I have been trying to identify the malaise that is eating the innards of Parramatta Rugby League. Previously, I suggested that the poor performance of our lower grades is a symptom of that malaise--a symptom, not the cause of the malaise. Another symptom closer to the cause, I believe, is the $20,000 fine imposed for failure to comply with the concussion guidelines instituted by the NRL. How did that happen? Brad Arthur said he had clearance from the medical staff for Nathan Peats to resume playing. But the fine was imposed because not enough time was allowed for Peats to recover. Five minutes is demanded by the guidelines. So, who should keep that time? I don`t think that the doctor should be a timekeeper. His attention should be solely be on the medical condition of the players. Likewise, I don`t think that Brad Arthur could or should be the time keeper. His attention is on the team`s performance and he is nowhere down where the injured players are. So again, who should keep that time?
I would suggest that Daniel Anderson should have that duty. I don`t think that he is overstretched in responsibilities on game day. It is clear that if Brad Arthur should know concussion guidelines, and he should, then Daniel Anderson should know them equally well because he is the Head coach. In his response to the NRL on this matter our CEO ,SS , said that procedures are now in place preventing such a situation occurring again. Which seems to confirm that nobody had that responsibility at the Warriors game.Is this then the cause of the malaise fundamentally effecting the Eels? That is does everyone know their position in the organisation? Do they know their duties in that organisation. Should not that have been established long before now.? Should have been done by the CEO as part of his duties? It does not seem to have been done in the case of the concussion guidelines, costing a $ 20,000 fine. Who is responsible for that?
On another matter. It was reported in the Sun- Herald today that Sam Burgess had failed as a centre in Rugby Union in England and is now playing second row for his team Bath. I thought Sam would have no trouble succeeding in Union. That he appears not to have done so must, in my opinion, point to some external factor or factors contributing to his predicament. Homesickness comes to mind. Missing his family. The class nature of Rugby Union in England and even the warm beer and cold pies that the mob consume in that demi-paradise. Could be a chance for our brilliant administration to entice Sam to where the eels lie down?
Replies
I've been seeing articles and videos for a while now, showing Sam is not up to it. It's hard to believe isn't it? He's been playing short stints off the bench. I wouldn't say it's home sickness, so much as missing his family and being the star player in the best team in the NRL.
The Australian Union coach reckons Sam will be chosen for the world cup, but after that he may return to the NRL for next year. I don't think he would be blocked from an early release if he can't even make the starting team. Might free up some money for Bath too.
Gower Power, I am with you there. I always thought that a league player could run backwards and still succeed in union. Like to see him back playing league somewhere.