Talin da Silva's knock on

The ref ruled it a 20m restart cause de silva kicked it dead after he knocks on. That was the second infringment though should it  not just be a knock on?

You need to be a member of 1Eyed Eel to add comments!

Join 1Eyed Eel

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Yes, but it's Sutton and he makes a lot of mistakes lol 

  • Yeah was weird, I bet if it went over the sticks he wouldn't have ruled it a field goal. 

  • Seems like a blatant error to me.

     

  • Yeah, ref got it wrong. We'd burnt our challenge. 

    It's weird to me how the bunker tips the ref they've made a mistake sometimes, but not others

  • Correct. 

  • My understanding of the rule is that after a knock on the ball is still live. The attacking team can regather possession to kill the ball. But after tallym kicked the ball, it was still live until it went dead in goals. I believe it was the correct call

    • Interesting. Does that mean if he did the same thing on our 20m line and kicked it into the Storm's half, that it would be play on unless a Parra player regains possesion? I can't see it happening.

    • I believe If the team that knocks it on touches the ball the play is dead. There is another rule book that states if it is knocked on and goes out either dead ball line or sideline it is a scrum from the knock on.

      • That's what i would of thought.

         

  • No its the correct call.

    If a player kicks it dead after the error it is moved to a restart.

    This is a correct call it was brought in a few years ago to stop slowing of the play.

This reply was deleted.

More stuff to read

Adam Magrath replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion VEGAS - HERE WE COME !!!! & its not the Storm !
"Randy, google "shingles vaccine dementia""
1 hour ago
Clintorian replied to ParramattaLurker's discussion Round 3 Team List v St George Illawarra Dragons
"It might not be a permanent move LB, the game is starting fast this season and Ryles needs to react to this change. This is a much more mobile pack to compete with the Dragons young pack. This is smart strategy and being agile in their team…"
7 hours ago
Clintorian replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion VEGAS - HERE WE COME !!!! & its not the Storm !
"My man 👌"
7 hours ago
Randy Handlinger replied to Cʜɪᴇғy Mclovin 🐐's discussion VEGAS - HERE WE COME !!!! & its not the Storm !
"Not true. Iranian oil in chinese tankers has been and is transiting."
7 hours ago
More…