With the Eels possibly in the market for a quality five eighth I have been thinking about past #6 signings and the huge hopes us fans had . Adam Dykes came to the Eels with massive expectations. Unfortunately it didn't work. Another massive signing was Kieran Foran and for different reasons that didn't go well. I guess we could say the Jason Smith and Jim Dymock signings worked out successful, however, those signings were related to the ARL - Super League war. I have probably missed a few more horror five eighth signings. I guess the times have changed from when I was playing junior league. As a kid, players like Brett Kenny, Wally Lewis and Terry Lamb had most kids wanting to wear the #6. These days you rarely see the best juniors playing five eighth. Half-back, fullback and Hooker have become the glamour positions. From the early 80's and into the 90's your best attacking player was generally your five eighth. Now that player is usually at fullback. Today's five eighths aren't even your best ball players. These players are at half-back and if you have a second ball player he will be either hooker or lock.
Replies
If there is one thing Joash has over a whole bunch of NRL players, it is passion and energy. Kid is an absolute goer. If he is not to be our 6 moving forward, he ain't going to lose the job without giving 110%
Assuming Joash's defence issues are now qualified, there is no doubt he has all the attacking skils in front of him.
I would like to point out what i mean in saying that. Different horses but same courses, Reed Mahoney is an inferior player to Rylie Smith because Reed can only go low or he gets trampled on, Rylie can stand in a tackle attempt against the biggest of players....is a rare feat of upper body strength for a much smaller man.
Dyllan Brown had the same strength skils not withstanding his perfect cover tackle technique when required. if Joash can develop those same capabilities then he will be just as effective as DB and in a timing sense be the perfect replacement for Dyllan.
I still believe DB was burnt out, whether he recovers after a break and (assuming) he doesn't get picked in the NZ side for the upcoming tests is yet to be seen. The seezun just gone confirms to me that DB's best is behind him, for his sake I hope I am wrong.
This is kind of why the Brown thing pissed me off. He could have said last year he didn't want to enact his option and we could have offered Blaize a clear first grade path. As I understand it, the Talagis have maintained a good relationship with the club and there was no falling out there. The fact we re-signed Ryda shows that.
Got a point he knew BA was gone well before the end of 2024. So not like he wanted to see what happened to BA and who the coach was going to be.
We can blame Oneill for this , much to somes disgust, some of highlighted the huge issues with Browns options at the time.
How do you know that O'Neill had anything to do with Brown's options, actually worked well if he did. Which course/path would you like to follow little Wizzie. You can lose both ways, but you have shown recently that is not uncommon for you!
SuperEel 22 I don't believe DB ever wanted or even planned to leave notwithstanding the option. The killer blow was the offer just to good to believe and he virtually had to accept it.
Where this worked so well for us is we did not get lumbered with Blaize and Dyllan had burnt out, could not have worked out better. Nothing special about what Blaize is doing at Penrith other than being an example of how to develop a player in an environment of no better alternatives.
Question if people on here had a choice of two of the following 3 players, who would you choose, Blaize, Casey McLean or Joash....... I would take Casey and Joash with daylight to third.
Bring back Corey Norman 😂
I heard some interesting comments from Matty Johns regarding five eighth play that might help Papali'i. His comments were about Darren Lockyer and how he struggled when he first moved from fullback to five eighth. He was saying that Lockyer was playing too fast when he first moved. After a while he changed his game by slowing down his play. Fullbacks generally play fast looking for space, whereas five eighths do better slowing down and making defenders commit to them so it provides space for their attacking support players. The really good ball players have the ability to play slow yet they appear to have all the time in the world. Im not sure I've seen enough of young Papali'i to know if he has this in his game at this stage. The young half-back at the Dolphins is the best example in the game now of playing slow and fast when needed.
Good points!
-
1
-
2
-
3
-
4
-
5
of 7 Next