

Williams down year from last season

Guymer starting back row first time ever

Walker better off the bench 

Da Silva only good player who is dangerous 

De Belin just way past it

Pryde a making debut

Matale playing his 2nd game

 

Not sure even worth watching game Sunday 

 

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Yes unless you consider the teams that rest the full team and play their nsw cup team at the end of a year.

  • Yeah prob matches what is possibly the greatest amount of injuries we've ever had too.

    Ado, Ryley Paulo Moses carrying some injuries too

    however, walker should be on bench

    • Yeah would start De Belin and have Walker for some impact with tired middle 

  • Just give the Dogs 2 points and call the game off. It's absolutely ludicrous by the NRL to even have this match when most of the regular Eels team is out injured. Any further Eels injuries means Jersey Flegg vs NRL 1st.Grade..So utterly stupid!

    • That has to be the most scariest thing to happen, but could pivot so much in growth of our younger guys. Everything happens for a reason. 

      • Have you ever played footy 101?  I only ask because you don't seem to understand that getting pumped & crushed over & over does not help growth or development.

        I get that you're trying to find a silver lining in this shit-cloud but it's not there dude...it's just shit right through

         

        • Your kinda both right 

          It can be beneficial 2000/2002 panthers blooded a lot of young players before they were ready then added some experience and 03 they were unbeatable 

          That been said if players are getting flogged week in week out then it can just as quickly end their career

  • Smith is playing injured and we don't have anybody in cup to give him a rest

    • I pointed this out in pre-season but people like Poppa thought I was wrong lol

  • I agreed 

    Paulo  -  not going well. 5/ 10 this year

    Smith - looks smaller gets dominated in defence 

    Williams  - isn't a prop

    Kautoga  - looks lazy in defence . Jury still out

    Kelma  - reserve grader. Release him now

    Walker - bench  is a must

    Sam Tuivaiti  - our best go forward,  yet he can speak to clubs in November  - unbelievable  mark o'neill the biggest dope in history 

    Moretti  -  looks lighter and minimal impact 

    Da Silva  - i like him. Future captain 

    Doorey  - too injury prone.  Not worth keeping 

    Hopgood  - big heart but not a prop

     

    Trained by tge Newcastle spoon 🥄  winning head trainer,  who previously coached at the Tigers failure.   Well done to Sarantinos and O’Neill 

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

EA replied to EA's discussion Loko Pasifiki Tonga requests immediate release
"Yep there are so many with similar potential with the players we have named. Polley and Bell were probably my next two on my list. I just want to see how they both go in u19/JF footy against the more physical and developed kids. Seuseu is so…"
2 minutes ago
Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin🐐 - Mark O'neill's 🪓 replied to Yeah Man's discussion Worst forward pack ever in team history?
"I agreed 
Paulo  -  not going well. 5/ 10 this year
Smith - looks smaller gets dominated in defence 
Williams  - isn't a prop
Kautoga  - looks lazy in defence . Jury still out
Kelma  - reserve grader. Release him now
Walker - bench  is a must
Sam…"
3 minutes ago
Sonic Boom replied to EA's discussion Loko Pasifiki Tonga requests immediate release
"Mine would be Bell, Seuseu, Petrus, Lorenzo, Polley.
In saying that there are prob 15-20 outside of the 5 that are just as promising but if i had to pick 5 based off my time watching
 "
6 minutes ago
Sonic Boom replied to EA's discussion Loko Pasifiki Tonga requests immediate release
"100% i had rated this guy way higher than Tuivaiti coming out of the jnrs (in saying that Sam has exceeded my expectations since). Still a blue chip talent to add to the squad"
12 minutes ago
More…