The Rugby League Eye Test released its mid-season report todasy and calculated Top and Bottom 20 players for player contribtion.
In the Bottom 20 list, Penisini sits . . . 3rd (worst). Luckily the resident 1Eyedeel Recruitment & Retention Experts were around to lambast the club for not paying overs for Sean Russell, because he sits . . . 5th (worst). Of course the next centre/winger up for the Eels has been Brian Kelly, who sits . . . 9th (worst). Those outside backs are all in good (well, I guess we mean bad) company, because some of our forwards who have played on the edges feature highly (lowly?) too: Williams 2nd (worst), Kautoga 12th (worst).
If it's any consolation for Moses bloody-well-again going into Origin and not making it out healthy (this time not even playing a game), his replacement Ethan Strange sits . . . 1st (worst).
So, um, like, if Penisini is off to Warriors and Russell to Bears, this means the Eels Recruitment & Retention team have just scored a coup, dispensing of the worst centre combination in the league?!
So Daz, your attack on posters with criticisms of R&R is identifying quite a few Eels players - who have been recruited or retained by the Eels - as amongst the worst in the league for contribution to their team?
And your closing statement is by losing Russell, and possibly Penisini, two players the Eels have spent years & money retaining & developing into the 'worst centre pairing in the league', this would be a coup for the R&R team?
While also ignoring players who have left the Eels system and are having good to great seasons elsewhere?
two players the Eels have spent years & money retaining & developing into the 'worst centre pairing....hmmm, perhaps not the flex Daz thought it was...he is determined to defend the status quo in head office...just like Hoe
I got a "Mod note" for wryly asking Daz if he was on the payroll and another for replying to him "'dis you MoN?"...I was taking the piss but damn it knotted some knickers & raised some surprisingly hairy hackles....probs another missive inbound for this one.
Some of the points made sit in a bin of self justification....
R&R sits with who again?
Now Russell looked really good last year and we were all disappointed to lose him to Perth, that doesn't stop the current judgements, but it is handy.
Will Penisini is/was a project, he started this year fitter and faster and has ended up a cripple, as Tim Robbin's said in Shawshank.... "I find that considerably inconvenient"
Williams our best player last year, has had a pretty shit season, Kautonga for all his promise has not delivered, Taulaiga fits in the same boat, players like Kelly was a nasty after thought, JAC and Moses have played mostly injured, our fullback most of the season, Doory season, Simmosson season, throw in a half dozen others out for 4 to 6 weeks and yes R&R have really fcuked up. Pezet turned out a wrong call!
I think you will find a lot of cynisism in various people adjudging this disaster of a year....but I feel there is a reasonable amount of "mitigation" I say reasonable, but it is also factual, original opinions held by some protaganists notwithstanding......I don't know much about the physcology of "lynch mobs" but I would be interested to know what is the turning point between rational and irrational.
In the interim I will continue to live in my glass house and when someone actually throws a stone that justifies breakage, I will probably join that lynch mob!
"That's the balance NOS. Having the quality to be competitive and bring juniors along, but also not blocking the paths of those juniors. It would be great to get a world class middle for 3-4 years but also do we lose someone like Tuivaiti, Brown,…"
"My post on Will Penisini GONE
R&R sits with who again?
Now Russell looked really good last year and we were all disappointed to lose him to Perth, that doesn't stop the current judgements, but it is handy.
Will Penisini is/was a project, he started…"
Replies
Warriors going great atm. Why would they want to dampen that by signing will penisini?.
The Rugby League Eye Test released its mid-season report todasy and calculated Top and Bottom 20 players for player contribtion.
In the Bottom 20 list, Penisini sits . . . 3rd (worst). Luckily the resident 1Eyedeel Recruitment & Retention Experts were around to lambast the club for not paying overs for Sean Russell, because he sits . . . 5th (worst). Of course the next centre/winger up for the Eels has been Brian Kelly, who sits . . . 9th (worst). Those outside backs are all in good (well, I guess we mean bad) company, because some of our forwards who have played on the edges feature highly (lowly?) too: Williams 2nd (worst), Kautoga 12th (worst).
If it's any consolation for Moses bloody-well-again going into Origin and not making it out healthy (this time not even playing a game), his replacement Ethan Strange sits . . . 1st (worst).
So, um, like, if Penisini is off to Warriors and Russell to Bears, this means the Eels Recruitment & Retention team have just scored a coup, dispensing of the worst centre combination in the league?!
So Daz, your attack on posters with criticisms of R&R is identifying quite a few Eels players - who have been recruited or retained by the Eels - as amongst the worst in the league for contribution to their team?
two players the Eels have spent years & money retaining & developing into the 'worst centre pairing....hmmm, perhaps not the flex Daz thought it was...he is determined to defend the status quo in head office...just like Hoe
I got a "Mod note" for wryly asking Daz if he was on the payroll and another for replying to him "'dis you MoN?"...I was taking the piss but damn it knotted some knickers & raised some surprisingly hairy hackles....probs another missive inbound for this one.
Some of the points made sit in a bin of self justification....
R&R sits with who again?
Now Russell looked really good last year and we were all disappointed to lose him to Perth, that doesn't stop the current judgements, but it is handy.
Will Penisini is/was a project, he started this year fitter and faster and has ended up a cripple, as Tim Robbin's said in Shawshank.... "I find that considerably inconvenient"
Williams our best player last year, has had a pretty shit season, Kautonga for all his promise has not delivered, Taulaiga fits in the same boat, players like Kelly was a nasty after thought, JAC and Moses have played mostly injured, our fullback most of the season, Doory season, Simmosson season, throw in a half dozen others out for 4 to 6 weeks and yes R&R have really fcuked up. Pezet turned out a wrong call!
I think you will find a lot of cynisism in various people adjudging this disaster of a year....but I feel there is a reasonable amount of "mitigation" I say reasonable, but it is also factual, original opinions held by some protaganists notwithstanding......I don't know much about the physcology of "lynch mobs" but I would be interested to know what is the turning point between rational and irrational.
In the interim I will continue to live in my glass house and when someone actually throws a stone that justifies breakage, I will probably join that lynch mob!
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 5 Next