Top 6 Dirtiest NRL Players

As its the 'Off Season' I thought I'd start with what players that you would consider to be in the 'Top 6' Grubbiest / Dirtiest Players in the N.R.L. Mine are:

1) Russell Packer

2) Nate Myles

3) Cameron Smith

4) Billy Slater

5) Josh McGuire

6) Nelson Asofa Solomona

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

    • Agree

  • Malcolm Reilly, Rod Reddy, James Graham, Les Boyd, Adrian Morley . Blokes like Rex Mossop and Noel Kelly were tough but were only sent off for punching, no knees, biting, head butts or elbows..

  • Dallas Donelly, Les Boyd, Adrian Morley, Hoppa, Greg Bird, Jason Stevens

     

  • Ennis 

  • Hopoate

  • Hopoate with his finger in bum poking lol I guess he had to dig his fingers in to remember what number tackle they were on 

  • Rod Reddy, Graeme Wynn, Chris Close, Justin Hodges, Felise Kaufusi and Josh McGuire. 

    Many options to choose from, it's hard to confine it to just six.

    • Agree hard to limit it to 6. 

  • Ian Randall

    Bob Cooper

    Tommy Smith

    Tom Raudonikos

    Les Boyd

    Rod Reddy

  • I won't repeat the names that have got a fair run on here already but James Maloney and Josh Reynolds deserve a mention,  as does Mick Crocker, Anthony Watmough and Steve Matai. 

    Chris Sandow, Todd Carney and  Cody Walker would make the cut too.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Prof. Daz commented on Hell On Eels's event R11 v Storm: Saturday Night, Magic Round
"Which record is better in the Jason Ryles era? Their start to 2025, or their start to 2026? Relatively speaking, as each is a losing record with 2x 50+ thrashings.
Eels in Rounds 1-10 of 2025 Win-Loss (2-7):
- Games: 18-56 (Storm), 6-32 (Tigers),…"
3 minutes ago
sloth replied to Parra fan on The Hill's discussion Parra Juniors- Sanders v Talagi versing
"Talagi has been great in the Penrith system, but to be 100% honest I doubt we would have developed him as well if he stayed.
Our team defense is already shocking and Talagi would've been an easy target for the opposition."
1 hour ago
TolEllts replied to Parra fan on The Hill's discussion Parra Juniors- Sanders v Talagi versing
"Unfortunately, BA was coaching with vested interest with Jake and Matt career in his mind."
1 hour ago
Mitchy replied to Aj's discussion Jonah Pezet
"He plays 5/8 or half for me when he is back; he only played a few games and yes did not start good but his game against Brisbane was good. He will get better; as for the discussion around his contract does not matter now; he is ours for the season."
1 hour ago
More…