Coach: Brad Arthur. Keep but needs a good assistant coach.
Captain: We need an intelligent captain
FB: Jarryd Hayne. Keep. Toughness has improved this year. Now needs to improve commitment/involvement.
Justin Hunt. Go.
W: Semi Radradra. Keep. Needs to improve to be FG quality – especially defense.
Ken Sio: Go (deserves to be renewed but need to make strategic decision). Our best winger but should be overtaken soon by Radradra, Goodall and/or Lavaka
C: Willie Tonga. Go/gone
Will Hopoate. Keep. Expensive for a centre but is a good role model gets him over the line.
Ryan Morgan. Go.
Vai Toutai. Go.
Bureta Faraimo. Go
Israel Folau. No. Too expensive for a centre. FB only but Hayne won’t move to 5/8.
H. Corey Norman. Go. May improve next year but does not look like he will ever be a top 5/8.
Luke Kelly. Go.
Chris Sandow. Hold. I love how he plays but it is not working at Parra for him. He is our only attacking option other than Hayne, would let him go for DCE.
Api Pewhairangi. Go. I can’t spell his name.
Hooker: Nathan Peats. Keep. Will his body ever last the season when he gives 200%.
Isaac De Gois. Go. He used to run.
Props: Tim Mannah. Keep
Darcy Lussick. Go. Can’t keep him at the price unless he learns to bend the line and offload.
Junior Paulo. Keep. Is a bench prop ATM.
David Gower. Keep. Says something when he can’t get a game or renewed at Manly but is one of our most skillful and committed forwards. Bench prop.
Lee Mossop. Go. Looks like a good starting prop but just one shoulder.
Allgood. Keep. Improved a lot this year and for the price a good bench or back-up.
Peni Terepo. Wenty until he improves defense and mistake rate.
Kelepi Tanginoa. Keep.
Fui Fui Moi Moi. Go. Was fantastic.
Lorenzo Ma’afu. Wenty.
Lock: Joseph Paulo. Go.
Back row: Manu Mau. Keep.
Kenny Edwards. Keep unless returns to old ways.
Tepai Moeroa. Keep. Need to do what it takes to sign him forever.
Pauli Pauli. Great potential but has a lot to learn. Bench only.
Ben Smith . Go.
Replies
There are other qualifiers too
For example if the player can improve or be coached to improve e.g. If Darcy could bend the line and offload he would be worth the money and a definite keeper
Just thoughts I got off my chest after the warriors embarrassment
Not suggestions for immediate actions